Resource 2024 AFL Draft discussion thread (Wed Nov 20 to Fri Nov 22)

[baldandbroke]

Are people going to keep bringing up this idea that we have stuffed up by not having more picks in this draft?

We aren't at that point of the rebuild anymore. We have done our drafting phase - now we need to get to the draftees becoming players phase.

No good the Crows getting a bunch good picks in this year so they can be peaking in 5 years time !!

Time to see if what we have will get us to the promised land.

That is why we got the trades we got - because we don't have time to develop another raft of draftees with this current group.

We need our existing under 25 years old picks to continue to grow - and add in existing known quantities where we can.

Players like these need to form the bulk of our next premiership:

Thilthorpe 22 - pick 2
Rankine 24 - pick 3 (trade)
?????? 18 - pick 5 (2024)
Rachele 22 - pick 6
Curtin 20 - pick 8
Jones 25 - pick 9
Pedlar 22 - pick 11
Fogarty 25 - pick 14
Michalanney 21 - pick 17 (FS)
Cumming 26 - pick 20 (2024 trade)
Edwards 19 - pick 21
Shoenberg 24 - pick 24
Cook 22 - pick 25
Ryan 19 - pick 27
Worrell 24 - pick 28
Berry 23 - pick 28
Soligo 23 - pick 36
Dowling 20 - pick 43
Taylor 22 - pick 44
Bond 20 - Pick 50
Nankervis 21 - PSD
Peatling 24 - Rookie (2024 trade)
Murray 24 - SSP

 

[latinoheat]

Hope we take a chance on this guy

CHARLIE WEST (Woodville-West Torrens/Immanuel College) Key forward/ruck, 18, 195cm

“Charlie’s contested marking is his greatest weapon. He took 42 marks, including 20 contested, in six games as a bottom-ager at under-18 level last season, which highlights his marking ability. At his SANFL testing in February, he ran the 20m sprint in 2.9 seconds, which shows he has genuine speed for his size as well. He is the grandson of Wayne Jackson (former Eagles player and president and AFL chief executive) and is very much in contention for this year’s draft pool. He was an emergency for our league team in Round 1 but is carrying a bit of a groin injury at the moment. Charlie has massive upside.’’ – Eagles under-18 coach Shane Reardon

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I mean, he will get found out very quickly if he doesn't adapt to an AFL environment. Stringer has still done more in his career than 90% of players ever achieve, I don't think that's the best example. Whether he's maximised that talent is another question, but he's still had a good career.

You want everything if your a number 1 pick which Smillie rates himself as

 

[BRL121]

You want everything if your a number 1 pick which Smillie rates himself as

But the evidence doesn't support that.

 

[Crow till I die]

You want everything if your a number 1 pick which Smillie rates himself as

Is this him?

 

[DJ75]

You have to wonder whether we might be a bit gun-shy on Draper with his injury history, in particular with us having rolled the dice on Pedlar, and him continuing to have major shoulder issues, despite us knowing about those in his draft year...

'Draper is in Melbourne for this week's Draft Combine, however, the 2023 South Australia MVP won't take part in testing due to a chronic pars defect in his back.'

I get the feeling our strategy has shifted in recent years.
I think we now avoid Vic Metro as much as possible and instead look at Vic Country more. I suspect we are also happy to overlook SA based players, with the plan to bring them back later.
Of course this is all reliant on the players being roughly equally rated.

 

[Mutineer]

This!

 

[Big Dub]

You have to wonder whether we might be a bit gun-shy on Draper with his injury history, in particular with us having rolled the dice on Pedlar, and him continuing to have major shoulder issues, despite us knowing about those in his draft year...

'Draper is in Melbourne for this week's Draft Combine, however, the 2023 South Australia MVP won't take part in testing due to a chronic pars defect in his back.'

Hmmm... my Son had a pars defect... essentially meant if he didn't rest he would end up with a fracture in his spine. Basically had to sit out of sport for 12 months. But it healed nicely. Definitely not a good injury to be carrying.

baaaall! probably has more idea than most, but I think someone else posted a while ago that they caught Draper's pars defect early enough to manage his workload to address it.

