Kane McGoodwin
Make me an Admin!
- May 21, 2001
- 85,548
- 90,528
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Adelaide Crows
My thoughts exactly when reading your post...Oh dear.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
My thoughts exactly when reading your post...Oh dear.
Fair enough Kane , it’s all an opinion.My thoughts exactly when reading your post...
Ben King is 3rd on the leading goal kickers!Fair enough Kane , it’s all an opinion.
My thoughts on Ben is that he is no where near the player he is thought to be by some and has been made
to look far better than he is by GC mids and inside 50’s.
As I said see how he goes in an average I/50 team and see how he goes.
Walter Wii make that happen imo of course
Just bookmark it , He will float throughout his career as a luko type player.Ben King is 3rd on the leading goal kickers!
If you had said Max King, you may have had a point...
He's already proven he is better than Luko!Just bookmark it , He will float throughout his career as a luko type player.
Never be a Coleman medalist.
Holy ****, that would be an absolute disgrace IMOIf we can turn any or all of Laird, O'Brien, Keane and Berry in to 2nd round picks, I would be doing it.
If we could turn Curtin and our future 1st in to West Coast's pick 3, I would be doing it.
Must trade in a 1st ruck to replace O'Brien - doesn't have to be best in league, just someone different. Trade in a developing/back up ruck to replace Strachan and target Dodson in the draft.
Cross our fingers Thilthorpe and Murray stay fit.
2025 midfield - new look Rucks, Dawson, Rankine, Soligo, Crouch, Taylor, occasional Rachele/Keays and 2 new young guns.
Really not sure what's going on up there with old donutHe's already proven he is better than Luko!
You're very wrong on this one.
Likely to win multiple Coleman’sBen King a bust!?
He's going at 2.5 goals a game and is on track for 50+ this year
It’s just too expensive to move a couple of positions higher from 4 to 2. Probably another top 10 pick or even next years first (same as GWS did with us in the 2019 draft)If we want Draper we might need to look at a trade with North to get ahead of West Coast, I'm worried they will pick him (not based on much though).
On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Personally think it’s somewhere in between those. 4 is definitely too high (and talk of 2 x first is ridiculous) but he is a.”nice” player to have but only ever a 3rd tall forward or versatile player playing wing or a Tom Lynch “connector” type role. The problem is his price if contracted 700-800k. He ain’t anywhere near the talent of Rankine and not worth the $$ and GC seem to have a lot more elite talent needing to be paid over co ing years (perhaps 6-7 elite and Luko is NOTin this category)There's no way Jack is worth pick 4 anymore.
He's borderline not wanted at GC.
Luko type player as description is one imo who coasts and never likely to reach potential.He's already proven he is better than Luko!
You're very wrong on this one.
Refer my reply to Kane for clarification .Really not sure what's going on up there with old donut
First King is going to not make it
Then he's going home
Then he's a "Lukosius" type.
Lol.
Say what?!
If we could turn Curtin and our future 1st in to West Coast's pick 3, I would be doing it.
Why LOl ?Really not sure what's going on up there with old donut
First King is going to not make it
Then he's going home
Then he's a "Lukosius" type.
Lol.
Can’t really see a scenario where we move up as the top 10 is so even and full of midsIt’s just too expensive to move a couple of positions higher from 4 to 2. Probably another top 10 pick or even next years first (same as GWS did with us in the 2019 draft)
Since when do teams only have 1x tall forwardWhy LOl ?
Do you not think with the amount of inside 50’s being second best in league GC may believe they are not getting the return from Ben King they would from a 2 year older Walter at rookie wages , from their academy, and already on their list ? And they can trade King for a first ?
Genuine question
Depends if we really rate Draper (can’t see it being for anyone else) and we think WCE will take himCan’t really see a scenario where we move up as the top 10 is so even and full of mids
As you say it’s way too expensive to do it vs the actual benefit
I’d actually consider moving back to get 2x early picks but I think the club might be too scarred from last time to consider
Maybe, I was thinking up 2 spots and then trade our second down a few spots, more like the 2023 GWS without the future 2nd involved.It’s just too expensive to move a couple of positions higher from 4 to 2. Probably another top 10 pick or even next years first (same as GWS did with us in the 2019 draft)
I don't think many are watching Gold Coast ever.Amazing. He mustn't watch football outside our games.
I’m just not sure he’d be so much in front of the others that we’d need to burn an extra 1st round pickDepends if we really rate Draper (can’t see it being for anyone else) and we think WCE will take him
But I can see NM asking for the world
They’re interesting to watch all right , mainly because they’ve got some of the better talented young players in comp
Agree it’s going to be hard (expensive) to get Draper if Eagles want him. After Gibney (top 10) and Reid the last 2 years ideally they look at Trainor but that’s probably wishful thinking,Maybe, I was thinking up 2 spots and then trade our second down a few spots, more like the 2023 GWS without the future 2nd involved.
If west Coast take Draper we'll just cop it I guess, like we do every year in this rebuild.
On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app
He’s not just a small forward , he will play also play midfield too and he’s got everything you need for an elite forward half playerWith all respect to Joe is a small forward really a need? What significant gains do we make by picking him at 11?
If we are going to ' reach ' why not Dodson at 11
Oh I’m not sure either, but the club might beI’m just not sure he’d be so much in front of the others that we’d need to burn an extra 1st round pick
I’d be disappointedOh I’m not sure either, but the club might be