Game Day 2022 Trade Period Match Thread

[Snuffaluphagus]

Thanks for making this an awesome trade period peeps. Will be locking this thread later tonight

 

[Spirit Level]

On topic, why would we not start negotiations off at first and F2?

He's uncontracted ffs

 

[Cobbler]

On topic, why would we not start negotiations off at first and F2?

He's uncontracted ffs

Probably did. Not like today would’ve been first chats held.

 

[Dockernut]

Sorry, I just still don’t get this trade. The guy’s out of contract, moved back to WA, only wants to play for us, has had little interest (or scope for interest) from the Weags and we’re shaping up to pull our pants down and say “have at it”?

****en dumb.

 

[wakojako]

Freo have loaded up on enough early draft picks these last few years, don't think missing a year or two of them will hurt too much.

True but we have not loaded up on enough forwards at the draft, only through trade. There are some solid WA forwards next year but more importantly, Kozzie or Naughton may be on the market. Losing our F1 automatically takes us out of the race.

 

[Grape Bear]

Historically, it seems like it’s always the club that loses the marquee player that wins the trade. this Jackson trade has shemozzle written all over it.

 

[tonygeeks]

Surely we send a Bakers Hill pie along with the two first rounders?

Send em a loaf of fruit toast and a jar of Vegemite

That should confuse the campaigners so much they are in a very vulnerable state at the trade table

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

Denmark and mount barker are good.

Haven’t really found a go to in perth.

Mt Barker rates v.high.

I also like Bred Cafe in Albany. Their pies are great but even better is their bread: the fruit and nut sourdough loaf is unreal. They grow their own wheat at Kendenup, then mill and bake in Albany.

 

[Silversurfer]

I’ve gotten on board most quintessential Aussie food since I’ve gotten here, but Vegemite is a bridge too far. Meat pies on other hand, I would consider having a coronary for. Where’s the best?

Small asian bakery in Northampton...Increadable chicken pies...so worth the drive.

 

[holybishop]

So picks 13 and 18. Sounds fair to me

 

[BeinPurplenGreen]

Any chance we somehow still keep Logue?

Maybe he suddenly realises vegemite, anchovies and pan fried brussels sprouts on toast is the breakfast of champions?

 

[Dayts]

You make it sound like list managers don’t lie.
Freo weren’t trading for hogan was traded to them 2 days later.
Neale wasn’t getting trade

I’d wait till next Wednesday before you get on your high horse champ

Lighten up, Francis…
Making some fun on a slow day

But if you think Lobb is getting traded

 

[Sewell21]

Thought I’d have a go at be David Walls for a day. Here is a suggestion of how we can end up with Jackson and Round 1 picks in both 2022 and 2023.

Logue & Tucker to North for 2023 PP2, 2023 PP3 [Unfortunately we are not getting more given how the compo picks worked out]
Meek, 2023 PP3, F3 to Hawthorn for 24 & 50 [values Meek at 47]
13 & F1 & 2023 PP2 to Melb for Jackson, 33 & 42 [gets them 2 x R1, plus a pick for Grundy and overall values Jackson at pick 3]
24, 33 & 42 (1743 points) to Brisbane for F1, F3 [with their own R2 this will get them 2285 which is close enough to the 2300 needed for Ashcroft. They can use points from McStay for Fletcher as their other father-son]

Then;
Lobb and 50 to Western Bulldogs for 15 (which they will get from Brisbane) [values Lobb at pick 23]
Acres to Carlton for F3
Carlton F3 & Bris F3 to GC for Sharp & Corbett [points for their 2023 Academy players]

2022 Draft
Pick 15, 70, + Round 5 picks as needed

2023 Draft
Brisbane F1(15), F2, F3, F4

Done. Bring on draft day.

 

[theGav56]

We have been the Trade Week winners the last 3 go arounds of it, feel like this year we may just break even.

Optimist.

 

[Nodgey]

I don't like that Jackson deal. But I accept, it's out of my hands - as a mere BigFooty spectator sat comfortably numb in my ivory tower crying endlessly into the wilderness of irrelevance; it is accepted a fate as what it's been touted for a while now.

Clearly our football club REALLY rates Jackson as some enigmatic missing piece of the jigsaw, so I hope for their sake and the frail sanity of the mob here, it's a deal worth its weight in salt. After Hogan's complete implosion based off another risky and high-costing trade (with the same club no less!) I really just don't feel easy about it, but....anyway. It'll be what it'll be.