I think that they expect to need to track the condition and manage into next year, but it's not considered a long term issue (apparently a condition that affects growing kids, but goes away once growing stops/ settles).

baaaall! does that sound right?

 

[50BC]

Are people going to keep bringing up this idea that we have stuffed up by not having more picks in this draft?

We aren't at that point of the rebuild anymore. We have done our drafting phase - now we need to get to the draftees becoming players phase.

No good the Crows getting a bunch good picks in this year so they can be peaking in 5 years time !!

Time to see if what we have will get us to the promised land.

That is why we got the trades we got - because we don't have time to develop another raft of draftees with this current group.

We need our existing under 25 years old picks to continue to grow - and add in existing known quantities where we can.

Players like these need to form the bulk of our next premiership:

Thilthorpe 22 - pick 2
Rankine 24 - pick 3
?????? 18 - pick 5 (2024)
Rachele 22 - pick 6
Curtin 20 - pick 8
Jones 25 - pick 9
Pedlar 22 - pick 11
Fogarty 25 - pick 14
Michalanney 21 - pick 17
Cumming 26 - pick 20 (trade)
Edwards 19 - pick 21
Shoenberg 24 - pick 24
Cook 22 - pick 25
Ryan 19 - pick 27
Worrell 24 - pick 28
Berry 23 - pick 28
Soligo 23 - pick 36
Dowling 20 - pick 43
Taylor 22 - pick 44
Bond 20 - Pick 50
Nankervis 21 - PSD
Peatling 24 - Rookie (trade)
Murray 24 - SSP

Yeah, we unfortunately had an overly extended initial draft focused period to our rebuild due to the fact that we had too many bust early picks prior than at least 2020, maybe even 2021 and hence too little talent in the lower age range early on. Our list management at least appears to have finally moved beyond that initial stage now and is topping up areas of need but still hanging onto the very early picks ie pick 4.

 

[Draft Bored]

This!

I don't think North will trade 2 until they see Richmond take Lalor. If he's still there at 2 I would assume they'd take him rather than trade the pick.

Unfortunately I think this means we're 0% chance of taking Lalor.

 

[adelaidecrows]

I don't think North will trade 2 until they see Richmond take Lalor. If he's still there at 2 I would assume they'd take him rather than trade the pick.

Unfortunately I think this means we're 0% chance of taking Lalor.

It depends on clubs ratings, needs combined with ours. I think Twomey's phantom draft will probably eye opening as his rankings are usually spot on.

 

[Drugs Are Bad Mackay?]

Lalor's hand writing is too messy for us to take him

 

[Captain Furious]

Are people going to keep bringing up this idea that we have stuffed up by not having more picks in this draft?

We aren't at that point of the rebuild anymore. We have done our drafting phase - now we need to get to the draftees becoming players phase.

No good the Crows getting a bunch good picks in this year so they can be peaking in 5 years time !!

Time to see if what we have will get us to the promised land.

That is why we got the trades we got - because we don't have time to develop another raft of draftees with this current group.

We need our existing under 25 years old picks to continue to grow - and add in existing known quantities where we can.

Players like these need to form the bulk of our next premiership:

Thilthorpe 22 - pick 2
Rankine 24 - pick 3
?????? 18 - pick 5 (2024)
Rachele 22 - pick 6
Curtin 20 - pick 8
Jones 25 - pick 9
Pedlar 22 - pick 11
Fogarty 25 - pick 14
Michalanney 21 - pick 17
Cumming 26 - pick 20 (trade)
Edwards 19 - pick 21
Shoenberg 24 - pick 24
Cook 22 - pick 25
Ryan 19 - pick 27
Worrell 24 - pick 28
Berry 23 - pick 28
Soligo 23 - pick 36
Dowling 20 - pick 43
Taylor 22 - pick 44
Bond 20 - Pick 50
Nankervis 21 - PSD
Peatling 24 - Rookie (trade)
Murray 24 - SSP

We finished bottom 4 - I don't think we're in the 'top up phase'. Even if we were, we should always be regenerating our list with young talent as well.

