Burgatron 2008 - Merged Threads

Remove this Banner Ad

Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Warwick said:
You serious?

I couldn't imagine anything worse after just being drafted to be swamped by a bunch of people you have never met.
Click to expand...

Agreed, first thing I would want to do is go home to friends and family.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Interesting from a Geelong perspective that he doesn't mention O'Keefe but does have us picking Cornelius.
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Intersting Pies Picks:

11 – COLLINGWOOD – STEPHEN HILL
West Perth, WA, Small/medium midfielder, May 1, 1990, 183.7cm, 68.9kg
(Draft range: 3-12)

Hill could go as early as No.3 to Fremantle, while Essendon, Carlton or North Melbourne are also interested. Or is he the one who just slides outside of the top 10? Expect the Pies to swoop if available. There is another intriguing part to Collingwood's first selection – the continual link with Queenslander Dayne Beams. The Magpies are believed to be eager to recruit the stoppage midfielder, but will he last until their second pick at No.29? The Pies have also been closely aligned with Tom Swift, who is regarded as a first-round/priority selection.
Click to expand...

29 – COLLINGWOOD – DAYNE BEAMS
Southport, QLD, Medium midfielder, February 12, 1990, 186.2cm, 76.9kg
(Draft range: 11-29)

For quite some time now Beams has been closely linked with the Pies after knocking back an offer to play with Gold Coast. Beams is a genuine top 30 selection and has been mooted strongly at No.11, Collingwood's first selection. He is condiered the ideal stoppage player replacement for recently retired captain Scott Burns. The question with Collingwood and Beams is will he slide through to No.29? Opinion is divided, with Melbourne, Port Adelaide, Essendon and the Brisbane Lions also considering him.
Click to expand...


45 – COLLINGWOOD – SAM WRIGHT
Murray Bushrangers, VIC, Medium forward, July 15, 1990, 188.1cm, 76kg
(Draft range: 28-54)

Highly-rated by the Pies, Wright could conceivably land at No.29 and it's unlikely he would slip past Collingwood's back-to-back picks at No.45 and No.46. He is also attracting interest from Adelaide, Hawthorn, West Coast and Port Adelaide. Stanley, Mangan, Rounds, Shiels, DeBoer, Benjamin, Bucovaz and Taylor Hunt have also been linked to the Pies with these picks.
Click to expand...
46 – COLLINGWOOD – TOM GILLIES
Dandenong Stingrays, VIC, Tall defender, March 7, 1990, 192.3cm, 86.5kg
(Draft range: 29-50)

With St Kilda (47 and 48) and Hawthorn (50) very interested in Gillies, the Pies are likely to swoop on the full-back before them. That's unless the Hawks fly under the radar at No.34. He has certainly come up the pecking order in recent weeks. Stanley, Mangan and DeBoer will again be strongly considered here if not taken at No.45.
Click to expand...

3 – COLLINGWOOD – SHANE SAVAGE
Dandenong Stingrays, VIC, Medium midfielder, January 5, 1991, 185.1cm, 74.5kg
(Draft range: 59-not selected)

Savage, a bottom-age player, has attracted considerable interest late in the draft, with Hawthorn, North Melbourne and Collingwood all interested. It is the Pies' final pick, and more than likely will be used. Other names to monitor late for the Magpies are Tom Hill, Jamie Bennell, Cockie, Gilligan, Kyal Horsley and Jack Weston. And don't discount ex-Roo Leigh Brown.
Click to expand...


We are Interested In:

Ziebell
Swift
Mitch Robinson
Jarrad Blight
Will Young
Rhys Stanlry
Do Boer
ROUNDS
Warren Benjiman
Luke Thompson
Cockie
Sheils
Taylor Hunt
Mangan
Tom Hill
Hislop
Buchoavz

 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

I don't like his any better than half the ones on here. Freo are supposedly targetting mids and he hasn't got us taking many at all.
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Both the Herald Sun and Burgman have us taking Hurley at 5. However, based on much of the discussion on here and Quayle's opinions, we are more likely to take a mid (e.g. Hatlett or Yarran).
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

chook2734 said:
I don't like his any better than half the ones on here. Freo are supposedly targetting mids and he hasn't got us taking many at all.
Click to expand...


