calling all wannabe draft experts

[Cursed Cat]

1 week left till the draft, get yer selections in and cover yourself in glory

 

[synista]

1. Marc Murphy
2. Xav Ellis
3. Josh Kennedy
4. Patrick Ryder
5. Shannon Hurn
6. Mitchell Clark
7. Nathan Jones
8. Marcus Drum
9. Beau Dowler
10. Shaun Higgins
11. Cleve Hughes
12. Austin Lucy
13. Richard Douglas
14. Cleve Hughes
15. Grant Birchall
16. Darren Pfeiffer
17. Travis Varcoe
18. Dale Thomas
19. Ben McKinley
20. Nick Lower
21. Trent West
22. Matt Spangher
23. Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls
24. Daany Stanley
25.Todd Grima

No Andrew Swallow?

 

[smthomson]

Thomo's Top 20!

1. Carlton - Marc Murphy
2. Collingwood - Xavier Ellis
3. Hawthorn - Josh Kennedy
4. Carlton - Patrick Ryder
5. Collingwood - Shannon Hurn
6. Hawtorn - Mitchell Clark
7. Essendon - Andrew Swallow
8. Richmond - Beau Dowler
9. Brisbane - Austin Lucy
10.Fremantle - Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls
11. Western Bulldogs - Marcus Drum
12. Melbourne - Nathan Jones
13. West Coast - Cleve Hughes
14. Hawthorn - Travis Varcoe
15. Geelong - Shaun Higgins
16. Adelaide - Tom Rischbieth
17. Adelaide - Dale Thomas
18. Hawthorn - Courtney Dempsey
19. Essendon - Grant Birchall
20. Carlton - Matthew Spangher

 

[Threadkilla]

I'll have a crack:

1) Carlton Mark Murphy
2) Collingwood Shannon Hurn
3) Hawthorn Patrick Ryder
4) Carlton Beau Dowler
5) Collingwood Xavier Ellis
6) Hawthorn Josh Kennedy
7) Essendon Andrew Swallow
8) Richmond Mitchell Clark
9) Brisbane Austin Lucy
10) Fremantle Marcus Drum
11) Western Bulldogs Cleve Hughes
12) Melbourne Nathan Jones
13) West Coast Scott Pendleberry
14) Hawthorn Beau Muston
15) Geelong Shaun Higgins
16) Adelaide Darren Pfeiffer
17) Adelaide Travis Varcoe
18) Hawthorn Dale Thomas
19) West Coast Todd Grima
20) Carlton Matthew Spangher
21) Collingwood Tom Rischbieth
22) Hawthorn Richard Douglas
23) Collingwood Ben McKinley
24) Richmond Jarred Oakley-Nichols
25) Brisbane Paul Bower
26) Fremantle Grant Birchall
27) Western Bulldogs Courtney Dempsey
28) Kangaroos Matt Thomas
29) West Coast Alan Toovey
30) Port Adelaide Jace Bode
31) Geelong Trent West
32) Adelaide Alan Obst
33) St Kilda Luke McEntee
34) West Coast Garrick Ibbotson
35) Geelong Danny Stanley
36) Carlton Matthew Laidlaw
37) Collingwood Ryan Jackson
38) Hawthorn Travis Tuck (F/S)
39) Essendon Jay Neagle (F/S)
40) Richmond Marcus Crook
41) Brisbane Rhan Hooper
42) Fremantle Grae Grant
43) Kangaroos Tim Looby
44) Port Adelaide Sam Lonergan
45) Kangaroos Shane Woewodin
46) Western Bulldogs James Podsiadly

 

[superstar_09]

1) Marc Murphy

Garaunteed win with 100%

 

[blumfieldisback]

I'll have a crack:

1) Carlton Mark Murphy
2) Collingwood Shannon Hurn
3) Hawthorn Patrick Ryder
4) Carlton Beau Dowler
5) Collingwood Xavier Ellis
6) Hawthorn Josh Kennedy
7) Essendon Andrew Swallow
8) Richmond Mitchell Clark
9) Brisbane Austin Lucy
10) Fremantle Marcus Drum
11) Western Bulldogs Cleve Hughes
12) Melbourne Nathan Jones
13) West Coast Scott Pendleberry
14) Hawthorn Beau Muston
15) Geelong Shaun Higgins
16) Adelaide Darren Pfeiffer
17) Adelaide Travis Varcoe
18) Hawthorn Dale Thomas
19) West Coast Todd Grima
20) Carlton Matthew Spangher
21) Collingwood Tom Rischbieth
22) Hawthorn Richard Douglas
23) Collingwood Ben McKinley
24) Richmond Jarred Oakley-Nichols
25) Brisbane Paul Bower
26) Fremantle Grant Birchall
27) Western Bulldogs Courtney Dempsey
28) Kangaroos Matt Thomas
29) West Coast Alan Toovey
30) Port Adelaide Jace Bode
31) Geelong Trent West
32) Adelaide Alan Obst
33) St Kilda Luke McEntee
34) West Coast Garrick Ibbotson
35) Geelong Danny Stanley
36) Carlton Matthew Laidlaw
37) Collingwood Ryan Jackson
38) Hawthorn Travis Tuck (F/S)
39) Essendon Jay Neagle (F/S)
40) Richmond Marcus Crook
41) Brisbane Rhan Hooper
42) Fremantle Grae Grant
43) Kangaroos Tim Looby
44) Port Adelaide Sam Lonergan
45) Kangaroos Shane Woewodin
46) Western Bulldogs James Podsiadly

