List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading

[ABAB]

Murphy doesn't play as a SF.

He is a stoppage mid, ie doesn't play on the middle but follows the ball pack to pack.


Keays and Rachele play more of a SF role.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

Exactly, the "revolutionary" coach's role that somehow Nicks want in the side and the disposal metrics is non existence for him.

 

[1990crow]

I’m not going to disagree. I just suspect that we haven’t put a contract in front of Tex as we are planning to bring Lukosius in.

When we absolutely have to take pick 4 to the draft.

There's no way Jack is worth pick 4 anymore.
He's borderline not wanted at GC.

 

[Punchy Bassett]

It's a big no to Lukosius for me, massive Jack Watts vibes.

 

[glengowan]

If we can turn any or all of Laird, O'Brien, Keane and Berry in to 2nd round picks, I would be doing it.

If we could turn Curtin and our future 1st in to West Coast's pick 3, I would be doing it.

Must trade in a 1st ruck to replace O'Brien - doesn't have to be best in league, just someone different. Trade in a developing/back up ruck to replace Strachan and target Dodson in the draft.

Cross our fingers Thilthorpe and Murray stay fit.

2025 midfield - new look Rucks, Dawson, Rankine, Soligo, Crouch, Taylor, occasional Rachele/Keays and 2 new young guns.

 

[robboaustralia]

The longer we go without signing Tex, the more I’m thinking that we’ll be trading for Luko.

If we bring him in there’s no room for Tex.

I just want us to choose a midfielder at 4 and not trade that pick away.

I have always thought this. Thilthorpe to ruck also with resting stints forward.

 

[cleanhands]

Murphy doesn't play as a SF.

He is a stoppage mid, ie doesn't play on the middle but follows the ball pack to pack.


Keays and Rachele play more of a SF role.

On SM-A325F using BigFooty.com mobile app

And it doesn’t work with Murphy

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I’m not going to disagree. I just suspect that we haven’t put a contract in front of Tex as we are planning to bring Lukosius in.

When we absolutely have to take pick 4 to the draft.

Lukoscious not worth pick 4 so I wouldn’t worry about it , we won’t be trading 4 for Luko

 

[Vader]

There's no way Jack is worth pick 4 anymore.
He's borderline not wanted at GC.

I'd be hesitant to give up Melbourne's 2nd round pick for him. I'd probably do it, but I'd have to think twice. Giving up pick #4 for him is a massive NO.

 

[fargothegreat]

How keen do you think your recruiters will be on Draper? Enough to look to trade up the order for him?

 

[Eagleboy2011]

It's a big no to Lukosius for me, massive Jack Watts vibes.

I suspect he is a salary dump and pick from GC like Bowes was, at best. Rankine was the wise pick of the 2.

 

[Floating Doughnut]

I suspect he is a salary dump and pick from GC like Bowes was, at best. Rankine was the wise pick of the 2.

I do not see how GC can entertain trading Lukosius. It is a line they are bereft of talent.
Their highest rating forward is Sam Flanders playing mid and half back.
They went all on on Jed Walter who is big but young.

 

[1990crow]

I do not see how GC can entertain trading Lukosius. It is a line they are bereft of talent.
Their highest rating forward is Sam Flanders playing mid and half back.
They went all on on Jed Walter who is big but young.

Ugh. Wrong.

King and Walter are top end KPF talents the Suns are going to build around. Walter will be a Jesse Hogan type monster.
Ainsworth is a highly talented half forward.
Lombard in their academy will go top 10 as a small forward.
Rogers small forward first round last year.

Forward talent is not GCs problem going forward.
Lukosius being on the outer at the Suns this season tells the story.

 

[ams4crows]

How keen do you think your recruiters will be on Draper? Enough to look to trade up the order for him?

If we have pick 4 I doubt we'll need to move up, and others on this board don't think he's the type of mid we actually need so I'm sure people will be upset with who ever we draft anyway

 

[rabidcrow]

There's no way Jack is worth pick 4 anymore.
He's borderline not wanted at GC.

I laughed listening to Morris and co on SEN. He “would definitely be in the two firsts territory - and one of those reasonably high”
If GC push Luko out the door it’s almost a salary dump. I get that they aren’t doing a Bowes with him but no way is he worth a single top 10 pick. Something in the teens fair enough


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[1990crow]

I laughed listening to Morris and co on SEN. He “would definitely be in the two firsts territory - and one of those reasonably high”
If GC push Luko out the door it’s almost a salary dump. I get that they aren’t doing a Bowes with him but no way is he worth a single top 10 pick. Something in the teens fair enough


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Even teens though? Lukosius is every chance of becoming a fringe footballer right now.
I wouldn't be too enthused with giving up a pick that could land Dobson for example.

Early 20s pick maybe.

 

[Disco Fox]

If we have pick 4 I doubt we'll need to move up

Though there is a thought that Eagles may draft him & anyway, we shouldn't trade up when there is such an even spread of 5 or 6 very talented mids in this draft. If Draper is gone, Hamish will probably pick either Finn O'Sullivan or Sam Lalor as in that group they are the Vic Country boys. Seen always as less likely to want to go home when they don't come from Melbourne.

 

[DJ75]

I laughed listening to Morris and co on SEN. He “would definitely be in the two firsts territory - and one of those reasonably high”
If GC push Luko out the door it’s almost a salary dump. I get that they aren’t doing a Bowes with him but no way is he worth a single top 10 pick. Something in the teens fair enough


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

It depends.

If He's going to an Adelaide team - 2 first round picks required.
If he's going to a Victorian team, it's a salary dump and you should also attach a first round pick with him.

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Ugh. Wrong.

King and Walter are top end KPF talents the Suns are going to build around. Walter will be a Jesse Hogan type monster.
Ainsworth is a highly talented half forward.
Lombard in their academy will go top 10 as a small forward.
Rogers small forward first round last year.

Forward talent is not GCs problem going forward.
Lukosius being on the outer at the Suns this season tells the story.

Ugh

King will be a bust , Walter a star but too early by 2 years.
Not talking small forwards, why are you ?

 

[1990crow]

Ugh

King will be a bust , Walter a star but too early by 2 years.
Not talking small forwards, why are you ?

Wrong.

 

[Scorpus]

Ugh

King will be a bust , Walter a star but too early by 2 years.
Not talking small forwards, why are you ?

Ben King a bust!?

He's going at 2.5 goals a game and is on track for 50+ this year

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Wrong.

King will be back in VIC as a fair to avge Forward and Jed Walter will own that position at GC.

 

[1990crow]

Ben King a bust!?

He's going at 2.5 goals a game and is on track for 50+ this year

Amazing. He mustn't watch football outside our games.

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Ben King a bust!?

He's going at 2.5 goals a game and is on track for 50+ this year

Bust too strong,

Jed Walter will push King out within 2 years imo and he will be traded to a vic club with less inside 50’s than GC
are providing him with atm . GC are second behind Brisbane for inside 50’s this year and many there see him as not making the most of his opportunities . I don’t think they can play in the same team over a long period time.

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Amazing. He mustn't watch football outside our games.

Oh dear.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Ugh

King will be a bust , Walter a star but too early by 2 years.
Not talking small forwards, why are you ?

Ben King is a bust?

Lol, what?