Analysis 2024 National Draft

[Aphrodite]

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Houston is a lock to be one of the best HBF'ers in the league. He has been top 10 for a few years, I'd take that in a heartbeat over getting Berry.

Mortgaging the future for a 27 year old is only worth while if it helps us win a flag in the next few years imo. It's a gamble the list team is going to have to weigh up.

 

[Michael Jezz]

Mortgaging the future for a 27 year old is only worth while if it helps us win a flag in the next few years imo. It's a gamble the list team is going to have to weigh up.

We are not close to winning a flag

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

We are not close to winning a flag

In your opinion, in others we may be. All that matters is whether our list team think we are.

 

[The Defender]

I think I've just accepted that we're probably going to trade some of our picks out to spend on some sugar hits rather than build some quality youth through the hitting the draft hard... but my dream of Berry + Hotton or Berry + Travaglia won't die until we see Dan Houston in a Carlton kit in a few weeks time!

I'm still not sure what the right strategy is for our overall list, Houstons a weapon and could deliver us a flag next year... but if it doesn't come off and we miss out on some of these kids in this draft we're looking very very thin in the youth department with Tassie very near on the horizon.

Houston + Berry/Hotton somehow would be a thing of joy but can't wrap my head around how it gets done.

I’d rather Berry & Travaglia over Houston.

Move Curnow back he can dominate in the air & distribute like our other defenders can’t.

Cowan Weitering McGovern
Travalgia Curnow Saad
Newman

Berry Moir Fogarty
Silvagni McKay Rosas
?

 

[The Blue Weirdo]

Mortgaging the future for a 27 year old is only worth while if it helps us win a flag in the next few years imo. It's a gamble the list team is going to have to weigh up.

2 picks before the Campo's this year in a strong draft then secure Weits and TDK.
Free up salary cap space next year by moving on oldies like Doc, then go hard at some quality free agents.

 

[Sector 7G]

I’d rather Berry & Travaglia over Houston.

Move Curnow back he can dominate in the air & distribute like our other defenders can’t.

Cowan Weitering McGovern
Travalgia Curnow Saad
Newman

Berry Moir Fogarty
Silvagni McKay Rosas
?

Curnow's (and McKay) disposal is very hit and miss. When it comes of it is amazing but for every one or 2 great kicks there is a shank or a dicey disposal.

In the forward line you can make these mistakes . Not so down back

 

[The Defender]

Curnow's (and McKay) disposal is very hit and miss. When it comes of it is amazing but for every one or 2 great kicks there is a shank or a dicey disposal.

In the forward line you can make these mistakes . Not so down back

Fair point although would still have faith that Charlie would be fine. Both backline & fwd line look more versatile plus we get another 2 kids in.

I know they won’t put Charlie back but I have seen it suggested elsewhere so I’m not on my own.

 

[David Sylvian]

I think I've just accepted that we're probably going to trade some of our picks out to spend on some sugar hits rather than build some quality youth through the hitting the draft hard... but my dream of Berry + Hotton or Berry + Travaglia won't die until we see Dan Houston in a Carlton kit in a few weeks time!

I'm still not sure what the right strategy is for our overall list, Houstons a weapon and could deliver us a flag next year... but if it doesn't come off and we miss out on some of these kids in this draft we're looking very very thin in the youth department with Tassie very near on the horizon.

Houston + Berry/Hotton somehow would be a thing of joy but can't wrap my head around how it gets done.

All about the future pick(s) Walshy. All the trade deals would have been done weeks if not months ago. Drafting is not necessarily the key for where we are at right now if chasing the premiership next year.
This off season, for me, is probably the most crucial in many years. Fascinating.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

All about the future pick(s) Walshy. All the trade deals would have been done weeks if not months ago. Drafting is not necessarily the key for where we are at right now if chasing the premiership next year.
This off season, for me, is probably the most crucial in many years. Fascinating.

Agree. Huge off season for this club.

 

[ray8182]

He reminds me of Milne with his acceleration and agility. Gets the legs pumping and gets himself out of a jam.

Agreed that he’s not as silky as Berry but he’s got speed, overhead marking, goal sense and desire to be physical and lay tackles. I’ll be interested in his combine testing (I believe he got overlooked for the national version but I assume he’ll get to the state combine) but it looks like his game will translate to the AFL.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Yes hannafords physicality is a standout. His attack on the ball is just so aggressive. Even going for marks against taller opponents he just hits the pack hard.

Berry plays a bit more like an outside player. Great skills, polished, smart, but not as physical.

Would like to have both.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro

 

[Michael Jezz]

In your opinion, in others we may be. All that matters is whether our list team think we are.

We are akin to Port Adelaide. Port have always thought they were close & have not realised that too many fundamentals are missing

 

[LemmingMaster]

I’d rather Berry & Travaglia over Houston.