We better hope we don't go backwards, because a price that high needs justification and the pitchforks are probably already getting stropped in the clean midnight glow.

I wonder if we could extract a 2023 first off Bullies for Lobb and some other chump change/s if the draft next year is as higher valued as others have said..?!

Liked for the comfortably numb reference

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

2 teen picks for a 20 year old former #3 who is a tall that has already played 50 games is hardly getting reemed.

Richmond just gave up 2 teen picks for a fomer #2 that is an average size midfielder (probably the most common type of high end footballer) who has already played half his career with average career stats.

 

[Quokka]

Yeah I'd be happy enough with our two firsts for Jackson and a second coming back, expect it will be worse.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

2 teen picks for a 20 year old former #3 who is a tall that has already played 50 games is hardly getting reemed.

Richmond just gave up 2 teen picks for a fomer #2 that is an average size midfielder (probably the most common type of high end footballer) who has already played half his career with average career stats.

Very Harsh on Taranto, he has shown ability to play quality forward minutes as well as being an excellent ball winner. Tbh I'd probably take him over Jackson if I had the choice.

 

[Hazelsnuts]

Mt Barker rates v.high.

I also like Bred Cafe in Albany. Their pies are great but even better is their bread: the fruit and nut sourdough loaf is unreal. They grow their own wheat at Kendenup, then mill and bake in Albany.

Finally subject matter I am really passionate about.
Kulin butcher - bakes the best Steak and Guinness pie.
Esperance- Lunchbox in the LIA - Skye does old school Savoury Mince Toasties and on Thursdays the best Seafood jaffle Pie you have ever wrapped ya gems around.
Scarborough- Viet Cong/Brighton Road Bakery- Chilli Steak with bird’s eye chillies.
Mingenew bakery - Lamb and tzatziki roll.

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

Very Harsh on Taranto, he has shown ability to play quality forward minutes as well as being an excellent ball winner. Tbh I'd probably take him over Jackson if I had the choice.

I think he is a good footballer and we would find room for him in our B22!!!

So his trade price is fair. But he has already played a fair amount of footy. And good six-foot-two midfielders are pretty damn common.

Tall kids who play decent footy at a young age are less common and deserve some premium. So my thinking is is two teen picks is also reasonable for Jackson.

 

[Paracleet]

Porterhouse in a stew? With the price of meat these days the Taylor household must be doing pretty well!

Forget the price surely it's wasted? Stew porterhouse and it's leather.

 

[SlipperySlipperyPete]

Starting to see a lot more out there around West Coast actually having a go at getting Jackson.

Is this legit or just a tactic to try and make Freo pay up?

I don’t want us to pay massive overs for him, I think our 1st round this year and next is reasonable, could prove to be overs but also he could be a really unique star.

I would be disappointed if he does go to the eagles after being projected as coming here all season long.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Dockeroo]

Thought I’d have a go at be David Walls for a day. Here is a suggestion of how we can end up with Jackson and Round 1 picks in both 2022 and 2023.

Logue & Tucker to North for 2023 PP2, 2023 PP3 [Unfortunately we are not getting more given how the compo picks worked out]
Meek, 2023 PP3, F3 to Hawthorn for 24 & 50 [values Meek at 47]
13 & F1 & 2023 PP2 to Melb for Jackson, 33 & 42 [gets them 2 x R1, plus a pick for Grundy and overall values Jackson at pick 3]
24, 33 & 42 (1743 points) to Brisbane for F1, F3 [with their own R2 this will get them 2285 which is close enough to the 2300 needed for Ashcroft. They can use points from McStay for Fletcher as their other father-son]

Then;
Lobb and 50 to Western Bulldogs for 15 (which they will get from Brisbane) [values Lobb at pick 23]
Acres to Carlton for F3
Carlton F3 & Bris F3 to GC for Sharp & Corbett [points for their 2023 Academy players]

2022 Draft
Pick 15, 70, + Round 5 picks as needed

2023 Draft
Brisbane F1(15), F2, F3, F4

Done. Bring on draft day.

Normally these type of posts are nonsense but this is an exception, good effort!

 

[Ge3ks]

We have been the Trade Week winners the last 3 go arounds of it, feel like this year we may just break even.

Did you just reply to yourself?

 

[Taylor]

Forget the price surely it's wasted? Stew porterhouse and it's leather.

Falls apart in your mouth.

 

[gungho]

We need to fight tooth and nail for a second pick coming back if it really is 2x first rounders.