at 19 you had west coast it should be essendon will u still say dale thomas at 19

 

[blumfieldisback]

oh by the way with muston out for a further 6 months with knee trouble i suspect he might even drop down to rookie status?

 

[John Connel]

#1 M. Murphy
#2 J. Kennedy
#3 X. Ellis
#4 S. Hurn
#5 A. Swallow
#6 P. Ryder
#7 C. Hughes
#8 A. Lucy
#9 N. Jones
#10 M. Clark

 

[worthy]

#1 - Carl - Murphy
#2 - Coll - Hurn
#3 - Haw - Kennedy
#4 - Carl - Ryder
#5 - Coll - Swallow
#6 - Haw - Ellis
#7 - Ess - Varcoe
#8 - Rich - Dowler
#9 - Bris - Bower
#10 - Freo - Clarke

 

[DannyJ]

No Andrew Swallow?

My bad, i had to edit it

 

[Dunst]

My top 10.

1.murphy.
2.ellis.
3.kennedy.
4.hurn.
5.ryder.
6.dowler.
7.swallow.
8.jones.
9.lucy.
10.clarke

 

[cobba]

matty white will go to the tigers at pick 40, book mark it

 

[burner1]

1. Murphy
2. Ellis
3. Dowler
4. Ryder
5. Kennedy
6. Varcoe
7. Hurn
8. Clarke
9. Drum
10. Swallow
11. Hughes
12. Jones
13. Pfeiffer
14. Muston
15. Douglas
16. Birchall
17. Oakley-Nicholls
18. McEntee
19. Dempsey
20. Higgins
21. Lucy
22. Markovic

 

[Pharaoh]

1. Murphy
2. Ellis
3. Dowler
4. Ryder
5. Kennedy
6. Varcoe
7. Hurn
8. Clarke
9. Drum
10. Swallow
11. Hughes
12. Jones
13. Pfeiffer
14. Muston
15. Douglas
16. Birchall
17. Oakley-Nicholls
18. McEntee
19. Dempsey
20. Higgins
21. Lucy
22. Markovic

That's an interesting list. Anything you know about the Hawks that we don't, or are you just taking a punt?

 

[Pharaoh]

1) Carlton - Mark Murphy
2) Collingwood - Xavier Ellis
3) Hawthorn - Shannon Hurn
4) Carlton - Beau Dowler
5) Collingwood - Josh Kennedy
6) Hawthorn - Patrick Ryder
7) Essendon - Andrew Swallow
8) Richmond - Mitchell Clark
9) Brisbane - Austin Lucy
10) Fremantle - Jarred Oakley Nicholls
11) Western Bulldogs - Cleve Hughes
12) Melbourne - Nathan Jones
13) West Coast - Marcus Drum
14) Hawthorn - Darren Pfeiffer
15) Geelong - Shaun Higgins
16) Adelaide - Travis Varcoe
17) Adelaide - Tom Rischbieth
18) Hawthorn - Dale Thomas
19) West Coast - Paul Bower
20) Carlton - Grant Birchall

 

[Slick]

1. Carlton - Mark Murphy
2. Collingwood - Xavier Ellis
3. Hawthorn - Josh Kennedy
4. Carlton - Patrick Ryder
5. Collingwood - Shannon Hurn
6. Hawthorn - Beau Dowler
7. Essendon - Nathan Jones
8. Richmond - Mitchell Clark
9. Brisbane - Austin Lucy
10. Fremantle - Andrew Swallow
11. Western Bulldogs - Cleve Hughes
12. Melbourne - Shaun Higgins
13. West Coast - Beau Muston
14. Hawthorn - Travis Varcoe
15. Geelong - Grant Birchall
16. Adelaide - Todd Grima
17. Adelaide - Dale Thomas
18. Hawthorn - Jarred Oakley-Nicholls
19. Essendon - Darren Pfeiffer
20. Carlton - Tom Rischbieth
21. Collingwood - Richard Douglas
22. Hawthorn - Luke McEntee
23. Collingwood - Matthew Spangher
24. Richmond - Scott Pendelbury
25. Brisbane - Paul Bower