Yeh, doesnt seem overly different to Bigfooty group think either. Maybe people on here got it pretty right this year.
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Cahill & Klemke slide, and Clayton picks a smokey again. Nick Davis picked up in Burgan's opinion too.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

From an Essendon point of view I'll be pissed. Hurley I can accept but Zaharitas is way too high. I'd rather Heyne at 23. But I'd still rather a midfielder at 5 and Post or Lisle at 23. He knows his stuff but fair dinkum I hope he is wrong on Saturday!
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Why would we be interested in Lynch. How many undersized KPP forwards do we have already? Has Burgatron ever heard of Mathhew Bate
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

bombersno1 said:
From an Essendon point of view I'll be pissed. Hurley I can accept but Zaharitas is way too high. I'd rather Heyne at 23. But I'd still rather a midfielder at 5 and Post or Lisle at 23. He knows his stuff but fair dinkum I hope he is wrong on Saturday!
Click to expand...

Same here. I don't want Hurley, if we are to take a KPP at 5, I would prefer Trengove.
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Surpised he has Pies taking Hill
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

Pawtucket Patriot said:
Same here. I don't want Hurley, if we are to take a KPP at 5, I would prefer Trengove.
Click to expand...

Dead agreed. Trengove suits our team more, and gosh knows why we are linked to Heyne at 5 and pass on him at 23..
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

ROUND ONE

1 – MELBOURNE – JACK WATTS
2 – WEST COAST – NICHOLAS NAITANUI
3 – FREMANTLE – DANIEL RICH
4 – PORT ADELAIDE – HAMISH HARTLETT
5 – ESSENDON – MICHAEL HURLEY
6 – CARLTON – CHRIS YARRAN
7 – BRISBANE LIONS – JACK ZIEBELL
8 - RICHMOND - TYRONE VICKERY
9 – NORTH MELBOURNE – STEELE SIDEBOTTOM
10 – ADELAIDE – JACKSON TRENGOVE
11 – COLLINGWOOD – STEPHEN HILL
12 – SYDNEY SWANS – LEWIS JOHNSTON
13 – ST KILDA – SAM BLEASE
14 – WESTERN BULLDOGS – AYCE CORDY
15 – GEELONG – ASHLEY SMITH
16 – HAWTHORN – PHIL DAVIS

PRIORITY ROUND
17 – MELBOURNE – TOM LYNCH
18 – WEST COAST EAGLES – TOM SWIFT

ROUND TWO
19 – MELBOURNE – JORDAN ROUGHEAD
20 – WEST COAST – RYAN SCHOENMAKERS
21 – FREMANTLE – SHAUN McKERNAN
22 – PORT ADELAIDE – MITCH BROWN
23 – ESSENDON – DAVID ZAHARAKIS
24 – FREMANTLE – NICK HEYNE
25 – BRISBANE LIONS – MITCH ROBINSON
26 – RICHMOND – JAYDYN POST
27 – NORTH MELBOURNE – JORDAN LISLE
28 – ADELAIDE – LUKE SHUEY
29 – COLLINGWOOD – DAYNE BEAMS
30 – SYDNEY SWANS – NICK SUBAN
31 – WESTERN BULLDOGS – LIAM JONES
32 – WESTERN BULLDOGS – TOM LEE
33 – GEELONG – MATTHEW BROADBENT
34 – HAWTHORN – JAMES STRAUSS


