Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Agree with all that - I think AFL coaches are maybe getting closer to soccer managers and NFL head coaches. You're a man manager and leader - but a lot of the actual vision and innovation happens on the ground with the line coaches.I'm not a Soccer aficionado ......but isn't that basically the role of the modern Soccer Manager ?
That said, the basic gameplan has to be established, so recruiting & development know the end goal
That would be hilarious.Ranks new mate?
Both sides that played in the grand final have had massive advantages through their Academy (and father sons).It would be like us having direct access to Draper, Dodson and Sharp in consecutive drafts...quite some leg up eh
No melts with that Smith on selection night.That would be hilarious.
The media are yet to cotton on to it.Ranks new mate?
Yeah, except Fagan is neither of those, and Fagan just won a flag.If you don't have a strategic mindset, then you better be a genius game day decision maker.
Unfortunately, Nicks is neither. Lacks strategy and does not make the right calls, on game day or selection. He only has one lever and that's the "effort" lever, which he believes so strongly in and clouds his other decisions.
This basically just makes him the "father figure" and paying a head coach to be a "fatherly figure" is the biggest waste of money. This is argue could/should be someone else outside the coach.
An ABSOLUTE must.Stewart Dew. I wonder
Never a truer line written about the AFCJust hoping you'll be smarter at the draft isn't enough.
This basically just makes him the "father figure" and paying a head coach to be a "fatherly figure" is the biggest waste of money. This is argue could/should be someone else outside the coach.
With all those, why are we keeping nicks?Yeah, except Fagan is neither of those, and Fagan just won a flag.
The Lions have been smart about identifying footy thinkers to put around Fagan. So have Port with Hinkley.
So were we when we had folks like Rahilly.
That's our big issue now. We should add Montgomery AND Dew. Hell, let's bring back Teague. And add David Noble while we're there, and pay Balme to be a board member. I don't care - but we need genuine footy assets in that team.
We would still pick the wrong one.
The greatest soccer managers, Ferguson, pep, Mourinho, even Postecoglou all had a distinct startegic vision and system in terms of how they want to play and they would be uncompromising in seeing this vision become a reality. They are in complete control and are the key decision makers.Agree with all that - I think AFL coaches are maybe getting closer to soccer managers and NFL head coaches. You're a man manager and leader - but a lot of the actual vision and innovation happens on the ground with the line coaches.
Or anyone.Never a truer line written about the AFC
You have it wrongThis is exactly what Fagan is. You've got it around the wrong way - this feels like the structure that many successful teams in different sports are leaning towards.
Sure, they have a culture and vision for the team.The greatest soccer managers, Ferguson, pep, Mourinho, even Postecoglou all had a distinct startegic vision and system in terms of how they want to play and they would be uncompromising in seeing this vision become a reality. They are in complete control and are the key decision makers.
That's a terrible example.
I can't comment on NFL as I'm not familiar.
That is exactly what he is.You have it wrong
Nicks isn't a father figure though. He just threw one of his players under the bus in the media and encouraged other senior players to do similar.This is exactly what Fagan is. You've got it around the wrong way - this feels like the structure that many successful teams in different sports are leaning towards.
I don't know Fagan or know what goes on in that coaches box so can't say.Yeah, except Fagan is neither of those, and Fagan just won a flag.
The Lions have been smart about identifying footy thinkers to put around Fagan. So have Port with Hinkley.
So were we when we had folks like Rahilly.
That's our big issue now. We should add Montgomery AND Dew. Hell, let's bring back Teague. And add David Noble while we're there, and pay Balme to be a board member. I don't care - but we need genuine footy assets in that team.
Who’s the tactical mastermind at Brisbane in that case? Genuinely asking as I’m unfamiliar with their assistants right nowThat is exactly what he is.
And he just won the flag.
I’m fine with a control freak coach, if they know what they’re doing (clearly doesn’t apply to our club right now)Hasn't it been said Nicks is a bit of a control freak vs hearing Fagan or one of the assistants talking about how he's very open to delegating duties.
No, they have a distinct they want to play. They have a system that is distinct in style and structure even when they move clubs.Sure, they have a culture and vision for the team.
But they have innovative line coaches that surround them. They're not in the weeds, they're able to lead, motivate and unite.
Anyway, that's my view of where many teams are going. Obviously others do it differently, but it's interesting that one of this "fatherly motivator" group just won the flag.
One of Fagans strengths is/was he is a teacher first . He was an assistant for 16 yearsI don't know Fagan or know what goes on in that coaches box so can't say.
If he's not a known strategic thinker then you have to be great game day decision maker. Being a great game day decision maker doesn't mean you come up with the ideas, it means you read the game, know when to listen to others and change things at the right time. You don't have to be the source of those ideas. You're like the orchestrater. I suspect Fagan does a good job of this.
Nicks is clearly neither.
In fact I'm sure Nicks is the assistant that is the father figure in his previous roles, which is how it should be and is his strength.