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

1. Carlton - Mark Murphy
2. Collingwood -Josh Kennedy
3. Hawthorn - Xavier Ellis
4. Carlton - Shannon Hurn
5. Collingwood - Nathan Jones
6. Hawthorn - Patrick Ryder
7. Essendon - Cleave Hughes
8. Richmond - Beau Dowler
9. Brisbane - Andrew Swallow
10. Fremantle - Marcus Drum
11. Western Bulldogs -Mitchell Clark
12. Melbourne - Jarrod Oakley-Nicholls
13. West Coast -Dale Thomas
14. Hawthorn - Travis Vacroe
15. Geelong - Darren Pfeiffer
16. Adelaide - Todd Grima
17. Adelaide -Tom Rischbieth
18. Hawthorn -Shaun Higgins
19. Essendon -Grant Birchell
20. Carlton - Mathew Spangher
21. Collingwood -Richard Douglas
22. Hawthorn - Alan Toovey
23. Collingwood -Austin Lucy
24. Richmond - Paul Bower
40.Richmond- Matt Seal

 

[Trav 20]

1. Carlton - Mark Murphy
2. Collingwood - Xavier Ellis
3. Hawthorn - Josh Kennedy
4. Carlton - Patrick Ryder
5. Collingwood - Shannon Hurn
6. Hawthorn - Beau Dowler
7. Essendon - Nathan Jones
8. Richmond - Mitchell Clark
9. Brisbane - Austin Lucy
10. Fremantle - Andrew Swallow
11. Western Bulldogs - Cleve Hughes
12. Melbourne - Shaun Higgins
13. West Coast - Beau Muston
14. Hawthorn - Travis Varcoe
15. Geelong - Shaun Higgins
16. Adelaide - Todd Grima
17. Adelaide - Dale Thomas
18. Hawthorn - Jarred Oakley-Nicholls
19. Essendon - Darren Pfeiffer
20. Carlton - Tom Rischbieth
21. Collingwood - Richard Douglas
22. Hawthorn - Luke McEntee
23. Collingwood - Matthew Spangher
24. Richmond - Scott Pendelbury
25. Brisbane - Paul Bower

Dees or Cats ?

 

[Trav 20]

Roughly with not all clubs needs included. Also i dont know if that order is right
1. Carlton- Marc Murphy
2. Collingwood- Josh Kennedy
3. Hawthorn- Xavier Ellis
4. Carlton- Pat Ryder
5. Collingwood- Shannon Hurn
6. Hawthorn- Mitch Clarke
7. Essendon- Andrew Swallow
8. Richmond- Cleve Hughes
9. Brisbane- Marcus Drum
10. Fremantle- Jarred Oakley-Nicholls
11. Bulldogs- Beau Dowler
12. Melbourne- Nathan Jones
13. West Coast- Todd Grima
14. Hawthorn- Dale Thomas
15. Geelong- Richard Douglas
16. Adelaide- Darren Pfeiffer
17. Adelaide- Travis Varcoe
18. Hawthorn- Courtenay Dempsey
19. Essendon- Grant Birchall
20. Carlton- Paul Bower
21. Collingwood- Beau Muston
22. Hawthorn- Tom Rischbieth
23. Collingwood- Austin Lucy
24. Richmond- Matt Spangher
25. Brisbane- Courteney Dempsey
26. Fremantle- Nick Lower
27. Bulldogs- Alan Obst
28. Kangaroos- Sam Iles
29. West Coast- Alan Toovey
30. Port Adelaide- Jace Bode
31. Geelong- Scott Pendlebury
32. Adelaide- Luke McEntee
33. St. Kilda- Wayde Mills
34. West Coast- Ed Lower
35. Geelong- Matt Laidlaw
36. Carlton- Ryan Jackson
37. Collingwood- Brad Kelleher
38. Hawthorn- F/S Travis Tuck
39. Essendon- F/S Jay Neagle
40. Richmond- Matt Seal
41- Brisbane- Ben McKinley
42- Fremantle- Brennan Mills
43- Kangaroos- Rhan Hooper
44- Port Adelaide- Trent West

Couldn't squeeze Shaun Higgins into your top 44 ?

