I still see him as a future elite running defender (but not a lock down defender).
Having an elite defender is about as important as an elite mid for winning a premiership.
Resource 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)
- Thread starter dogs105
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Having an elite defender is about as important as an elite mid for winning a premiership.
Floating Doughnut
SuperCrouch 🧦🧦🧦🧢🧢
- Dec 11, 2022
- 778
- 2,418
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Watch out the fat joke police will pull you up .
And this crap about not listing weight is infuriating when trying to get a good idea of how a player is tracking.
So, I guess a skinfold test result is out of the question?
- Apr 12, 2012
- 4,524
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Ricciardo, Red Sox
We are living through one of the dumbest periods in history.
Happy with Curtin. I see him as a Def/Mid in the Dawson mould. Gives us real marking power and versatility.
Plus we have a long list of inside mids now albeit no real top liners.
I would’ve taken that deal for sure, especially as it was more likely 1 or 2 at the time, no one really anticipated Richmond falling off a cliff that bad. Even for pick 3 I’d do it. Nothing against Curtin, just don’t think he’s a top 3 talent or will be an elite mid. More likely a rebounding defender but you don’t use top 3 picks on them.
ADELAIDE
Current Draft Picks: 4, 64The Crows want to bolster their midfield and this is a good draft to do that.
Adelaide’s midfield was labelled “pedestrian” at times this year, but there is a player in the frame for pick four who could change that.
South Australian Sid Draper has been strongly linked to the Crows and is a player who has drawn comparisons to Chris Judd and Zak Butters with his speed and power coming out of stoppages.
Will Sid Draper become a Crow? Picture: Sarah Reed/AFL Photos via Getty Images
He captained his state at the under-18 national championships mid-year and spent the second half of the season playing senior football with South Adelaide in the SANFL.
Alternatively, the Crows could secure a Victorian onballer, with the likes of Jagga Smith, Harvey Langford, Josh Smillie and Murphy Reid also in the mix to be top-five picks.
Langford (191cm) and Smillie (195cm) are both bigger-bodied options, while Smith and Reid are clean ball-winners with good footy IQ.
Adelaide also has access to a father-son in 191cm marking forward Tyler Welsh, the son of Scott.
The club is yet to commit to Welsh, who shapes as a potential late selection.
Pick Sid.
That’s the message from former Crows captain Mark Bickley to Adelaide’s recruiters as they weigh up whether to take South Australia’s premier talent with pick No. 4 in this year’s National Draft.
Draper, who captained South Australia at the under-18 national championships, is widely considered a top-10 prospect and has been strongly linked to the Crows.
The South Adelaide product has even been touted as a potential No. 1 pick.
Bickley said Draper had all the traits to complement Adelaide’s midfield, which has been criticised for being one-paced.
Should being an SA local be a factor for the Crows when drafting?
YesNo, just pick the best talent
Cast your vote
Sid Draper is South Australia’s top prospect in this year’s draft.
“I think more importantly for people who are saying, ‘are Adelaide going to take Sid Draper’, Adelaide need burst power out of stoppage,” Bickley said.
“They need someone who breaks away from stoppage — think Chad Warner. That’s one need.
“I reckon the other need … if you can get a classy midfielder who is the best kick in the draft and he’s someone who has got some speed as well, that would be another need.
“Adelaide have got Laird, Berry, Crouch that style of player who wins the footy. They don’t have the finishers.”
You are watching
2024 AFL Draft Prospects | Dream grand final entertainmentContinue watching
SHARE
Click to unmute
Draper averaged 108 ranking points in six SANFL seniors games this year and scored a whopping 200 points in his only under-18 match of 2024.
He also averaged 21 disposals, eight contested possessions and 5.5 score involvements at the under-18 national carnival.
“That burst out of stoppage, (Sid) has that,” Bickley said on SEN SA.
“I’ve seen him play at South Adelaide. He finds the ball, he takes off with his legs, he handballs it to someone he then keeps running. He’s a chain-type player. Zak Butters style.
“I think he’s very much the style of player Adelaide need.”
WHAT OUR EXPERTS SAID...
Position: MidfielderHeight: 182cm
Clubs: South Adelaide/South Australia
Excitement is growing around South Australia’s best draft prospect, with the dynamic onballer “killing it” in the SANFL. Draper won his state’s MVP award as a bottom-age player at the under-18 national championships last year, but had a delayed start to this season as he battled a stress fracture in his shin. Since recovering from that injury he has well and truly hit his straps, though. Despite still being underdone leading into this year’s national championships, Draper captained his state and had some eye-catching moments with his acceleration and power away from contests. He has since gone on to find some serious form playing seniors for South Adelaide, including a round 14 game where he logged 27 disposals, nine clearances, 11 ground ball gets and 10 tackles. The younger brother of ex-Collingwood player Arlo, Draper has great composure in the thick of the action, makes good decisions and has exceptional balance between his inside and outside game.
