![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/st_kilda.png)
- Mar 14, 2011
- 14,640
- 77,447
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Leeds united, Chicago Bulls
Looks a very very good top 10Still a bad draft![]()
![Face with tears of joy :joy: š](https://cdnjs.cloudflare.com/ajax/libs/twemoji/14.0.2/72x72/1f602.png)
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: GWS Giants v Brisbane Lions - 7:30PM Sat
Squiggle tips Lions at 65% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
AFLW 2024 - Round 3 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Looks a very very good top 10Still a bad draft![]()
Smilie will feed his #1 campaign in the Nab League.that game highlighted the depth of this draft. Genuine guns all over the field, but no one standing above the pack to claim they are the best player in the land.
After today I would say smillie and O'Sullivan have came back to the pack, and join the likes of Smith, Lalor, Murphy Reid, trainor, Langford, travaglia, Lombard, Ashcroft and Draper.
If we get access to him we will gobble him without a doubt - bookmark it.Any kid that can play amongst men & hold his own is ahead of the pack. Sid Draper.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
I still have major doubts over Reid's upside at AFL level. What is his standout attribute? Same for Langford to a lesser extent. All the others have one; Smith - positioning, Smillie - size, FOS - running ability, Lalor - power, Draper - burst, Travaglia - speed & height etc.I have no idea who I prefer at our pick after these champs. I feel like it's a good year having pick 4/5 instead of 1 or 2, let the other clubs make the decisions and see who is left.
My preferences in order , which will change as I am more unsure then ever now.
1-smith
2-smillie
3-Reid
4-O'Sullivan
5-lalor
6-draper
7-Langford
8-travaglia
9-trainor
Add Lombard and Ashcroft who we can't have, plus maybe Armstrong, that's probably the top 12 leading group imo.
Itās a shockerStill a bad draft![]()
Yeah I am definitely thinking about how the hell we try get more picks. But I donāt think anything more then 1 additional top 30 pick is possible from us.Itās a shockerIād love six picks in the top 30 then our two academy boys.
I still have major doubts over Reid's upside at AFL level. What is his standout attribute? Same for Langford to a lesser extent. All the others have one; Smith - positioning, Smillie - size, FOS - running ability, Lalor - power, Draper - burst, Travaglia - speed & height etc.
I still have major doubts over Reid's upside at AFL level. What is his standout attribute? Same for Langford to a lesser extent. All the others have one; Smith - positioning, Smillie - size, FOS - running ability, Lalor - power, Draper - burst, Travaglia - speed & height etc.
And the other mids dont? Jagga is the best in the comp at itReid hunts the ball & wins his own
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
I just feel like the game has gone past those slow but skillful midfield types, none of the top mids at AFL level are like that, they all either have; electric speed, Cripps/Bont-like size or Neale-like contest abilityYes I'm unsure if Reid makes it as a midfielder at afl level, he is on the smaller side and not very quick. What he does have in spades his excellent kicking skills, great decision making, and moves in and out of traffic with time and space like a Pendlebury or probably more Hunter Clark like. He is definitely a better inside player then billings though.
Langford is pretty well rounded, but maybe no stand out attribute. Kicks well, strong overhead, can win the footy on the inside, but equally adept on the outside. Seems to have a reasonable tank, and at the end of the day, has football smarts, which is something you can't teach.
I think youāre right. They could do something like last year. Get another third rounder and trade that and our third for a second.Yeah I am definitely thinking about how the hell we try get more picks. But I donāt think anything more then 1 additional top 30 pick is possible from us.
If we got Band 1.I think youāre right. They could do something like last year. Get another third rounder and trade that and our third for a second.
Difference is obvious size pendles and bont is 190cm+ which separates them. Looks like a good player but a lot more upside with others Iād say. More then likely a Half back/neat user at afl level then a starting midfielder (youād want at our pick)Yes I'm unsure if Reid makes it as a midfielder at afl level, he is on the smaller side and not very quick. What he does have in spades his excellent kicking skills, great decision making, and moves in and out of traffic with time and space like a Pendlebury or probably more Hunter Clark like. He is definitely a better inside player then billings though.
Langford is pretty well rounded, but maybe no stand out attribute. Kicks well, strong overhead, can win the footy on the inside, but equally adept on the outside. Seems to have a reasonable tank, and at the end of the day, has football smarts, which is something you can't teach.
Any kid that can play amongst men & hold his own is ahead of the pack. Sid Draper.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Yeah Cal Twomey said Reid is likely to start his AFL career at half back. Very similar to Hunts imo and I don't want another version of him hahaDifference is obvious size pendles and bont is 190cm+ which separates them. Looks like a good player but a lot more upside with others Iād say. More then likely a Half back/neat user at afl level then a starting midfielder (youād want at our pick)
Jagga and Lalor and best slider in round 2.
Still not convinced by Hofmann, could be better off taking someone from open draftJagga and Lalor and best slider in round 2.
Both NGAs late.