List Mgmt. 2024 Trade & List Management Thread - Part II

[Shagga is all Class]

They won three flags off the carcass of Fitzroy and are getting number 1 kids when competing for premierships. I’d take those swings and roundabouts

From memory, I think they won a spoon after the carcass of Fitzroy.

They didn't take Pike (the best and fairest) and Lynch had left the carcass beforehand.

Jono Brown, as father son from about 51 games and Chris Johnson were pretty handy though.

 

[BrownPaperBag]

Nah the discount should not exist.
You already are getting a player your not entitled too due to ladder position.
That's a big enough bonus you don't need a discount on top.
It should be really hard to get 2 first round picks from academy or fs. Gc got 5 last year. Thats ridiculous

It’s no coincidence the grand finalists have massive leg up through academies, I don’t disagree with the concept but the mechanism needs adjustment. A post earlier linked the discount to finishing position, I think that is a great start, I also think if the bid comes in the first round you should need a first rounder in making up the value

 

[Gasometer]

From memory, I think they won a spoon after the carcass of Fitzroy.

They didn't take Pike (the best and fairest) and Lynch and had left the carcass beforehand.

Jono Brown, as father son from about 51 games and Chris Johnson were pretty handy though.

Imagine what would have happened had we merged?

On second thoughts

 

[Lomas]

From memory, I think they won a spoon after the carcass of Fitzroy.

They didn't take Pike (the best and fairest) and Lynch and had left the carcass beforehand.

Jono Brown, as father son from about 50 games and Chris Johnson were pretty handy though.

It’s not about the immediate effect, it is an accumulation of off field finance injection and on field talent. Although Fitzroy were broke, the supporter base, merger funds, and additional income through sponsors played a big role in their success.

 

[BrownPaperBag]

Remember when we went from 2002-2017 with maybe 3 top 5 picks

 

[showusyacunningt]

Yeah … he was robbed … should of had the norm smith

We got a good one. 3 goals in a grand final.

 

[Samsquanch]

It’s no coincidence the grand finalists have massive leg up through academies, I don’t disagree with the concept but the mechanism needs adjustment. A post earlier linked the discount to finishing position, I think that is a great start, I also think if the bid comes in the first round you should need a first rounder in making up the value

Didn't sydney do a dodgy pick swap with the eagles to avoid them losing their first rounder a few years back, then in a turn of good fortune, trade it back during the live trade period after they got their academy pick safely tucked in?

Or am I imagining things?

 

[Lomas]

Imagine what would have happened had we merged?

On second thoughts

As a former Fitzroy supporter, I was for the merger. As a North supporter I’m glad it didn’t happen really.

 

[Lomas]

Didn't sydney do a dodgy pick swap with the eagles to avoid them losing their first rounder a few years back, then in a turn of good fortune, trade it back during the live trade period after they got their academy pick safely tucked in?

Or am I imagining things?

I think they changed the rules after that. Or I could be imaging things too.

 

[BrownPaperBag]

Didn't sydney do a dodgy pick swap with the eagles to avoid them losing their first rounder a few years back, then in a turn of good fortune, trade it back during the live trade period after they got their academy pick safely tucked in?

Or am I imagining things?

Can’t recall but obviously that would need looking at

 

[BrownPaperBag]

We got a good one. 3 goals in a grand final.

Jayden Stephenson kicked a few in a grandy

 

[Samsquanch]

Can’t recall but obviously that would need looking at

I think Lomas might be on to something.

Another reason to be satisfied with the result today, over and above seeing Papley and the hyena miss out again.

 

[LB2Snake]

Our best father son ever has been Lmac

I reckon our best one just lost the GF today

 

[Shagga is all Class]

It’s not about the immediate effect, it is an accumulation of off field finance injection and on field talent. Although Fitzroy were broke, the supporter base, merger funds, and additional income through sponsors played a big role in their success.

This is true.

The last time we were successful, it was off the back of some production line U19s program under Pagan, some savvy recruits in Carey and Longmire signed for a 70K transfer after a guy got sacked from Sydney, and some random delisted and traded for journey men like Blakey, Bell, Roberts, Laidley and Pike. Not to mention, the Pagan ability to talk disinterested guys like McKernan and Archer to actually play footy.

The time before, we had the magical ability to recruit interstate players like Blight, get out the brown paper bags for the small window the 10 year FA rule was actually open, and just happen to hit the jackpot in our zone with guys like Grieg and Schimmelbusch at the same time (when you would bet lucky to see one of those every 20 years).

I still remember the HUN newspaper publishing the best team of players that left Fitzroy during the 90s and you would swear the team the players that left could have won a flag.

Bit like the year where the top 10 of the Coleman had about 5 ex-Carlton players.

 

[hilly]

Didn't sydney do a dodgy pick swap with the eagles to avoid them losing their first rounder a few years back, then in a turn of good fortune, trade it back during the live trade period after they got their academy pick safely tucked in?

Or am I imagining things?

Yes. AFL closed that loophole the year after. They are incredibly well-run (putting the academy access aside).

 

[Shinboner1]

If Half back is one of the most important What would be the most important position in the modern game.

HB is probably the most important position.
They generally take kickouts, command the ball in the backline and start the transition towards goal.
They also have the vision to push players around to needed spots of field and help lockdown the ball in opposition forward 50.

 

[Gumble Frankieton]

What’s wrong with tonight when he’s 10 cans in.

All of the best decisions in life are made after drinking 10 cans

 

[Gumble Frankieton]

Our best father son ever has been Lmac

I’d go with Laurie Dwyer personally

 

[Shagga is all Class]

I’d go with Laurie Dwyer personally

I was there the day David Dwyer kicked the winning goal at PP in 85 against Carlton after we were 16 points down in time on. I think Donald McDonald might have kicked 7 that day.

Don't think it was the first time we were down 16 points in time on at that ground but I believe Blight kicked all 3, to win that game.

 

[Dan]

Did today's result improve or decrease our chances of getting Parker?

 

[hilly]

Did today's result improve or decrease our chances of getting Parker?

Neither I reckon.

 

[Samsquanch]

Did today's result improve or decrease our chances of getting Parker?

He knows he ain't winning one with Sydneys.

 

[DuckYeah]

Big call still reckon he will be better than caddy at the moment probably a premiership player

Caddy would look pretty good at Brisbane too

 

[DuckYeah]

Brisbane took 158 marks in a grand final and Zorko went at 96%.

Watching the Brisbane spread live today was amazing when they win the ball at half back. They can kick.

That Zorko is a piece of shit.. But when he retires it will leave a massive gaping hole in that team.

 

[Val Keating]

That says a lot...

Our best F/S was Jesse Smith.