![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/carlton.png)
Blueyourmyboy!!
Team Captain
- Apr 26, 2017
- 309
- 437
- AFL Club
- Carlton
They're done. Been list cloggers for to long...goneski.Not really …they just need some luck …they should be right
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
They're done. Been list cloggers for to long...goneski.Not really …they just need some luck …they should be right
Saad, Walsh, Acres, Elijah all on the table?Yeah, fair shout. You need a good squad of 30 to win a flag imo - 30 players genuinely capable at AFL level, with 31-44 players group as break-glass depth.
I think the reason our 25-44 bracket are average is because it seems our VFL program is still rubbish - which is just unacceptable considering how rubbish it's been for so long. It's the VFL team for Carlton! That's a dead set dream for kids who have missed the draft, local guns wanting a VFL spot, or delisted AFL players wanting to remain in the system - how we can't get this program right is a disgrace - it's in the heart of Melbourne at a famous club & ground ffs.
Anyway, requests for off-season:
1. KPD - nothing on the market though which is concerning. Weitering needs help & McGovern is only good for intercepting.
2. Midfielder - a nimble type, not necessarily speedy but able to weave through traffic with fast feet.
3. Some goddamn promising kids and solid role players who can get us VFL results and push the standards of our AFL squad.
I'm open to trading, too. Nobody is off the table except Cripps, Curnow, McKay, Weitering & De Koning.
The Moir one is just beyond baffling to me. A slow off the mark 3rd tall option who has questionable commitment to the contest. Didn't make sense to me then and still doesn't from what he's shown.Over the past 3 years we have drafted
Moir
Wilson
Hollands
Cowan
Binns
Lemmey
Motlop
Akuei
None are locks but there is some possibles. None are exactly stand outs
O'Keefe, Boyd, Cincotta as SSP/Mid season picks
We have brought in Cerra Hewett Elijah Acres which IMO have been good deals
The other issue is there isn't much KPP's in that group
Saad, Walsh, Acres, Elijah all on the table?God talk about an overreaction.
The Moir one is just beyond baffling to me. A slow off the mark 3rd tall option who has questionable commitment to the contest. Didn't make sense to me then and still doesn't from what he's shown.
Wilson will end up a very good player, fairly convinced on that selection from what he's shown in his 1st year. Needs to add another 5-6 kgs in the off season.
ok but are campo boys any good?I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
Cerra is about 3000x better of a kick than Ben Campo. Not going to happen when he's the only mid we have capable of retaining the ball by footI would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
They are both fine players but neither are going to shift the needle for us towards a premiership. They are for the futureok but are campo boys any good?
I know they havent even started yet but i really havent heard anything too good about them. One seems ok from what is mentioned on here.
ok but are campo boys any good?
I know they havent even started yet but i really havent heard anything too good about them. One seems ok from what is mentioned on here.
I understand but I dont think we should be calling cerra a star - he is a good B grade imo.Cerra is star. We quickly forget. A full pre season and playing the middle and we will see it again. You don't trade gun mids in their prime
I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
I would only move cerra on for an explosive mid where both teams win etc.I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
Playing devils advocate, if we were looking to maximise our return, it wouldn't be either of those guys on the table, it'd be TDK.I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
The names to look at are Motlop, Owies, Kemp, Kennedy and Carroll in terms of non essential players that still have some value imo.Forgot Walsh & Elijah.
If someone offered a gun KPD in their prime for Saad, I'd absolutely consider it. Love him, but we need a KPD more than we need a small/running defender right now. Nobody would offer anything of value for Acres anyway - he's worth way more to us than he would be any other club.
My point I was making is contending clubs make big calls - Richmond offloaded Deledio, Collingwood did with Grundy (even though is was a cap squeeze), I'm not saying we have to as well but if an opportunity arises..
Ben Campo is not going to address our midfield issues, he is another big bodied mid with a suspect kicking style.I would put Cerra and pittonet on the table. See what offers we get. With Ben camporeale incoming Cerra is expendable
No current season stats available
Oh God some of the suggestions here are beyond a joke, TDK is by far our best ruckman.Playing devils advocate, if we were looking to maximise our return, it wouldn't be either of those guys on the table, it'd be TDK.
If we believe we are in the window I would be going after Barass hard as my priorityWhat’s our thoughts on KPD defenders available.
Jake kolojashnij
Adam Tomlinson
Tom mcdonald
Josh schache
Darragh Joyce
Ben Miller
Can we afford him. It’ll cost a 1st+ more.If we believe we are in the window I would be going after Barass hard as my priority
Kolodjasnij - won’t leave. Will finish top 5 in the cats BnF this year. Best of the lot thoughWhat’s our thoughts on KPD defenders available.
Jake kolojashnij
Adam Tomlinson
Tom mcdonald
Josh schache
Darragh Joyce
Ben Miller