List Mgmt. 2023 Trade & List Management discussion

[irel]

With a trigger for a fifth, according to Fox Sports. Interesting.

My take is we worked with Adelaide to structure Doedee's contract to ensure the Crows got a highest possible draft pick. I expect something will come back to us later in the trade period or next year's draft. Thinking pick swaps for points.

On F1 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Nathan Barley]

Lyons, Robbo, Hamling, Membrey, Menegola, Keays would all be examples where the new club would reasonably be upset if the player walked out the door with no compensation at one point or another during their career.

That's kind of how free agency works. You should be getting less value and I don't think any of those named would be losing too much value to leave for free

 

[Sherrinator]

Doedee is going to be good for us. The guy is a great intercept mark, brave, quick and a good kick. Have seen some hard tackles from him too. I think we will need to restructure our backline for this guy.

 

[dlanod]

That's kind of how free agency works. You should be getting less value and I don't think any of those named would be losing too much value to leave for free

I'd argue that there shouldn't be compo if we're using that logic (which I don't mind either).

If there is compo, then clubs shouldn't be penalised for helping a player reach his potential because of how he's been recruited.

 

[haystark]

North Melbourne wanting pick 3 as compo for McKay is laughable, and no doubt the AFL will hand it to them.

 

[SpecialBruce]

North Melbourne wanting pick 3 as compo for McKay is laughable, and no doubt the AFL will hand it to them.

Yes. Unfortunately I think you are right. The AFL will hand it to them. Gross

 

[JasRulz63]

 

[_Big_D_]

Am I the only person that things delisting Blake Coleman could be a mistake?

 

[haystark]

nothing there…

 

[JasRulz63]

nothing there…

Fixed.

 

[FFB1]

 

[Crusha]

Am I the only person that thinks delisting Blake Coleman could be a mistake?

Most likely .......

 

[Fitzroy bears]

Tbh I think there should only compo for restricted free agents and tweak the system a little.

Anyone who is delisted then relisted by the same club, should be classified as an unrestricted free agent until the end of his career or until he is signed by a different club. If signed by a different club his free agency status is reclassified to "Restricted".

Only players coming off contract who are rookie listed or players who have been delisted, then relisted should be classified as unrestricted free agents.

All other players coming off contract should be classified as restricted free agents.

In my view this gives players and clubs opportunity. Opportunity for the players at the bottom end of the list to move freely for more money or exposure at the elite level and opportunities for the club to retain or be compensated for talent leaving.

I personally don't think we need free agency classifications to be based on years of service anymore.

 

[Chezz]

As you can see, some posters are still struggling to get over the grand final

Not struggling at all. The pies deserved to win, but we did throw away a great chance to win it.

I’ve been on about Berry being a weak link for a while and it caught up with us on GF day unfortunately.

 

[briztoon]

Am I the only person that things delisting Blake Coleman could be a mistake?

Have we announced some delistings?

 

[dlanod]

Have we announced some delistings?

Not yet.

 

[Cubs2Lions]

Not yet.

The worst part of the year IMO for the club

 

[mpal6]

Am I the only person that things delisting Blake Coleman could be a mistake?

Extend Kiddy for 5 right now and then delist Blake.

 

[Dalions]

Am I the only person that things delisting Blake Coleman could be a mistake?

Have we?
Haven’t seen anything formal, or have I missed something?

 

[Section 5]

Darn pick 27 is now 28
The system is rigged

 

[T Rick]

Adelaide have not matched, they get pick 19. Doedee is ours.

Jeez - pick 19 after they significantly downgraded his contract following the ACL injury. Crows have done well!

 

[Section 5]

They missed out the important part.
Should have had a shot including his legs.

 

[Tom14]

Peter Bell vs Collingwood nuffies could lead to the biggest trade period shitfight on bigfooty we've seen in some time.

Sadly, a very good get for Collingwood if the trade goes through.

 

[rye]

there were some whispers about ginnivan seeking a trade a couple months back

would think schultz coming in means hes basically consigned to being a magoos player from now if he doesnt change clubs

 

[beatnik]

Peter Bell vs Collingwood nuffies could lead to the biggest trade period shitfight on bigfooty we've seen in some time.

Sadly, a very good get for Collingwood if the trade goes through.

As annoying as Bell is, interstate teams are often up against the entire Melbourne-centric ‘national’ foot media

For eg, Freo will come under heaps of media pressure to from nufties on Trade radio to do what the player wants, think of his well-being, player freedom etc

Meanwhile…