Autopsy AFL 2022 Second Preliminary Final - Swans v Pies Sat Sept 17th 4:45pm EST (SCG)

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

That loss will sting for years it did for me in 96 Pies wont get over it till they win a flag

 

[YeoShuey]

No we didn’t. Stevic and co always screw us. Happens every game

I saw a very clear push in the back leading to a Papley mark which should not have been paid a mark as the Collingwood guy had a fist on it prior to Papley controlling it and leading to a goal. And don’t get me started on all those 50m penalties that Sydney got.

But yeah, keep telling yourself that

 

[BringFevBack2021]

Btw love you Carlton supporters

Collingwood supporters would have you believe that it’s only about them, but when your partners cousin wins a Norm Smith for the club it’s hard to not have some kind of affiliation for that club.

Would love to see the baby Swans win it next week.

 

[The Devils Advocate]

That loss will sting for years it did for me in 96 Pies wont get over it till they win a flag

Yeah, I was 10 and remember the pain still. 99 also.

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Why are you bringing something irrelevant up, because you don't know the rules?

He didn’t go a meter over, they replayed it on the commentary several times.

Not only that but the umpire didn’t even ask him back, when a Swans player did it later he gave him and opportunity to step back.

Horrible call in a final. That was round 1 stamp your authority stuff.

 

[The Casey Cat]

Umps cost us the game. Cya next year

Oh please

 

[adammania9]

Celebrate the awesome Freo victory mate at the G.

Such a great season for you.

The whole league knew the Pies were pretenders except Pies fans. 7-0 Getting lucky in the season in close games and come finals 0-2 when against decent opposition!

Your pre season is the same length as ours!

22 years. 5 wooden spoons in that time

 

[Jimthegreat]

Since 2018, the Pies they have had a 5pts loss in a GF, 3pts loss in a PF, a SF thrashing, 17th last year with all the coaching up upheavals, and another real close loss in a knockout final by 1pt.

 

[CoastersFlag No.5]

Bobby hasn’t been happy the past few years as he doesn’t like living in Sydney. Bobby hill will play better footy at the pies with Bobby’s cousin Leon Davis also working back at Collingwood.

Yeah it's definitely a positive and it shows the impact of removing the old guard in Bucks and McGuire. Fly and Browne and the recovery from their salary cap car crash looks very bright indeed. Definitely a destination club ATM.

 

[deck]

Why is this thread full of all these fans of minnow clubs arguing over who is less futile?

When your teams been shit most your life it's all you got.

 

[maxiboy238]

Honestly credit to the pies
I will put my hand and say they were gonna get caught out in finals and get blown off the park
But to be fair they probably should of made the GF
few costly umpire decisions in the cats game
Another two minutes tonight and they win that game

 

[Thrawn]

That loss will sting for years it did for me in 96 Pies wont get over it till they win a flag

Given how many games they've pulled out of their rear end this year, they should take comfort in the fact they very easily could have not been there in the first place. No one expected them to be in a PF.

They were a Charlie Curnow herp-a-derp body snap away from not even making top 4 in the first place.

 

[adammania9]

Really, is that all you got? Coming from the club who's produced this, that's rich coming from you:

Where did Carlton finish that year

 

[Iamspock]

They aren’t but we didn’t get the rub off the green if anything the Pies did

But they determined the 2016 grand final? FWIW, good luck next week, my Mum is a devoted Swans supporter, and I will be very happy for her if the Swans get up.

 

[Maddo11]

I hope that mentally scars them and they **** off back to the doldrums where the scum club belongs

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

Your pre season is the same length as ours!

It’s not though, you will start back before the Pies do.

 

[LoungeLizard]

22 years. 5 wooden spoons in that time

I heard their next slogan is, "bring back the brown bags"

 

[Bungeye]

So I'm guessing that was a clear cut mark to Papley, or am I seeing things?

 

[jules09]

Stfu Carlton fans trolling in here. Embarrassing.
Have some ****ing dignity and respect what Collingwood have achieved this year. They beat us for good reason. A true team On the same page.
Great game of footy.

 

[BOMBERS 4 LIFE!!!!]

Yeah, I was 10 and remember the pain still. 99 also.

Yep 99 was the worst but the team made up for it by winning 2000 and ony losing one game for the year

Belting Carlton the following year in a pre lim felt so good sweet,sweet revenge

 

[Do_Beta_Rapport]

You know your club has been starved of finals when it’s a Saturday night and you are on bigfooty to give it to opposition supporters weeks after your season ends.

Chaps, enjoy the off-season ffs, there has to be some benefit to not making finals again, get off the couch!

 

[VinnieB]

Celebrate the awesome Freo victory mate at the G.

Such a great season for you.

The whole league knew the Pies were pretenders except Pies fans. 7-0 Getting lucky in the season in close games and come finals 0-2 when against decent opposition!

Your pre season is the same length as ours!

But you only ever get to see 22 games a season from your club and most of them losses. Must be really shiit.

I feel for you.

 

[kickazz]

He didn’t go a meter over, they replayed it on the commentary several times.

Not only that but the umpire didn’t even ask him back, when a Swans player did it later he gave him and opportunity to step back.

Horrible call in a final. That was round 1 stamp your authority stuff.

The big difference though is that there is no doubt where the mark was - the 9m out from goal. Players know this and they are supposed to go straight back

Still unlucky but the situations are not really comparable

 

[Jimthegreat]

Shhhh child you haven’t won anything keep dreaming okay

That's all I've had for 27 years....lol.

 

[Thrawn]

Stfu Carlton fans trolling in here. Embarrassing.
Have some ******* dignity and respect what Collingwood have achieved this year. They beat us for good reason.
Great game of footy.

Five posts in 14 years. Hmm.