He’d be a Pearce replacement. I know the chances are basically zero but a backline with Cox and Taylor would be incredible
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
List Mgmt. 2024 List Management thread - Trade Targets
- Thread starter go_the_dockers
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Pearce to lead at Peel. They will start games slowly but he would dominate contests.
DRAGONS FFC - Moderator
- #529
So another spot being opened up.
- May 26, 2014
- 957
- 1,286
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
So sounds like we still want to look at a couple of talks along with some small forwards.
We already know about Voss and Beattie. Wasn't there another tall forward linked to us around the same time as Odin, or was that Voss? Obviously I'd like Sanchez to get a look-in, but there's surely some other mature options we might trial.
We already know about Voss and Beattie. Wasn't there another tall forward linked to us around the same time as Odin, or was that Voss? Obviously I'd like Sanchez to get a look-in, but there's surely some other mature options we might trial.
Duff said before the second half of the draft that clubs cooled off him. Turns out it’s true. Maybe his attitude stinks, who knows
The Feeder Club
Club Legend
- Sep 8, 2023
- 1,320
- 3,260
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Shame for Kuek, it's a long way back from the LTI list to a new contract
- Apr 25, 2011
- 7,983
- 18,706
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Fremantle Dockers look to open up two more list spots with long-term injuries to Sebit Kuek, Josh Corbett
Jake Santa Maria
The West Australian
Fri, 24 November 2023 7:03AM
Fremantle Dockers are set to open up two more spots on their list as they look to fill the holes in the forward line left by long-term injuries and the shock departure of Lachie Schultz.
The Dockers have lodged requests to move key forwards Sebit Kuek (ACL, shoulder) and Josh Corbett (hip) to the club’s long-term injury list as the pair recover from surgery.
With the departure of Schultz in the off-season, the Dockers have been desperate to replace their small forward stocks, drafting Jack Delean.
The West Australian also revealed on Friday the club had invited Woodville West Torrens forward Max Beattie as a train-on player.
“We’re losing two talls with Sebit and Josh having long-term injuries and that also gives us the opportunity to have four train-ons,” Fremantle Head of Player Personnel David Walls said.
“We’ll look at a few different types there. A couple of talls and some small forwards as well.”
The Dockers reportedly have their eye on former Essendon rookie Patrick Voss for a train-on spot, with the pre-season supplemental signing period opening on Monday.
Ex-Gold Coast wingman Jeremy Sharp is set to join the club after opting out of both the national and rookie drafts.
Kuek was pushing for an AFL debut amid a blazing run of form in the WAFL last year, including a six-goal haul against Perth, before his knee injury ended his season.
“It’s unfortunate for Sebit and Josh, who have both had promising starts since arriving at the club,” Walls said.
“Josh and Sebit’s long-term health is our priority and the club will support them with their rehab while getting back to being able to play.”
thewest.com.au
Jake Santa Maria
The West Australian
Fri, 24 November 2023 7:03AM
Fremantle Dockers are set to open up two more spots on their list as they look to fill the holes in the forward line left by long-term injuries and the shock departure of Lachie Schultz.
The Dockers have lodged requests to move key forwards Sebit Kuek (ACL, shoulder) and Josh Corbett (hip) to the club’s long-term injury list as the pair recover from surgery.
With the departure of Schultz in the off-season, the Dockers have been desperate to replace their small forward stocks, drafting Jack Delean.
The West Australian also revealed on Friday the club had invited Woodville West Torrens forward Max Beattie as a train-on player.
“We’re losing two talls with Sebit and Josh having long-term injuries and that also gives us the opportunity to have four train-ons,” Fremantle Head of Player Personnel David Walls said.
“We’ll look at a few different types there. A couple of talls and some small forwards as well.”
The Dockers reportedly have their eye on former Essendon rookie Patrick Voss for a train-on spot, with the pre-season supplemental signing period opening on Monday.
Ex-Gold Coast wingman Jeremy Sharp is set to join the club after opting out of both the national and rookie drafts.
Kuek was pushing for an AFL debut amid a blazing run of form in the WAFL last year, including a six-goal haul against Perth, before his knee injury ended his season.
“It’s unfortunate for Sebit and Josh, who have both had promising starts since arriving at the club,” Walls said.
“Josh and Sebit’s long-term health is our priority and the club will support them with their rehab while getting back to being able to play.”
Dockers look to open up two list spots for injured pair
Fremantle Dockers are set to open up two more spots on their list as they look to fill the holes in the forward line left by long-term injuries and the shock departure of Lachie Schultz.
thewest.com.au
"a couple of talls" So Voss and Mclaughlin maybe?
Interested in who the other tall is, I reckon its more likely a more ready to go one as Jones essentially takes Kueks (Bennings?) developing spot while Corbetts ready to go spot is to be filled
Interested in who the other tall is, I reckon its more likely a more ready to go one as Jones essentially takes Kueks (Bennings?) developing spot while Corbetts ready to go spot is to be filled
With Dimma leaving the Tiges I wonder if we can pry Shai Bolton out of Richmond….
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Purple Jesus
not jess
Rather him than L McDonald tbh.
Bolton roving off Jackson would be unreal
- Jul 20, 2018
- 1,651
- 3,008
Change thread name to Operation get Bolton
He's a need / want / must
Him roving off the feet of Darcy / Jackson. / amiss / Treacy
Woweeee.