ROUND THREE
35 – MELBOURNE – MICHAEL WALTERS
36 – WEST COAST – JARRAD BLIGHT
37 – FREMANTLE – HAYDEN BALLANTYNE
38 – PORT ADELAIDE – JARRAD REDDEN
39 – GEELONG – AARON CORNELIUS
40 – CARLTON – WILL YOUNG
41 – BRISBANE LIONS – RHYS STANLEY
42 – PORT ADELAIDE – RORY SLOANE
43 – NORTH MELBOURNE – DAN HANNEBERY
44 – ADELAIDE – CASEY SIBASADO
45 – COLLINGWOOD – SAM WRIGHT
46 – COLLINGWOOD – TOM GILLIES
47 – ST KILDA – STEVEN GAERTNER
48 – ST KILDA – MATTHEW DEBOER
49 – GEELONG – LUKE ROUNDS
50 – HAWTHORN – RHYS O'KEEFE

ROUND FOUR
51 – MELBOURNE – NEVILLE JETTA
52 – WEST COAST – JAMIE BENNELL
53 – FREMANTLE – WARREN BENJAMIN
54 – PORT ADELAIDE – STEVEN MOTLOP
55 – ESSENDON – LUKE THOMPSON
56 – FREMANTLE – CLANCEE PEARCE
57 – BRISBANE LIONS – JACK REDDEN
58 – RICHMOND – ADAM COCKIE
59 – NORTH MELBOURNE – LIAM SHIELS
60 – ADELAIDE – ZAC CLARKE
61 – SYDNEY SWANS – ALISTAIR SMITH
62 – ST KILDA – TAYLOR HUNT
63 – HAWTHORN – JORDAN JONES
ROUND FIVE

64 – MELBOURNE – GLEN DAWSON
65 – CARLTON – BRAD MANGAN
66 – PORT ADELAIDE – MITCHELL BANNER
67 – ESSENDON – BART McCULLOCH
68 – FREMANTLE – TOM HILL
69 – BRISBANE LIONS – ROHAN BAIL
70 – RICHMOND – TOM HISLOP
71 – NORTH MELBOURNE – TOM ROCKLIFF
72 – ADELAIDE – BEN BUCOVAZ
73 – COLLINGWOOD – SHANE SAVAGE
74 – ST KILDA – LUKE LOWDEN
75 – HAWTHORN – DANNY MEYER

ROUND SIX
76 – MELBOURNE – PASS
77 – FREMANTLE – MATTHEW MOODY
78 – PORT ADELAIDE – PAUL CAHILL
79 – ESSENDON – KADE KLEMKE
80 – CARLTON – ROBIN NAHAS
81 – BRISBANE LIONS – NICK DAVIS
82 – BRISBANE LIONS – PASS - (USE ON COUSINS IN PSD?)
83 – ST KILDA – NATHAN CARROLL

ROUND SEVEN
84 – PORT ADELAIDE – PASS
85 – CARLTON – PASS
 
Re: Burgatron's Phantom Draft Due Today

bombersno1 said:
Dead agreed. Trengove suits our team more, and gosh knows why we are linked to Heyne at 5 and pass on him at 23..
Click to expand...

Damages the credibility of his draft, I reckon.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Burgatron 2008 - Merged Threads

Similar threads

Smythe
Draft Watcher SMYTHE's 2024 Draft Thread
8 9 10 11 12
Replies
291
Views
53K
T4P
T
PMBangers
Draft Expert PMBangers 2024 Draft Thread and psuedo general draft discussion apparently
16 17 18 19 20
Replies
483
Views
71K
Tasmanian saint
T
Davo-27
Draft Expert Davo-27's 2024 Draft Thread
43 44 45 46 47
Replies
1K
Views
174K
tenderwarrior
tenderwarrior
F
Phantom Draft Footy Head's 2023 Draft Thread
Replies
0
Views
3K
Footy Heads
F
PMBangers
Draft Expert PMBangers 2023 Draft Thread
70 71 72 73 74
Replies
2K
Views
223K
Holy Hunter Clark
Holy Hunter Clark
M
Draft Expert ModernArtillery 2023 Draft Thread
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
125
Views
32K
chels
C
Davo-27
Draft Expert Davo-27's 2023 Draft Thread
36 37 38 39 40
Replies
985
Views
144K
Mutineer
Mutineer

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top