Blueyourmyboy!!
Team Captain
- Apr 26, 2017
- 309
- 437
- AFL Club
- Carlton
They're done. Been list cloggers for to long...goneski.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management 📃
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,024
- 21,777
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,024
- 21,777
- AFL Club
- Carlton
The Moir one is just beyond baffling to me. A slow off the mark 3rd tall option who has questionable commitment to the contest. Didn't make sense to me then and still doesn't from what he's shown.
Wilson will end up a very good player, fairly convinced on that selection from what he's shown in his 1st year. Needs to add another 5-6 kgs in the off season.
CarmenSandiego
Team Captain
- Apr 23, 2024
- 544
- 1,259
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Saad, Walsh, Acres, Elijah all on the table?God talk about an overreaction.
Forgot Walsh & Elijah.
If someone offered a gun KPD in their prime for Saad, I'd absolutely consider it. Love him, but we need a KPD more than we need a small/running defender right now. Nobody would offer anything of value for Acres anyway - he's worth way more to us than he would be any other club.
My point I was making is contending clubs make big calls - Richmond offloaded Deledio, Collingwood did with Grundy (even though is was a cap squeeze), I'm not saying we have to as well but if an opportunity arises..
I honestly don't know. He is hard to peg. I have seen him do some incredible things but then goes missing
My worry was I asked a top player manager about him after the draft. Said Carlton was the only club that really rated him top 30ish. Many though he was speculative and a maybe a good rookie type. Not sure he had AFL qualities
- Oct 4, 2015
- 12,580
- 22,985
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Voss loves clearances... end of season, it will be time to do some off field.
Cunners, Marchbank, Martin, S.Durdin, Young, Akuei, Mirkov - thanks very much, but time to be shown the door either through trades or delist.
After that, our KPD deficiency MUST be addressed properly... not through some stupid notion that we can find a kpf on the scrap heap and turn them into a solid kpd...
I would like to see us at the very least attempt to bring in a very solid kpd via trade, even if it costs us our 1st pick this year. We need one with experience that can help Weitering out.
Cunners, Marchbank, Martin, S.Durdin, Young, Akuei, Mirkov - thanks very much, but time to be shown the door either through trades or delist.
After that, our KPD deficiency MUST be addressed properly... not through some stupid notion that we can find a kpf on the scrap heap and turn them into a solid kpd...
I would like to see us at the very least attempt to bring in a very solid kpd via trade, even if it costs us our 1st pick this year. We need one with experience that can help Weitering out.
- Apr 4, 2018
- 16,984
- 35,027
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Weitering and our backline desperately need a reliable kpd.
Its a massive weak point of our list.
We are trying to play others (on the cheap) there but it isnt working.
We need to bring one in on reasonable $ if that is what it takes.
Stop the pussy footing around and do it.
Its a massive weak point of our list.
We are trying to play others (on the cheap) there but it isnt working.
We need to bring one in on reasonable $ if that is what it takes.
Stop the pussy footing around and do it.
Last edited:
- Apr 4, 2018
- 16,984
- 35,027
- AFL Club
- Carlton
ok but are campo boys any good?
I know they havent even started yet but i really havent heard anything too good about them. One seems ok from what is mentioned on here.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,024
- 21,777
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Cerra is about 3000x better of a kick than Ben Campo. Not going to happen when he's the only mid we have capable of retaining the ball by foot
Cerra is star. We quickly forget. A full pre season and playing the middle and we will see it again. You don't trade gun mids in their prime
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,024
- 21,777
- AFL Club
- Carlton
They are both fine players but neither are going to shift the needle for us towards a premiership. They are for the future
We won't know until they play. Have talent but aren't locks or Top 10 types
- Apr 4, 2018
- 16,984
- 35,027
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I understand but I dont think we should be calling cerra a star - he is a good B grade imo.
I wanted us to get Goldstein end of last year and trade Pittonet. I rate O'keefe but he is young and TDK is a genuine star
Jack will be back. We just need a quality back up
Whatever happens we need to be aggressive the off season
I would only move cerra on for an explosive mid where both teams win etc.
Sent from my SM-G998B using Tapatalk
- Aug 16, 2009
- 7,607
- 11,128
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- North Ballarat
Playing devils advocate, if we were looking to maximise our return, it wouldn't be either of those guys on the table, it'd be TDK.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 11,024
- 21,777
- AFL Club
- Carlton
The names to look at are Motlop, Owies, Kemp, Kennedy and Carroll in terms of non essential players that still have some value imo.
Acres, Saad, Gov etc are invaluable for us because they provide something none of our other players can and we'd get little in return comparatively to what they provide for us.
The players listed above are all essentially depth pieces when we are at full health but none provide a point of difference to what we've got.
Ben Campo is not going to address our midfield issues, he is another big bodied mid with a suspect kicking style.
Cerra will fine form if the coach plays him back in the mid field, crazy suggestion.
What’s our thoughts on KPD defenders available.
Jake kolojashnij
Adam Tomlinson
Tom mcdonald
Josh schache
Darragh Joyce
Ben Miller
Jake kolojashnij
Adam Tomlinson
Tom mcdonald
Josh schache
Darragh Joyce
Ben Miller
Oh God some of the suggestions here are beyond a joke, TDK is by far our best ruckman.
If we believe we are in the window I would be going after Barass hard as my priority
Can we afford him. It’ll cost a 1st+ more.
- Apr 4, 2018
- 16,984
- 35,027
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Realistically if we want a good kpd we are going to have to give a couple of good player away to get the draft capital
I think the untouchables are:
Cripps, Weits, H, Charlie and TDK.
With the new incumbent our spine become rigid stiff.
I think the untouchables are:
Cripps, Weits, H, Charlie and TDK.
With the new incumbent our spine become rigid stiff.
Kolodjasnij - won’t leave. Will finish top 5 in the cats BnF this year. Best of the lot though
Tomlinson - too old and unreliable
McDonald - too old and unreliable
Schache - don’t make me laugh
Joyce - yet to be proven to be reliable
Miller - potentially most realistic of the lot. Solid one-on-one. Reckon he stays though
- Status
