List Mgmt. 2022 Trade & List Management Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
It'd be hard to imagine there's enough money that would lure anyone to * right now.

The coaching and off field shambles, the looming shadow of Sheedy ready to blow s**t up again and then the possibility of Hird returning.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

That’s what I can’t get my head around either. They don’t have a coach and are conducting a review. Don’t know what would entice someone to go there. They should be struggling to hold onto to players. Merrett and Hurley both pretty much said it hasn’t been a good environment throughout their careers.

Plus he’d have to play with Stringer.
 
He's OK. And yeah, I'd have him. There's limits to what you pay OK within the salary cap though.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk
Of course, but he as a target is what I would consider responsible list management. Right age, fills a need and hypothetically doesn't cost too much in cap or capital. Given the fairly modest offer from Carlton, an extra 50 or 100k a year would be good work from us
 

Log in to remove this ad.

There's obviously a hell of a lot of smoke around a few players at the moment.

This looms like being probably our biggest trade period just about ever if there's any truth to Scott, Zurhaar and Thomas.

It's all relative to what some of these players would be worth, but would you trade Thomas for the Rankine pick and by extension for Cadman as an example from a list balance perspective?

I would consider it.

And I say that as someone who was absolutely adamant that Thomas was now our best player 6 months ago seeing him in pre-season, his disintegration is really concerning and despite people making excuses for him, most of it seems off field relegated and there was evidence of it from before his ribs and grandmother.

Zurhaar is absolutely critical to our scoring, but again, I feel like im far more at peace with these rumours than I would have been 12 months ago with Clarko now here.

If there's players that don't want to be here, that's fine, just as long as we can extract maximum value. If Cam decides to go, transferring him into another pick in the first dozen wouldn't be a disaster.
 
North
Picks 1, 2 (p.p), 19 (p.p), 55, 66

Trade Zurhaar to * for pick 4 and we give 19 in return

Trade Thomas to GCS for pick 5 (their pick for Rankine

Waltz into the draft with picks 1,2,4 and 5.


Party Dancing GIF by Florida Georgia Line
 
Josh Corbett's name came up on the trade bell. Was being scouted by a recruiting team. Kicked 4.4 from 25 disposals and 17 marks.

Would Clayton and team have gone up to watch him?


 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

There's obviously a hell of a lot of smoke around a few players at the moment.

This looms like being probably our biggest trade period just about ever if there's any truth to Scott, Zurhaar and Thomas.

It's all relative to what some of these players would be worth, but would you trade Thomas for the Rankine pick and by extension for Cadman as an example from a list balance perspective?

I would consider it.

And I say that as someone who was absolutely adamant that Thomas was now our best player 6 months ago seeing him in pre-season, his disintegration is really concerning and despite people making excuses for him, most of it seems off field relegated and there was evidence of it from before his ribs and grandmother.

Zurhaar is absolutely critical to our scoring, but again, I feel like im far more at peace with these rumours than I would have been 12 months ago with Clarko now here.

If there's players that don't want to be here, that's fine, just as long as we can extract maximum value. If Cam decides to go, transferring him into another pick in the first dozen wouldn't be a disaster.
I think that all three will stay at North
 
Josh Corbett's name came up on the trade bell. Was being scouted by a recruiting team. Kicked 4.4 from 25 disposals and 17 marks.

Would Clayton and team have gone up to watch him?
Far from the worst idea I've seen thrown around here. Can play a bit and is surplus to requirements at GC. Wouldn't want to give up too much for him though.
 
Far from the worst idea I've seen thrown around here. Can play a bit and is surplus to requirements at GC. Wouldn't want to give up too much for him though.

I agree wouldn't be against this. Would be a good 3rd option up forward, played some good footy this year when he was in the side. Certainly a good competitor
 
Apparently Dunkley to Bris is real.
Their list management needs to be commended if they end up getting him.
Neale and probably Dunkley for a single first rounder is insane.
 
Apparently Dunkley to Bris is real.
Their list management needs to be commended if they end up getting him.
Neale and probably Dunkley for a single first rounder is insane.

They could offer this and next first rounder with absolutely no sniff of regret, they need to lose this years anyway and they still sit with this years best kid in the draft. Extraordinary stroke of luck.
 
It'd be hard to imagine there's enough money that would lure anyone to * right now.

The coaching and off field shambles, the looming shadow of Sheedy ready to blow s**t up again and then the possibility of Hird returning.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

Leave Shifty Sheedy out of this please, he will right the ship. He is very similar to the Cpt of the Voyageur Drunken Duncan Herbert Stevens.

Or DD as he was referred to by those aboard.

Fun fact my mates dad was on the Melbourne carrier that ill-fated evening. Old Blinky Al as I call him, something to do with his time in Vietnam made him blink a lot.

He hates conflict and yeah he use to be made man the 50 cal when they pulled over small fishing vessels.

Oh well.
 
They could offer this and next first rounder with absolutely no sniff of regret, they need to lose this years anyway and they still sit with this years best kid in the draft. Extraordinary stroke of luck.
All while getting decent compensation back for mcstay and probably others in their VFL program.
We're so far behind its not funny.
 
We should veale deal for rankine, if the want Thomas they can trade for a lower pick and not deal with Adelaide
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top