Analysis 2024 National Draft

Who should Carlton take at Pick 3 if available?


  • Total voters
    336

Remove this Banner Ad

Might end up like something around 14 and 16/17 with bids. Brisbane got Wilmot and lohmann with similar picks a few years back. This is our chance


I’d be stunned if we didn’t use one of the picks on berry
 

Log in to remove this ad.

So what are we thinking for 12 and 14?

Small Forward and Burst Mid

Key back and Small Forward



On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app
In an ideal world it would be a dynamic half forward who can develop into a midfielder and a dynamic half back who can develop into a midfielder but really we just need to pick the two that will be the absolute best players for the club for ten years.
 
It's happening isn't it... We're getting Berry and Travaglia 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Always Sunny Shut Up GIF
 
Going back to my rough top 30 or so players with our extra pick. My list is has slightly changed recently, but these are still close.
Bolded players are not getting to us most likely.
Hannaford/Berry combination would be lovely. I would smile if a Reid drifted to our pick, Langford does not suit our list needs but might be a little too hard to say no.
I'm higher on Davis than most people on BF, but he reminds me a little of Hayward. That second tall that is dangerous in the air but also on the ground. I really don't have enough info on Hotton to make a strong statement on his worth these days, but Dattoli has elements of a kid that could go higher with Hokball love.
  1. Ashcroft
  2. Draper
  3. Lalor
  4. Lombard
  5. Reid
  6. Smith
  7. Langford
  8. FOS
  9. Lindsay
  10. Travaglia
  11. Hannaford
  12. Berry
  13. Marshall
  14. Tauru
  15. Smillie
  16. Hotton
  17. Davis
  18. Dattoli
  19. Kako
  20. Dodson
  21. Armstrong
  22. Trainor
  23. Allan
  24. Hynes
  25. J Whitlock
  26. M Whitlock
  27. Shanahan
  28. Anderson
  29. Ough
  30. Gross
 
Anyone heard anything about that James barrat from Bendigo? Haven’t seen him in any top 30s but seems to me to really have something in him
Where's his position at AFL seniors? Very versatile at U18 level but is he big enough for a tall man role in the seniors? If not I think he slides, but I do like the penetration in his kicking from what I have seen.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Where's his position at AFL seniors? Very versatile at U18 level but is he big enough for a tall man role in the seniors? If not I think he slides, but I do like the penetration in his kicking from what I have seen.

I’m not quite sure of the size, he is listed at 193 on the talent league app but he feels a bit bigger in person. I was amazed at his last game of footy with the pioneers, when he was put in the midfield and had 25 and 2.
 
I’m not quite sure of the size, he is listed at 193 on the talent league app but he feels a bit bigger in person. I was amazed at his last game of footy with the pioneers, when he was put in the midfield and had 25 and 2.
Yes he seems to be bigger than 193 just on the eye test but is he big enough to be a genuine KP option - that in my mind is what will determine whether attracts an early pick. And I just don't know (nor have a strong feeling about) the answer to that question. But the fact that he doesn't feature much in top 30s and the like suggests to me that maybe there is doubt about that - or it may just be that he seems to be a late bloomer, he certainly seems to me to have really come on well as the season has progressed, I think early lists wouldn't have had him near where he now is.
 
Austin keeps mentioning speed and run. Who fits that bill?

Lindsay, Travaglia, Hotton, Allan?

None are express but are quick in different ways.

I don't get the vibe we are as desperate for a small forward as alot on here are.

He's also mentioned KP defence depth but that could be a mature player. Not many options where our draft picks sit. Maybe Trainor or Tauru?
 
Austin keeps mentioning speed and run. Who fits that bill?
Draper, Hannaford - Those two play quick
Berry - He does not seem slow
Dattoli seems to play quick as well.
Allan - He is quick, does not seem to use his pace as much as others.

Later picks
Urquhart is an explosive player with some speed, would not mind considering him if he drifts far enough. Reminds me a little of Warner. There are question marks on his kicking skills, but he is strong, explosive with a decent side step.
Hayes from WA is also another winger with great speed, sticks to his position and can hit targets.
 
Twomey suggesting we were looking at trading up with West Coast.

Imagine having the Berry/Travaglia hand and trading it in for Sid Draper.

WalshistheGoat wouldn’t know what to do with himself.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Sid Draper looks like a beauty!! For me if we were to trade up Draper or Lalor would be the dream result

If Draper could do a Charlie and slide to pick 12 I’d really appreciate it 👍🏼
 
We must have had a specific player or 2 in mind to make that trade. I wonder who else would consider a pick split?

Doubt Richmond would at 1 or 6. North probably not unless Houston is a go. Adelaide could do with it but gut says they'll want draper. Melbourne I suspect will want quality over quantity. After that it's probably not worth it.
 
Twomey suggesting we were looking at trading up with West Coast.

Imagine having the Berry/Travaglia hand and trading it in for Sid Draper.

WalshistheGoat wouldn’t know what to do with himself.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
Tbf I've long said Draper is my favorite in the class. I just feel like we're a limited chance of taking 2 picks before Ben if we trade up for Draper
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Analysis 2024 National Draft

Back
Top