Bluemour Discussion Thread XVIII - Please Sir, Can We Have More?

[Navara79]

Eddie wants his pocket back after Marc Murphy claimed it

 

[GT619]

Those saying Eddie's stats were padded by big hauls against weak sides...don't forget we also played those weak sides. I think a fit, happy Eddie would be great for a year.

Andrew Russell can fix that

 

[slashin_velvet]

Those saying Eddie's stats were padded by big hauls against weak sides...don't forget we also played those weak sides. I think a fit, happy Eddie would be great for a year.

Yep. One year deal, option for a second. Buys us another 12 months to shake the tree at other clubs, or get a small forward late in the draft who can be mentored by one of the best.

The best small forward this year (Cameron) was mentored by Betts....if we lock him down early, it could be a big drawcard for opposition players

 

[teknodeejay]

Political decision

Actually wasn’t it was an online vote decision and Collingwood swarmed it? I vaguely remember the outrage.

 

[teknodeejay]

Those saying Eddie's stats were padded by big hauls against weak sides...don't forget we also played those weak sides. I think a fit, happy Eddie would be great for a year.

True but we already beat those sides (or should).

 

[VainGlorious]

If Doc and Eddie run out together Round 1, 2020 I’ll be a bit sooky



Ill pull it together eventually but if Doc goal assists Eddie I’ll be dancing in my favourite shoes

 

[Pater44]

Actually wasn’t it was an online vote decision and Collingwood swarmed it? I vaguely remember the outrage.

100%


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Blues_fest]

Eddie kicked 37 goals this year and didn’t look like he was enjoying footy.

He would be our leading goal kicker this year with 37 goals.

Get Eddie enjoying footy again, back with Teague and the blues. He could wind the clock back.

He’s still better than what we have

Yep, buys us an extra year to find the exact small forward we need in case it doesn’t drop this year. Could even mean we use our 8 in the draft..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[ESKIE]

Even just the talk of Eddie returning is great marketing

 

[Dravid's in]

Actually wasn’t it was an online vote decision and Collingwood swarmed it? I vaguely remember the outrage.

No.

That was Howe vs Daniher in 2017.

I'll let agro fill in the details regarding the 2011 decision.....

 

[slashin_velvet]

True but we already beat those sides (or should).

Not crazy to see Top 4 spots decided on percentage

 

[SHOWEY]

I approve eddie coming home
The marketing $$$ alone validates this decision
Until we have small forwards taking his spot and kicking 37 goals he is welcome to occupy his spot
Let the healing begin
Loved daisy but daisy would not be as positive on the (predominantly younger) group as Eddie would be.
Anyone talking about bringing Jeffy back, please don't. Don't want the baggage that comes with him.

 

[Blue and Blue]

This is as silly as the Ratts for coach thing a few months back.
I can't see the club doing it. Fairytales arent part of a rebuild.

 

[manang magoos]

This is as silly as the Ratts for coach thing a few months back.
I can't see the club doing it. Fairytales arent part of a rebuild.

They can be

 

[Curnivore]

Jeff Garlett shoots a hole straight through your point though...

How so? Who was the other player who was equally talented but from say Xavier collage that we chose Garrlett over?
Talent and training come from the individual, but the 'risk factor' often comes from situations the kid can't control.

 

[Benaly28]

Imagine round one next year,the return of Eddie and Doc........salivating.

 

[GT619]

Banner says welcome home Eddie rnd 1

 

[Donstuie]

From a respected ITK poster from another forum.

I wonder how young Ollie's chat went with David last night...

#Bluemour

 

[The Blue Weirdo]

This is as silly as the Ratts for coach thing a few months back.
I can't see the club doing it. Fairytales arent part of a rebuild.

Think this belongs in the un-popular opinions thread.

 

[Pixelshooter]

If we can't get Papley or Martin this year, Eddie would have to be worth a punt. Especially considering he wouldn't be on a huge contract and it was just a year by year proposition.

 

[Blue and Blue]

Think this belongs in the un-popular opinions thread.

Could be Weirdo.....
I would be happy to see it from the romantic viewpoint don't get me wrong but that is the heart not the mind.

Stranger things have happened but it would be a big risk and if it backfired folks here will be after the list peoples heads. Again.

 

[myblueroan]

If we can't get Papley or Martin this year, Eddie would have to be worth a punt. Especially considering he wouldn't be on a huge contract and it was just a year by year proposition.

No no no.
As well!!

 

[skadoosh]

From a respected ITK poster from another forum.



#Bluemour

I was going to ask who David was...and then it actually hit me....
Who calls him 'David' anyway?

 

[Dravid's in]

Penberthy certainly not backing down this morning.

Describing Betts as miserable and depressed at the Football Club.

Can't see anyone staying under those circumstances. Whether it's us, another club, or retirement is seemingly the only remaining options.

 

[TBellicious]

I was going to ask who David was...and then it actually hit me....
Who calls him 'David' anyway?

Yeah, it’s Mr. Train thank you very much