2 top firsts no issues
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
He's a need / want / must
Him roving off the feet of Darcy / Jackson. / amiss / Treacy
Woweeee.
2 top firsts no issues
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I would definitely rate Bolton a long way ahead of McDonald. But I don’t think it’s realistic to get him out of Tigerland.
He’s exactly what we need though. Bolton could be as good as peak Toby Grenne over the next 5 years if he hits the upper part of his ceiling… a proven absolute gun
He’s exactly what we need though. Bolton could be as good as peak Toby Grenne over the next 5 years if he hits the upper part of his ceiling… a proven absolute gun
Shame he’s on basicailly seven figures at the tigers.
He ain’t a chance in hell , not until OOC and a free agent .. and by then he’ll be what 29/30 ?… time for people to let that go.
As for McDonald the underrating of him on this board is borderline comical.
He’s not much better than Treacy, “no elite. traits “ ,“He’s not as good as amiss” etc etc
Not sure how many times it needs be stated but go back through 90% of top rated junior kpfs and most of them dont hit their strides to year 4/5/6.
Cameron and amiss are the EXCEPTION not the rule .
Imagine if we’d had a chance at Kennedy and Hawkins in their formative years … this board wouldn’t have given up a second rounder for them combined!
I’m with Docker82 on this ,McDonalds one of the most promising kpfs I ve seen come out of WA in recent times (and we’ve produced way above our average in terms of numbers of very good/elite kpp)
Him combined with amiss for the next ten years is our kennedy/darling with potential to be even better
Id happily pay 2 first for him- obviously not if both top 10 but something around 9/10 mark and late first is fine - who knows could even get a third back with that if we ever show some balls at the trade table
He ain’t a chance in hell , not until OOC and a free agent .. and by then he’ll be what 29/30 ?… time for people to let that go.
As for McDonald the underrating of him on this board is borderline comical.
He’s not much better than Treacy, “no elite. traits “ ,“He’s not as good as amiss” etc etc
Not sure how many times it needs be stated but go back through 90% of top rated junior kpfs and most of them dont hit their strides to year 4/5/6.
Cameron and amiss are the EXCEPTION not the rule .
Imagine if we’d had a chance at Kennedy and Hawkins in their formative years … this board wouldn’t have given up a second rounder for them combined!
I’m with Docker82 on this ,McDonalds one of the most promising kpfs I ve seen come out of WA in recent times (and we’ve produced way above our average in terms of numbers of very good/elite kpp)
Him combined with amiss for the next ten years is our kennedy/darling with potential to be even better
Id happily pay 2 first for him- obviously not if both top 10 but something around 9/10 mark and late first is fine - who knows could even get a third back with that if we ever show some balls at the trade table
Last edited:
Below is the Treacy/McDonald comparison for 2023. There is not a lot between them.
Worth remembering we had Treacy playing as a 2nd ruck for significant periods. Treacy had a much better all round game (we all know this). Also that we were weak in attack even before Treacy was asked to play in the ruck. .
I like McDonald, but if we go with the forwards we have I think we can do ok. Looking for more out of Sturt in particular, and very interested to see what Jackson is asked to do.
Worth remembering we had Treacy playing as a 2nd ruck for significant periods. Treacy had a much better all round game (we all know this). Also that we were weak in attack even before Treacy was asked to play in the ruck. .
I like McDonald, but if we go with the forwards we have I think we can do ok. Looking for more out of Sturt in particular, and very interested to see what Jackson is asked to do.
Josh Treacy and Logan McDonald AFL Stats Comparison
Josh Treacy and Logan McDonald AFL Stats Comparison.
www.footywire.com
Yes he did. I think that highlights their different functions in the game rather than being definitive. Over their careers I do expect McDonald to maintain that superiority in those statistics, but that Treacy would close the gap substantially if he was a full time forward.
Double the goals, double the behinds, double the goal assists
Treacy had a part ruck role for part of the season, so naturally you'd expect him to beat Mcdonald statistically in terms of disposals, Mcdonald still slightly beats him in that.
Mcdonald averages nearly an extra mark per game too and this is over more games than treacy played.
I think the stats are quite clear on a gap between the two
The only thing Treacy really has him on is Tackles and one percenters, which we all expect
- Dec 6, 2020
- 3,577
- 7,606
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Tackles, 1%, Hitouts, Clearances, I50s, R50s, even contested marks, which surprised me. It’s clear they were playing different roles and Treacy was further up the ground than McDonald.
Treacy played 6 games as second ruck, which is over 1/3 of the 17 games he played. Of course he kicked less total goals than someone who played 20 games as a Key forward.
You would hope McDonald is a long way ahead of Treacy being taken at pick 4 vs Rookie pick 7, but there isn’t that big a gap.
If Darcy stays fit, or they bring in Knobel, Reidy or Odin if he or Jackson misses games, Treacy will spend more time forward and we’ll have a better comparison. Even then though, I’d wager McDonald will get targeted a lot more than Treacy does as Amiss is our #1 KPF.
I like the idea of Max Beattie running around developing at Peel, I think we are a little top heavy, and will be more so if we go Voss. We've seen what Voss brings, let's give another small forward a go to see if he's got AFL traits.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