The point that's been made is we've made some list management errors - signing players like Pedlar, Jones & Cook to longer deals just wasn't necessary. None have proven they belong at the top level and no one was coming for them. Then more recently we resigned Berry - who is not only a player that struggles for impact at AFL level but a player that we have a surfeit of that type on our list already; solid grunt players who aren't clean by hand or foot. Then we overpaid for ANB - who despite the qualities he'll bring, is a 29 yr old defensive forward. Not an area of need at age or type or position.

These decisions have cost us a 2nd round pick in a remarkably even draft where pick 30 could be a top 10 pick on other club's draft orders - in turn denying us a Hannaford or a Dodson, likely quality players in positions of need.

 

[feenix67]

The myths around Sam Berry carried by some of you would rival Sasqwatch...

 

[Crow till I die]

We finished bottom 4 - I don't think we're in the 'top up phase'. Even if we were, we should always be regenerating our list with young talent as well.

The point that's been made is we've made some list management errors - signing players like Pedlar, Jones & Cook to longer deals just wasn't necessary. None have proven they belong at the top level and no one was coming for them. Then more recently we resigned Berry - who is not only a player that struggles for impact at AFL level but a player that we have a surfeit of that type on our list already; solid grunt players who aren't clean by hand or foot. Then we overpaid for ANB - who despite the qualities he'll bring, is a 29 yr old defensive forward. Not an area of need at age or type or position.

These decisions have cost us a 2nd round pick in a remarkably even draft where pick 30 could be a top 10 pick on other club's draft orders - in turn denying us a Hannaford or a Dodson, likely quality players in positions of need.

Both cumming and Peatling will be here for our next flag push. I hope ANB is too. BUT it was 1 list spot for ANB with pick 4, Welsh and the other 2 players coming in long term for us so while we did top up, its mostly topping up for both the now AND the longer term so in my eyes does not take away that we are still building. It will help the rebuid move quicker and thats the hope

 

[Mostyn]

Overpaid for ANB? F*** me.

 

[Amacca 23]

We finished bottom 4 - I don't think we're in the 'top up phase'. Even if we were, we should always be regenerating our list with young talent as well.

The point that's been made is we've made some list management errors - signing players like Pedlar, Jones & Cook to longer deals just wasn't necessary. None have proven they belong at the top level and no one was coming for them. Then more recently we resigned Berry - who is not only a player that struggles for impact at AFL level but a player that we have a surfeit of that type on our list already; solid grunt players who aren't clean by hand or foot. Then we overpaid for ANB - who despite the qualities he'll bring, is a 29 yr old defensive forward. Not an area of need at age or type or position.

These decisions have cost us a 2nd round pick in a remarkably even draft where pick 30 could be a top 10 pick on other club's draft orders - in turn denying us a Hannaford or a Dodson, likely quality players in positions of need.

Overpaid for ANB is a joke are you serious this guy has been top 5 in dees bnf the last 3 years and if he plays a similar role to the one he had in melb which releases izak into the mid like he did with trac we have under paid for him fmd

On SM-G996B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[baldandbroke]

We finished bottom 4 - I don't think we're in the 'top up phase'. Even if we were, we should always be regenerating our list with young talent as well.

The point that's been made is we've made some list management errors - signing players like Pedlar, Jones & Cook to longer deals just wasn't necessary. None have proven they belong at the top level and no one was coming for them. Then more recently we resigned Berry - who is not only a player that struggles for impact at AFL level but a player that we have a surfeit of that type on our list already; solid grunt players who aren't clean by hand or foot. Then we overpaid for ANB - who despite the qualities he'll bring, is a 29 yr old defensive forward. Not an area of need at age or type or position.

These decisions have cost us a 2nd round pick in a remarkably even draft where pick 30 could be a top 10 pick on other club's draft orders - in turn denying us a Hannaford or a Dodson, likely quality players in positions of need.

Not saying it's going well - or that we are nailing the rebuild!!

It's an unfortunate truth that we are in the phase we are without any improvement in our wins / losses.

You do not determine where you are at in a rebuild by your ladder position.

We have begun the "top-up phase" whether we are ready or not.

 

[GreyCrow]

You do not determine where you are at in a rebuild by your ladder position.

Really? I agree getting things in place means you can ignore the ladder but there comes a time when you cant ignore it and that was 2023

We have begun the "top-up phase" whether we are ready or not.

