2024 Draft Thread.

[ScrappyDo]

On Smillie, Dylan Alexander made an exceptional video evaluating him as a player. The point that stood out to me was the ground balls argument - for a tall midfielder to make it at AFL level, they have to be able to win ground balls. It's what separates Bontempelli, Cripps, and Green from the likes of Nash and Setterfield. Apparently Smillie is 'elite' in this category in U18s

Alexander then goes on to directly compare Smillie to Tom Green and the similarities are very promising - including the fall in form for Champs

If this guy falls to our picks we should consider ourselves very lucky.

 

[ScrappyDo]

The best combo would be

7 Reid
8 Smillie

Class and Brute

1. Lindsay
2. Lalor/Smilie
3. Hynes

 

[akaifu]

1. Lindsay
2. Lalor/Smilie
3. Hynes

I wouldn't be surprised if SOS and Ross are keen on Lindsay, but I feel like at pick 7 its slight reach territory. He's the best kick in the draft but maybe lacking a bit of pace and tricks which would prevent him from moving inside midfield. Also pretty small in stature too

I guess the question is can we see him developing into a Jack Sinclair/Dan Houston, or is he going to become a Dylan Stephens etc

 

[Barrels]

This will get people talking

What a ****ing shambles.

 

[Ekomaira]

What a ****ing shambles.

who do you hope we get mate?

 

[austinnn]

No Ough in the top 30?

Oh no
View attachment 2115319

 

[Sol Goodman]

If Smilie makes it to our picks and we pass. I'll spew.
Smilie/Lindsay will be huge wins.

I don't get all this talk that size doesn't translate well to AFL because his opponents are smaller. I think this is overstated. He has a better base, get him through an elite training system, will be a beast of mid.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

1. Lindsay
2. Lalor
3. Oliver or Barrat

 

[Rors]

If we walked away with 3 of Lalor, Smillie, Reid, Tauru, Travaglia, Lindsay or Hynes, we should be very happy and pumped for the future

Looking forward to seeing what is in store for us over trade week & the draft

 

[ScrappyDo]

I wouldn't be surprised if SOS and Ross are keen on Lindsay, but I feel like at pick 7 its slight reach territory. He's the best kick in the draft but maybe lacking a bit of pace and tricks which would prevent him from moving inside midfield. Also pretty small in stature too

I guess the question is can we see him developing into a Jack Sinclair/Dan Houston, or is he going to become a Dylan Stephens etc

I think 7-8 is his range. Not the highest ranked but he's become my fave.

 

[ScrappyDo]

If we walked away with 3 of Lalor, Smillie, Reid, Tauru, Travaglia, Lindsay or Hynes, we should be very happy and pumped for the future

Looking forward to seeing what is in store for us over trade week & the draft

That's about my list too. I don't like Reid so I'll swap him with Hannaford for a slightly later pick.

 

[Tommy Wigs]

I wouldn't be surprised if SOS and Ross are keen on Lindsay, but I feel like at pick 7 its slight reach territory. He's the best kick in the draft but maybe lacking a bit of pace and tricks which would prevent him from moving inside midfield. Also pretty small in stature too

I guess the question is can we see him developing into a Jack Sinclair/Dan Houston, or is he going to become a Dylan Stephens etc

Have you seen any stats on his CP v UP? I recall seeing some analysis more broadly that those that are <30% will generally be flops.

 

[Tommy Wigs]

who do you hope we get mate?

I think it’s a comment on old mate, Jasper that wrote it. ESPN don’t tend to have a great history of their AFL talent watchers

 

[Tommy Wigs]

I’m not that big on Cole. I think we need another tall back at some point. Ideally we still have 43 or whatever it is and one may have slipped through.

 

[SaintsSeptember]

I think it’s a comment on old mate, Jasper that wrote it. ESPN don’t tend to have a great history of their AFL talent watchers

It's very different to Twomey's and Twomey does have a great history.

 

[ESPN8 The Ocho]

1. Lindsay
2. Lalor/Smilie
3. Hynes

Based on last year, positional need is the premium.
Then foot skills:

#7 Lindsay
#21 Hynes
#24 Dodson

(Battle compo will be end of first).

 

[akaifu]

Have you seen any stats on his CP v UP? I recall seeing some analysis more broadly that those that are <30% will generally be flops.

 

[beside the seaside]

View attachment 2115469

Has a beautiful left foot kick too.

 

[akaifu]

Has a beautiful left foot kick too.

He's the best kick in the draft and has been all year

After Dalrymple said he was going to draft more on a needs basis over pure talent, I feel like he's a real chance to get to us. Him and Nas would be so damaging

Might start his career in the McKercher half back role

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

Based on last year, positional need is the premium.
Then foot skills:

#7 Lindsay
#21 Hynes
#24 Dodson

(Battle compo will be end of first).

Love the reverse jinx

 

[Tommy Wigs]

View attachment 2115469

Oh. Sorry mate. I use that site all the time

 

[Joffaboy]

I am so confused by who we should draft, that I am probably not going to post on this thread after this.

Hoping for a slider so we get one of Reid, Smillie, FoS plus another high rated mid.
Basically don't care who we get, have to trust the recruiters.
Whitlock gor our second would be good.

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[gringo2011]

What a ****ing shambles.

Controversy gets more clicks than sensible.