Unofficial Preview Changes and In the Mix V Collingwood Rd 8

[iameviljez]

No I think he is referring to Jonathan Simpkon

I thought it might have been Todd Sampson

 

[AlcoaCat]

Out: Z Guthrie

Yes, a thousand times, yes. He needs some time in the gym and in the VFL. Talented kid, but he is heading for a serious bone crunching hit which may permanently damage his confidence .

Anyone remember the almighty smack Billie smedts copped in a preseason against Collingwood at KP in 2014? I thought then that Smedts would find that kind of treatment hard to cope with. Zuthers reminds me so much of Billie in that regard.

 

[Strange Cat]

Yes, a thousand times, yes. He needs some time in the gym and in the VFL. Talented kid, but he is heading for a serious bone crunching hit which may permanently damage his confidence .

Anyone remember the almighty smack Billie smedts copped in a preseason against Collingwood at KP in 2014? I thought then that Smedts would find that kind of treatment hard to cope with. Zuthers reminds me so much of Billie in that regard.

To be fair Zuthrie has already copped some tough tackles and is a lot stronger than what he looks...miles ahead of Smedts in that regard.

However, I agree he should have a rest in the VFL when Taylor becomes available

 

[steady2]

... Cunico?

Probably. He's been very good, tough for him but George is a lock after his last full game.

 

[Tony Barber]

I think you mean Sam Simpson, who, most interestingly, the AFL Injury List has as Scott Simpson...

Anyway, he's injured.

It was a joke Joyce.

 

[Footy Smarts]

Kolodjashnij back to a wing, eh? So move a player who has found his niche playing as a key defender back to a position he obviously struggled at in previous attempts. He lacks the polish and poise to play through the midfield.

Obviously struggled in? He was far better on a wing last year than he'd been as a key defender previously. Didn't he have one of the highest votes per game in our B&F playing mostly as a wingman last year? He's been good this year and I'd leave him down back but we're not exactly stocked for defensively minded mids and he did a good job for us there last year. It's definitely an option.

 

[Down at K Park]

Can't drop Stanley after his performance on Friday night. Farmer will have to come back via the twos.

Yes we can drop stanley. He played against 2 fwds, not ruckmen so he had it easy. Grundy will destroy him.

But it all depends on wether zacs back is ok.

 

[iameviljez]

It was a joke Joyce.

Poe's Law!

 

[Vdubs]

Surely chris Scott drunk....

...a cup of tea. So he was serious , and it made total sense.

 

[Vdubs]

Omitting all 4

If Hawk gets weeks Crameri stays in

Just can't drop Henry for Taylor after last night so

Parfitt - Murdoch
Taylor - Guthrie
Menzel - Crameri
Ablett - Gregson

Forget Parfitt next week, I hope. I love him. We need him LT. No need to rush back a bone bruised foot.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Obviously struggled in? He was far better on a wing last year than he'd been as a key defender previously. Didn't he have one of the highest votes per game in our B&F playing mostly as a wingman last year? He's been good this year and I'd leave him down back but we're not exactly stocked for defensively minded mids and he did a good job for us there last year. It's definitely an option.

Lol.

I can see why Willo_ has gone.

 

[Stan The Caddy]

Why do you think Parfitt is coming back in? He has a stress reaction to his foot which usually mean navicular which isn’t a two week recovery time

What a load of crap.

 

[Shai]

Anyone watching the Pies game against Lions, right now..?

Our team needs to be selected on merit but also to nullify any strengths the opps are displaying.

 

[Boxhead_31]

What a load of crap.

Which part?

 

[Stan The Caddy]

Which part?

The navicular part...

 

[dazbroncos]

The navicular part...

The report from the club was that he has a foot issue and a hot spot of sorts was found in the scans - albeit an inconclusive one.

The worst outcome would be a Navicular issue - It has not been confirmed but its a reason for caution.
GO Catters

 

[Boxhead_31]

The navicular part...

How many foot scans have we had come back saying that they have identified a hot spot in a players foot and they have not turned out to be a navicular?

 

[foxdog50]

The report from the club was that he has a foot issue and a hot spot of sorts was found in the scans - albeit an inconclusive one.

The worst outcome would be a Navicular issue - It has not been confirmed but its a reason for caution.
GO Catters

What happen to the club use to do a weekly update which that phisyo of our club? It was good getting a weekly update..

 

[Stan The Caddy]

The report from the club was that he has a foot issue and a hot spot of sorts was found in the scans - albeit an inconclusive one.

The worst outcome would be a Navicular issue - It has not been confirmed but its a reason for caution.
GO Catters

Lol, so we have no idea whether it's the navicular bone or not but just to be on the safe side we're saying that it is? Doesn't make sense to me Daz. Let's just wait until we find out more I reckon.

 

[allrighty]

I wouldn’t be resting Sav. Runs at the contest, crashes packs and tables clunks.
The pies have an undersized defence so I’d keep him in.

Maybe Crameri an unlucky out?

Crameri stays to cover Hawk out for 11 weeks

 

[allrighty]

It's possible we'll get Gazza & the Q9 back next week, keeping my fingers crossed for that.

Leave Harry to recover/train for another week I reckon

 

[dazbroncos]

Lol, so we have no idea whether it's the navicular bone or not but just to be on the safe side we're saying that it is? Doesn't make sense to me Daz. Let's just wait until we find out more I reckon.

The club are resting it to avoid it getting to a worst case that comes with continued work on a hot spot. Does not mean its a Navicular issue but they are trying to avoid one whilst trying to diagnose exactly what it is.

sounds pretty logical to me.

GO Catters

 

[Stan The Caddy]

How many foot scans have we had come back saying that they have identified a hot spot in a players foot and they have not turned out to be a navicular?

Have we heard that he's even got a hot spot though? And it could also be any one of the metatarsals.

 

[Shai]

If Smith is right, bring him in by all means, a hybrid of him & Stanley would be ideal.

There are more positions than ruck, that we need to take into consideration.

 

[Stan The Caddy]

The club are resting it to avoid it getting to a worst case that comes with continued work on a hot spot. Does not mean its a Navicular issue but they are trying to avoid one whilst trying to diagnose exactly what it is.

sounds pretty logical to me.

GO Catters

I'll give you the hot tip mate, they already know what it is. They're just not telling us.