List Mgmt. 2024 List Mismanagement and Trading Part 2

[WaynesWorld19]

If the AFL re-register him first. But not if they don't. I know that a 2 step scenario is a little difficult for you to wrap your head around, but you should try, self improvement should always be a goal.

And in terms of respect for women, how's this guy?

I have a hunch, if Thomas were to be re-listed by another Club, bar the Crows ....you'd have the opposite perspective

 

[Soggy2112]

Maybe thats the plan RT as our long term ruck with Tex, Fog and Luko forward and with Welsh eventually replacing Tex


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

It’s just about dumb enough for us to do it.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Rankine is still a fair way away from being a top 20 mid, but has the potential to break into the top 10 forwards next year, whilst pinch hitting in the midfield. TT and Fog will need to make some massive improvements that I don't think they are capable of whilst playing behind Tex.

Sorry, but this is a weird take on Rankine.....reminiscent of those who were against Rankine moving out of the FWD line last season

Kingy declared mid season, Rankine would be in the top few players in the AFL ....and it wasn't as a FWD

I want him creating, drawing opponents, to free up teammates & delivering inside F50 ....not finishing off the work of others

Rankine is our best midfielder !

 

[George Kramer]

I have a hunch, if Thomas were to be re-listed by another Club, bar the Crows ....you'd have the opposite perspective

Which means the AFL have cleared him

 

[1990crow]

Sorry, but this is a weird take on Rankine.....reminiscent of those who were against Rankine moving out of the FWD line last season

Kingy declared mid season, Rankine would be in the top few players in the AFL ....and it wasn't as a FWD

I want him creating, drawing opponents, to free up teammates & delivering inside F50 ....not finishing off the work of others

Rankine is our best midfielder !

Sure, but he's yet to actually put together a season.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Sure, but he's yet to actually put together a season.

He missed 7 games ....was moved into the MID / FWD role, I'm estimating round 8,9,or 10 .....so what's he played as a MID ....7 of the last 14 games

And did he train with the Mids last PS ( bigman ) ....because I'm very confident he will this PS

 

[1990crow]

He missed 7 games ....was moved into the MID / FWD role, I'm estimating round 8,9,or 10 .....so what's he played as a MID ....7 of the last 14 games

And did he train with the Mids last PS ( bigman ) ....because I'm very confident he will this PS

Yes, but your response evades the point he is yet to put together a season of top quality football.
Until he does that he's achieved nothing.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yes, but your response evades the point he is yet to put together a season of top quality football.
Until he does that he's achieved nothing.

If you can't see his dynamics in the midfield ...and around packs ...well I can't help you

You don't need a body of work to see the obvious with players .....the top end talent I mean

Most players are in various stages of development .....so sometimes it's hard to see where they are on the curve ....but not Rankine

 

[1990crow]

If you can't see his dynamics in the midfield ...and around packs ...well I can't help you

You don't need a body of work to see the obvious with players .....the top end talent I mean

Most players are in various stages of development .....so sometimes it's hard to see where they are on the curve ....but not Rankine

You're not reading my posts.

 

[crow2crow]

You're not reading my posts.

everyone just wants their say nobody wants to listen

 

[crow2crow]

how about preuss as a backup to ROB? same age but way better than strachan.

DFA so costs nothing except a modest pay

 

[Mutineer]

how about preuss as a backup to ROB? same age but way better than strachan.

DFA so costs nothing except a modest pay

Just what we need another broken down croc, a player that makes Wayne Milera look like Michael Tuck re actual games played across their careers.

 

[crow2crow]

Just what we need another broken down croc, a player that makes Wayne Milera look like Michael Tuck re actual games played across their careers.

yeh probably not just a thought

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

how about preuss as a backup to ROB? same age but way better than strachan.

DFA so costs nothing except a modest pay

Beyond cooked.

We do need to bring in a decent 2nd ruck option though.

 

[MrBarry]

You're not reading my posts.

Your saying because Rankine missed a chunk of games this year, he's not really a midfielder?

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

how about preuss as a backup to ROB? same age but way better than strachan.

DFA so costs nothing except a modest pay

I'd prefer Nick Bryan who was named first ruck in the VFL team of the year. Unfortunately, we don't have the list spots unless we delist Strachan a year early.

 

[crow2crow]

I'd prefer Nick Bryan who was named first ruck in the VFL team of the year. Unfortunately, we don't have the list spots unless we delist Strachan a year early.

dont worry about strachan
he gets paid regardless and rucks for sanfl team regardless

we need something else. i never seen bryan live so i dont know.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I'd prefer Nick Bryan who was named first ruck in the VFL team of the year. Unfortunately, we don't have the list spots unless we delist Strachan a year early.

We should just delist Strachan given he can't play out 4 quarters of AFL.

 

[Mostyn]

Everytime i hear Thilthorpe to be lead ruck, i just think of someone using a Ferrari as a dodgem car...why on earth would you want to trash a very valuable asset like that?

Well, it makes him a midfielder, which has some positives.

But with the change of rucking rules, I'd be concerned about the unathletic rucks smashing into him (which is probably your point).

 

[Mostyn]

Cant see any team paying that for Laird on 750k+

We would need to give him away for free (Bowes style) AND throw in a second rounder (or else pay 33-50% of his salary at another club). Laird says no anyway

Agree Butts could be a valuable trade chip getting something in the 20's next year if we went that way

So, in a few weeks, after Laird finishes top 3 in the B&F for the eighth year in a row, you think any club would only consider him as a salary dump?

Mate, love your posts, this seems like pandering to the Laird haters though.

 

[Mostyn]

lots of media this year saying they are one of the clubs along with us, Saints and Dons that have a large capacity still in the salary cap so not sure I can agree here

EDIT - their 2 highest paid players are likely to be JHF (contracted for another few years from memory) and Butters going forward. Butters will be getting a MASSIVE 1m+ / year offer to either stay in the swamps or else to move back to VIC when hitting FA status in a couple of years

Rozee obviously on lot, Ratagulea was given $750k a year to come across, Rioli is on $550k, etc

 

[BigFella!]

If you can't see his dynamics in the midfield ...and around packs ...well I can't help you

You don't need a body of work to see the obvious with players .....the top end talent I mean

Most players are in various stages of development .....so sometimes it's hard to see where they are on the curve ....but not Rankine

Wayne, I agree that Rankine has the potential to be a top 10 mid, and is an extremely talented individual. Rankine is also still building up his tank to move full-time into the midfield. He has started that transition, but it normally takes 2-3 years before it all clicks, and Rankine can play 80% midfield time. When Rankine can be a full-time mid, he will become a top 10 mid. Until then, he will be splitting his time forward, and he will be a top 10 forward in the interim.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Rozee obviously on lot, Ratagulea was given $750k a year to come across, Rioli is on $550k, etc

They save Dixon money.
They may save Houston money.

More importantly as I have explained to you previously, Port along with the Crows are w of only a handful of clubs that did not build in EB increases into their contracts... which is a huge advantage when the cap has significant increase.

 

[1990crow]

Your saying because Rankine missed a chunk of games this year, he's not really a midfielder?

No

 

[ABAB]

Wayne, I agree that Rankine has the potential to be a top 10 mid, and is an extremely talented individual. Rankine is also still building up his tank to move full-time into the midfield. He has started that transition, but it normally takes 2-3 years before it all clicks, and Rankine can play 80% midfield time. When Rankine can be a full-time mid, he will become a top 10 mid. Until then, he will be splitting his time forward, and he will be a top 10 forward in the interim.

Rankine already has a good tank, GCS trained him to be a midfielder the year he requested a trade.