![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
WyntersGame_
Senior List
- Jun 10, 2022
- 234
- 743
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I agree he is unreliable which is a damn shame, however I do think if we aren't carrying so many injury prone players, I would be happy to have him on the books. I mean he is a hell of player when fit and I think when u aren't carrying so many injury prone players every year, you are more forgiving of the one you have because of what he does bring when fitIn all seriousness, 10 of the 12 I listed should just go whether we get anything from them or not. We need to draft and develop some real talent. Our club has to be the worst in the league for hanging on to players who are either injury prone or not developing as expected.
I love Martin, and I seriously rate him as an absolute gun, but regardless what happens during Finals, we need to let him go.
His body is just too unreliable and now we have Elijah who is doing everything we wanted from Martin.
Owies is apparently getting big offers elsewhere so I say we get what we can from him, even though he's our best small forward. We can cover him. I think Jack Carroll has shown enough to say he'll be worth hanging on to and if the list is thinned I dare say extra game time will help him evolve his game.
Khamis I never really took any notice of until a couple of games ago when he played on Charlie.
I agree and think he's going to become a VG player.
I like to compare it with Jamie Elliot & Collingwood. Hell of player but always injured. They keep him on their list because of what he brings.