You rate two people that you've probably watched a total of 3 times (at best) play football over a guy that has been rated in the top 10 players by champion data for a number of years.

If either of those players end up to be half as good as Houston we're lucky.
This is a classic example of overrating draft picks.

The only real concern for me with regards to Houston is the salary cap constraints. Assuming we're not paying a kings ransom in draft picks to secure him.

 

[LemmingMaster]

We are akin to Port Adelaide. Port have always thought they were close & have not realised that too many fundamentals are missing

Collingwood last year had some areas of concern, yet they still won.

Often teams have an area which is weak, you just need a collective buy in and everything to click. Hawks have buy in and up until recently a good run with injuries. Look at their season.

Last year we were close to a finals and who knows what happens when you make it.

This year was destroyed by injuries throughout the season and some issues behind the scenes.

I have faith we have the list, we just need a few elements to click. Currently, small forward and maybe speed around the ball.

Moir, Lord, Wilson, {insert a recruit}....

Natural development of our list, we're mostly on the improvement spectrum of our key players.

 

[mochacinolatte]

Collingwood last year had some areas of concern, yet they still won.

Often teams have an area which is weak, you just need a collective buy in and everything to click. Hawks have buy in and up until recently a good run with injuries. Look at their season.

Last year we were close to a finals and who knows what happens when you make it.

This year was destroyed by injuries throughout the season and some issues behind the scenes.

I have faith we have the list, we just need a few elements to click. Currently, small forward and maybe speed around the ball.

Moir, Lord, Wilson, {insert a recruit}....

Natural development of our list, we're mostly on the improvement spectrum of our key players.

Having a healthy list going into the final is key, plus they were riding a big momentum.

We were riding that wave last year as well till we were out of juice and players were struggling due to all the niggles.

 

[branedotorg]

Collingwood last year had some areas of concern, yet they still won.

Often teams have an area which is weak, you just need a collective buy in and everything to click. Hawks have buy in and up until recently a good run with injuries. Look at their season.

.

Salary cap is an equalisation method to make sure ALL clubs have flaws on the list.

We've gone with a superstar spine, others have different mixes but no team is a complete work.

Great recruitment and development can mitigate it a bit... but you know that already

 

[LemmingMaster]

Salary cap is an equalisation method to make sure ALL clubs have flaws on the list.

We've gone with a superstar spine, others have different mixes but no team is a complete work.

Great recruitment and development can mitigate it a bit... but you know that already

Just hoping Martin, Williams coming off some big contracts.

 

[branedotorg]

Just hoping Martin, Williams coming off some big contracts.

Imo they'll clear out about 600k this season on Martin, Cunningham and Marchbank (1m in salary between them - 380 in draftee wages)

 

[DangerousD]

Mortgaging the future for a 27 year old is only worth while if it helps us win a flag in the next few years imo. It's a gamble the list team is going to have to weigh up.

Im still confident that even if we get Houston, we will still get a top 20 pick and an early 20s pick

 

[DangerousD]

Take two kids like Watson and hopefully one of them comes on, he’s a gun

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Take two kids like Watson and hopefully one of them comes on, he’s a gun

Every final so far has just been a battle of who's got the best small forwards.

And Heeney. He's a different proposition entirely

 

[DangerousD]

Having a healthy list going into the final is key, plus they were riding a big momentum.

We were riding that wave last year as well till we were out of juice and players were struggling due to all the niggles.

The idea of a banged up list can be a little deceiving, why was it banged up? Could it be the coach, which he has been accused of this year and previously, of not spreading the work load and not blooding kids throughout the season.

Could 3-4 more games from Dow throughout the season have kept a few other players fresher? Same with Carrol?

Being out of juice can be and i see it as a coaching issue.

 

[macky99]

Every final so far has just been a battle of who's got the best small forwards.

And Heeney. He's a different proposition entirely

Pretty sure the Hawks have received 5 out of 7 from free kicks tonight smalls have not been influential so far.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Pretty sure the Hawks have received 5 out of 7 from free kicks tonight smalls have not been influential so far.

Gotta be small enough to draw them I guess?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Rioli and Watson just ridiculous.

If we have the pick on the night and pass on Berry I'm petitioning to have the board sacked!

 

[teagueyubeauty]

The idea of a banged up list can be a little deceiving, why was it banged up? Could it be the coach, which he has been accused of this year and previously, of not spreading the work load and not blooding kids throughout the season.

Could 3-4 more games from Dow throughout the season have kept a few other players fresher? Same with Carrol?

Being out of juice can be and i see it as a coaching issue.

Bingo, it’s whole of squad to get through an AFL season..it’s too brutal on the body

Trick is to use them before the best get banged up too bad and keeping them fresh


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com