Rumour 2024 Hypothetical trade and FA Thread

[Strapping Young Lad]

2024 Picks



2025 Picks

 

[A1fromDay1]

The Dees offered their future 1st to the Suns for pick 13, would've much rather that pick than the blues.

All in all should've just kept pick 14 if a deal couldn't be done and just go to the draft which is a very deep one.

 

[kazzooka]

This wouldn't have been done without WCE and possibly even Richmonds knowledge in what they want for their respective trades. Try not to look at things in isolation

Yep, This trade was done so that we can make a trade more in line with what west coast want. Not to downgrade what we offer. If our offer was 14 + F2 for Barrass + F3 then our next offer will likely be a bit better for west coast than that. Or it is simply a way for us to be able to trade F1 and F2 now that we have 2 of both that would be expected to be similar value.

 

[Jim Prideaux]

exactly.....likely carltons f1 and f2 next year will be (significantly?) better than ours.....

Spot on

 

[Jim Prideaux]

The Dees offered their future 1st to the Suns for pick 13, would've much rather that pick than the blues.

All in all should've just kept pick 14 if a deal couldn't be done and just go to the draft which is a very deep one.

Did the suns accept the dees offer?

 

[mustang]

Well atleast now other clubs will know there is a new boss in town

About bloody time

 

[kazzooka]

exactly.....likely carltons f1 and f2 next year will be (significantly?) better than ours.....

I think we're both going to be top 4 next year. They collapsed to 8th on the back of a heap of injuries. Not just we should expect them to plummet down the ladder.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Good on Hawks, Eagles were just being plan out greedy!

Potential outcomes Carlton picks for Barrass? We make a bid for Smith? Or we have lit draft hand for 2025? Interesting days!

 

[daniel23]

There is no way we go into next season with those 2 firsts.

 

[Kuuz]

It appears my worst fears were answered. The mods did the dirty deed.
……

I suppose it’s back to the North board for me.

Maybe, I will see you again in the future - when I come for that little wizard of yours after round 7 and another missed Auskick clinic.

An aside EDIT: I understand Norf being pretty much irrelevant for several seasons straight probably breeds a level of pent up banter, but jesus christ, even your off-season is fairly bland. Norf is literally haggling over picks in the 50-60s for a 30+ Luke Parker.

Just stop, I feel second-hand embarassment on your behalf. Thx <3

 

[mustang]

Yep, This trade was done so that we can make a trade more in line with what west coast want. Not to downgrade what we offer. If our offer was 14 + F2 for Barrass + F3 then our next offer will likely be a bit better for west coast than that. Or it is simply a way for us to be able to trade F1 and F2 now that we have 2 of both that would be expected to be similar value.

Let's hope not, MM has made a big statement to all AFL clubs and players let hope we stick to it.

Offer WC another downgraded of a deal and say take it or leave it.

 

[HeHateMe]

It's not sleepy mark it's sleeper agent mark.

 

[HairyO]

There is no way we go into next season with those 2 firsts.

Unless there is a player out of contract we want next year and figure 2 x 1sts will get the trade done.

We either get Barrass this year or start 2025 Trade season with a big advantage.

 

[cryptor]

Jesus reading the Weagles board induces genuine brain rot.

Literally read on one post that they're happy to keep Barrass as he has plenty of game time left, but also happy they miss Baker because he's too old.

Baker is 27, Barrass is 29.

Then another says Barrass should be happy as he's on good coin. Did they not read the whole point he's leaving is he was promised a bump in his contract by handshake, which was not honoured by the club & literally gave a speech wanting to walk.

Honestly, what are they drinking over there? I understand wanting to keep a decorated player, but they have royally screwed him over at points + I just can't see him being around for their next tilt, and feel it would only delay their rebuild if they kept him. They have good youth ready to make a play at the backline. Just really odd.

Their entire board needs a crash course in self-awareness from Chris Scott.

 

[Roddy]

This thread is up to page 666….

 

[hfc70]

Finally something!

So figure that the eagles were party to this as 14 doesn’t mean anything if it was to be on traded. 14 way overs for baker maybe that’s the point. How about
Hawks give blues f1/2 serong 71
Hawks get Barrass f3

Hawks give 33 f1 to scum
Hawks get 9

In Barrass 9 f3 eagles
Out Serong 14 33 f1 71

2024: 9 plus 2 rookie delist and relists
2025: f2 hawks f3 eagles

Barrass costs pies r2 and f1 and Serong and we upgrade 14 to 9 and f3 to eagles f3.

I’d like to order a kilo please

 

[Chioli]

Did the suns accept the dees offer?

Does 33 and 2 future seconds get us close to pick 13 from the suns? I know nobody likes points but if it was 33 this year and 35 and 36 next year it would be 1587 points with 13 worth 1212 but 13 turns into 15 after Ashcroft and Kako so becomes 1112.

I’m sure I’m missing something but it doesn’t seem wildly off.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Unless there is a player out of contract we want next year and figure 2 x 1sts will get the trade done.

We either get Barrass this year or start 2025 Trade season with a big advantage.

Or we rate the 2025 draft

 

[Kuuz]

Or we rate the 2025 draft

Doubtful. Not this far out anyway. It's going to be pretty compromised by academy picks by the sounds of it.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Doubtful. Not this far out anyway. It's going to be pretty compromised by academy picks by the sounds of it.

Why? Clubs follow players years and years out. We’ve lost nothing and added an extra second.

It may also be the last draft before Tassie comes in!

 

[SSSSSS]

I suppose it’s back to the North board for me.

Maybe, I will see you again in the future - when I come for that little wizard of yours after round 7 and another missed Auskick clinic.

Is that what Norf are calling their training sessions now?

 

[Sturty]

This thread is up to page 666….

 

[hawkmang]

GigaMark after West Coast incorrectly assumed he was in a coma

 

[Mopar Jason]

Barrett still thinks the Barrass deal will go ahead.

 

[kazzooka]

Barrett still thinks the Barrass deal will go ahead.

I think it's happening just how WCE and Hawthorn want it to. The reason we split 14 is to facilitate the deal, we didn't do it just for fun because we expect to go into next year with no barrass and have double picks in the 1st and 2nd round next year.

 

[Bugs1977]

Smart business really. We still have the picks to get Barrass done if the eagles are willing plus Carlton’s first rounder could be pretty handy

Is there a chance that this whole thing is just a big media build up to add to the whole trade period drama? What I'm saying is that like years gone by everything has already bee agreed to with Carlton, Richmond, West Coast and Hawthorn.

For example Richmond might've already told WC that they're content with a F1 for Baker knowing full well that they're already going to have a plethora of 1sts coming thorough very soon anyway. WC in turn might've then told us to move pick 14 to Carlton for their F1 + F2 which they to are content with for Barrass.

So all we really end up really giving up for Barrass is pick 14 without adding any steak knives to the deal. I assume this would all be dependent on WC being okay with future picks.

Hawks give – F1 + F2 (via Carlton)
Hawks get – Barrass

WC – give – Barrass
WC – get – F1 + F2 (via Carlton)