I cant wait for the '' get rid of the deadwood '' phase

 

[Coopers]

Really? I agree getting things in place means you can ignore the ladder but there comes a time when you cant ignore it and that was 2023

I cant wait for the '' get rid of the deadwood '' phase

In theory that happens this year - if I look at the list we have about 12-15 players who are nibbling around the 22 who should have a reasonable shot of "making it". Some of them are young and need more opportunity (Dowling, Ryan, Curtin, pick 4, Taylor and more) some of those are in the "make or break season" (Milera, Pedlar, Cook, Jones, Schoey).

So there's some guys that will probably have to go and ideally don't get games in the 22 (Smith, looking at you), and a chunk of those in the above categories. Could easily delist 5 guys this year.

List is actually really healthy in the "up and coming depth" regard. Still missing that out and out star power - we need those 5x AA level players that premiership teams tend to have.

 

[baldandbroke]

Really? I agree getting things in place means you can ignore the ladder but there comes a time when you cant ignore it and that was 2023

Our list rebuild is not solely responsible for the ladder position. That is broader club issue - how we develop / coach / use our list is where I see our biggest problems.

I cant wait for the '' get rid of the deadwood '' phase

If you are talking about the non-playing deadwood ... Agreed, that is our biggest anchor right now imo.

The deadwood on the list are another discussion that we all have had, and continue to have - but that is not as big a problem as the other side of the coin.

 

[Draft Bored]

It depends on clubs ratings, needs combined with ours. I think Twomey's phantom draft will probably eye opening as his rankings are usually spot on.

I feel it could go something like this. I just have a feeling we love FOS.

1 RICH - Lalor
2 ADEL - FOS (NM trade down to 4)
3 CARL - Smith
4 RICH - Langford (NM trade down to 6)
5 MELB - Draper
6 NM - Tauru

 

[rocket18]

Are people going to keep bringing up this idea that we have stuffed up by not having more picks in this draft?

We aren't at that point of the rebuild anymore. We have done our drafting phase - now we need to get to the draftees becoming players phase.

No good the Crows getting a bunch good picks in this year so they can be peaking in 5 years time !!

Time to see if what we have will get us to the promised land.

That is why we got the trades we got - because we don't have time to develop another raft of draftees with this current group.

We need our existing under 25 years old picks to continue to grow - and add in existing known quantities where we can.

Players like these need to form the bulk of our next premiership:

Thilthorpe 22 - pick 2
Rankine 24 - pick 3 (trade)
?????? 18 - pick 5 (2024)
Rachele 22 - pick 6
Curtin 20 - pick 8
Jones 25 - pick 9
Pedlar 22 - pick 11
Fogarty 25 - pick 14
Michalanney 21 - pick 17 (FS)
Cumming 26 - pick 20 (2024 trade)
Edwards 19 - pick 21
Shoenberg 24 - pick 24
Cook 22 - pick 25
Ryan 19 - pick 27
Worrell 24 - pick 28
Berry 23 - pick 28
Soligo 23 - pick 36
Dowling 20 - pick 43
Taylor 22 - pick 44
Bond 20 - Pick 50
Nankervis 21 - PSD
Peatling 24 - Rookie (2024 trade)
Murray 24 - SSP

Of course we have stuffed up by not having more picks in this 'super' draft, we still have a lot of crap left on our list.

What is wrong with expecting another one or two of them to be replaced with this years draftees?

 

[Sizzlepack]

Very little new stuff in Gettable. Pretty funny that "Crows narrow sights on Pick 4" was just a 30-second response to a viewer question rather than an actual segment, despite getting top billing in the show's title. Pretty much all I've learnt from the last couple of weeks is that there's very little chance Lalor makes it to our pick, and that Langford is being talked about more as a consideration.

 

[Trigger13]

I feel it could go something like this. I just have a feeling we love FOS.

1 RICH - Lalor
2 ADEL - FOS (NM trade down to 4)
3 CARL - Smith
4 RICH - Langford (NM trade down to 6)
5 MELB - Draper
6 NM - Tauru

I’ve got a feeling we love Langford. Wouldn’t put it past Hamish.