Words by Chris Cavanagh and Dan Batten
Bickley floated Sandringham Dragons star Murphy Reid as another on-baller who had the attributes Adelaide needed.
“It is a consideration, the local talent versus the (interstate) talent,” he said.
“And it’s a big consideration. But if you’re marking it out of 100, that might be 10 per cent of 15 per cent.”
Bickley said he expected the Crows to resist any temptation to split pick 4 for two first-round selections.
Draper recently rubbished speculation he did not want to be drafted to Adelaide due to how some of the Crows younger talent had been treated.
That is a big price to pay - when the option you get left with at 4 is apparently a good potential mid anyway.
I get it if we see Draper as THE player of the draft ... which he might well be.
We would just swap our F1 for North's F2 if that was the price they asked for.
I'm still not sure we just go and do the right thing and just pick the best potential player at our pick - although, last time we did that and picked the Vic MVP he decided teaching Yoga to the influenced suited him better :-(
yeah you are probably right. but giving up a F1 for their F2 is clearly a much bigger price and risk to pay than what I had proposed
I just cant see how Kangas stay with pick 2 as assuming they want a tall it doesnt make sense to overpay. They would be looking at either our pick 4 (if worried about Dees taking same player - with an additional pick from us which was our second rounder next year I was speculating) OR Tigers pick 6 (where they would probably get a bonus mid-late first rounder this year)
Last edited:
- Apr 12, 2012
- 4,524
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Ricciardo, Red Sox
I think they just wanted the full set so they keep all their options open on draft night.
If we want a 2nd it won't be that hard to get one from a club who will be collecting points next year as there are a number of academy kids from what I've read and only the first 50 picks have value.
We have 3 x F3s meaning to trade up to sydney 2nd would be a big points gain for them.
eg. 36 for 40 + 41 - Sydney aren't turning that trade down.
- Aug 9, 2019
- 37,710
- 65,453
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels, Central Augusta
Birthdates always of interest to Recruiters.. oldest to youngest of those in discussion for our pick noting Levi Ashcroft at 18/12/2006 is the youngest of the top 10 or so.
Jagga Smith - 28/01/2006
Bo Allan - 16/02/2006
Harvey Langford - 15/03/2006
Josh Smillie - 17/05/2006
Finn O'Sullivan - 30/05/2006
Sid Draper - 05/07/2006
Murphy Reid - 30/07/2006
Sam Lalor - 30/08/2006
Jagga Smith - 28/01/2006
Bo Allan - 16/02/2006
Harvey Langford - 15/03/2006
Josh Smillie - 17/05/2006
Finn O'Sullivan - 30/05/2006
Sid Draper - 05/07/2006
Murphy Reid - 30/07/2006
Sam Lalor - 30/08/2006
Kinda wild that arguably the best performed prospect is also the youngest
- Aug 9, 2019
- 37,710
- 65,453
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Panthers, GWV Rebels, Central Augusta
Jagga Smith and Bo Allan will be the only two 19 year old's round 1, closely followed by Harvey Langford of that group.
He likely will fail as a gun mid. But if it does workout he will be an absolute jet at his size. Upside is therw
ok many thanks man. one thing though. points are being revalued materially next year and third rounders worth much less relative to current points system.
not sure if your calcs take that into account.
- Apr 12, 2012
- 4,524
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Ricciardo, Red Sox
I went off Draper but reviewing footage I'm back on him. It's simple, Vic clubs take Vic players 1,2,3. We take Draper. at 4 Then we relax. So many words are going to be spent speculating but this is what will happen.
- Jul 6, 2017
- 32,035
- 46,385
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
If we get Draper, we should rightly be ecstatic as he will come in and will become a very very good player for us as time goes on I have no doubt
I really love our spot in the draft.
Each of Lalor, FOS, Jagga and Draper provide a point of difference that we need.
Would be happy to sit and take whoever falls to us out of that lot. Hopefully Haggis thinks the same!
Each of Lalor, FOS, Jagga and Draper provide a point of difference that we need.
Would be happy to sit and take whoever falls to us out of that lot. Hopefully Haggis thinks the same!
- Apr 12, 2012
- 4,524
- 7,765
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Ricciardo, Red Sox
I agree, but if we could get up to pick 2 and take our number 1 guy (that we wouldn't get at 4) I would hope they do that.
- Jul 6, 2017
- 32,035
- 46,385
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
As long as our team don't get cute and reach for a player...just go the best talent and it seems almost universal now that is one of FOS, Lalor, Smith or Draper
GROTTO
TheBrownDog
- Jul 5, 2013
- 68,440
- 94,039
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I think this is how it will eventually pan out.
1. Rich Lalor
2. North FOS
3. Carl Smith
4. Adel Draper
Port have made thier delistings
I would rookie Scully if we had room
I would rookie Scully if we had room
Similar threads
