Strategy Blair Hartley Project 2015 IV - Trade and Free Agency Discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do not want Carlisle! I will spew if Richmond pay a man who openly badmouthed his club anywhere near as much as the likes of Rance, who accepted unders to stay loyal to the tiges!

The club wronged him I would be bagging out the club aswell, I have no problem looking at guys who fell out of love with Essendon over what happened
 
Do not want Carlisle! I will spew if Richmond pay a man who openly badmouthed his club anywhere near as much as the likes of Rance, who accepted unders to stay loyal to the tiges!
If there's ever been circumstances where a bloke had fair grounds to bad mouth his club, it's the current bomber list after what that mob have put them through.

That said, I dont want Carlisle. He is only good coming at the footy. If You can lead up and turn him around he is no good
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Report trolls, replying just gives them attention and derails the thread.

Discussing another clubs board is off topic for this thread. Don't encourage visiting and if you see someone on another board encouraging visiting ours, report it and let their mods deal with it. If you're going to quote someone, remove the name and link to the post.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Carlisle is waaaaay over rated in my opinion. Good height, good aggression to the ball, can take a pack mark, but... shocking field disposal, poor attitude, poor work rate. Perhaps the last 2 points were due to environment but to me he's just one of the better players in a bad bunch. Any club that pays a pick higher than the mid 20s is overs I reckon.
 
Carlisle is waaaaay over rated in my opinion. Good height, good aggression to the ball, can take a pack mark, but... shocking field disposal, poor attitude, poor work rate. Perhaps the last 2 points were due to environment but to me he's just one of the better players in a bad bunch. Any club that pays a pick higher than the mid 20s is overs I reckon.
Carltoon have essendon over a barrel with this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top