 

[Back Pocket Rocket]

1. Carlton - Marc Murphy
2. Collingwood -Xavier Ellis
3. Hawthorn - Shannon Hurn
4. Carlton - Beau Dowler
5. Collingwood - Josh Kennedy
6. Hawthorn - Patrick Ryder
7. Essendon - Andrew Swallow
8. Richmond - Cleve Hughes
9. Brisbane - Marcus Drum
10. Fremantle - Mitchell Clarke
11. Western Bulldogs - Richard Douglas
12. Melbourne - Nathan Jones
13. West Coast - Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls
14. Hawthorn - Dale Thomas
15. Geelong - Shaun Higgins
16. Adelaide - Darren Pfeiffer
17. Adelaide - Travis Varcoe
18. Hawthorn - Beau Muston
19. Essendon - Tom Rischbieth
20. Carlton - Austin Lucy
21. Collingwood - Grant Birchall
22. Hawthorn - Luke McEntee

As a Hawk supporter I would be happy with this outcome (1 ruck, 1 KPP/Ruck, 2 quick mids and a hard at it midfielder)

 

[burner1]

That's an interesting list. Anything you know about the Hawks that we don't, or are you just taking a punt?

Nah, mate just having a punt, thought i try to make a slightly different list to the others and try a diff top 6 and see what happens with the rest as not entirely sold on ryder and kennedy for the hawks from what read on BF (and as PA always seems to go slightly against consensus with picks now with Pelchin thought maybe we might do the same), but hawks get CHF, fast mid, classy mid, Ruck & FF which to seems about right to me. (but big injury risks however)

 

[Benno_900]

1. Carlton - Marc Murphy
2. Collingwood - Xavier Ellis
3. Hawthorn - Josh Kennedy
4. Carlton - Shannon Hurn
5. Collingwood - Patrick Ryder
6. Hawthorn - Beau Dowler
7. Essendon - Mitchell Clark
8. Richmond - Marcus Drum
9. Brisbane - Nathan Jones
10. Fremantle - Andrew Swallow
11. Bulldogs - Jarrad Oakley-Nicholls
12. Melbourne - Dale Thomas
13. West Coast - Cleve Hughes
14. Hawthorn – Austin Lucy
15. Geelong - Grant Birchall
16. Adelaide - Darren Pfeiffer
17. Adelaide - Scott Pendlebury
18. Hawthorn – Richard Douglas
19. Essendon - Ryan Jackson
20. Carlton - Shaun Higgins
21. Collingwood - Beau Muston
22. Hawthorn - Travis Varcoe
23. Collingwood - Ben McKinley
24. Richmond - Alan Toovey
25. Brisbane - Courtenay Dempsey
26. Fremantle - Paul Bower
27. Bulldogs - Todd Grima
28. Kangaroos - Matthew Spangher
29. West Coast - Luke McEntee
30. Port Adelaide - Jace Bode

 

[cobba]

if we dont get grima, id be happy with Matthew Spangher

 

[purebomber]

1.M.Murphy
2.X.Ellis
3.P.Ryder
4.B.Dowler
5.S.Hurn
6.G.Birchall
7.M.Clark
8.J.Kennedy
9.A.Swallow
10.J.O-Nicholls
11.M.Drum
12.D.Pfeiffer
13.P.Bower
14.S.Pendlebury
15.S.Higgins
16.T.Varcoe
17.Laidlaw
18.Lucy
19.R.Douglas

 

[king_Brown]

Here we go........


1.Carlton-Marc Murphy
2.Collingwood-Shannon Hurn
3.Hawthorn-Josh Kennedy
4.Carlton-Beau Dowler
5.Collingwood-Dale Thomas
6.Hawthorn-Xavier Ellis
7.Essendon-Darren Pfieffer
8.Richmond-Mitch Clarke
9.Brisbane-Paul Bower
10.Fremantle-Andrew Swallow
11.Western Bulldogs-Patrick Ryder
12.MElbourne-Nathan Jones
13.West Coast-Jarrad Oakliegh-Nicholls
14.Hawthorn-Marcus Drum
15.Geelong-Cleve Hughes
16.Adelaide-Scott Pendelberry
17.Adelaide-Travis Varcoe
18.Hawthorn-Richard Douglas
19.Essendon-Grant Birchall
20.Carlton-Matthew Spangher
21.Collingwood-Shaun Higgins
22.Hawthorn-Luke McEntee
23.Collingwood-Ben McKinley
24.Richmond-Wayde Mills
25.Brisbane-Austin Lucy
26.Fremantle-Jace Bode
27.Western Bulldogs-Beau Muston
28.Kangaroos-Todd Grima
29.West Coast- Tom Rischbieth
30.Port Adelaide-Trent West


This is my top 30 probly wont end up anything like this haha