Changes for Collingwood

[TheKanga]

Any changes if any?

Tarrant is a bit of a worry, if he doesn't come right who comes in.
Daw? Hopefully Adams is back as we could use his run on the MCG.

 

[OMAN]

Any changes if any?

Tarrant is a bit of a worry, if he doesn't come right who comes in.
Daw? Hopefully Adams is back as we could use his run on the MCG.

Daw is out for 6 months.

 

[Only Forwards]

Crusher might get a go.

Taz has been carrying injury according to the post match stuff with the players.

 

[TheKanga]

Daw is out for 6 months.

Really? Am i missing something?

 

[Joshen]

Out: Sirra, Tarrant (inj.)
In: Adams, Currie

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Out: Swan, Embleberry, Cloke. Nah. They won't be resting players, as they'll want to win, but they might want to give Jolly, Krak a run like they did with Didak last week. Who knows.

From our side, surely we have a better option than Sierakowski for the 22nd spot. If Adams is ok he comes back in. Obviously if we could get Thompson or Grima back we would. Otherwise - given injuries are now limiting our options - don't mind sticking with the team that got so close yesterday.

Would be happy with interesting emgergencies. If Carlton beat Port, then some different guys could have a run.

 

[Maddox]

Give Crusher a go if Taz doesn't pull up. Patch to come straight back in if fit also.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Brad Scott said taz was fine in his post match interview. Was a tactical sub and will be right for next week.

Out sierakowski and wright
In Adams and garner

 

[jacko57]

Tarrant should stay IF fit, we need him to learn to perform in big games, and next week is a golden opportunity.

Sierakowski, Jacobs and Wright all a bit iffy to stay in the team.........is there anyone to replace them though? Adams if fit, sure. Has Harper returned from injury & shown any sort of form? Don't want to see Anthony in the seniors again.

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

Out: Sirra, Jacobs, MacMillan, Gibson
In: Garner, Adams, Kennedy, Harper

Firitto - Delaney - Kennedy
Atley - Hansen - Wright
Mullet - Ziebell - Wells
Harvey - Petrie - Adams
Thomas - Tarrant - Black
Goldstein - Cunnington - Bastinac
Greenwood Garner McKenzie Harper

 

[john farrugia]

currie has to come in for Tarrant.adams for serra.

 

[Only Forwards]

Out: Sirra, Jacobs, MacMillan, Gibson
In: Garner, Adams, Kennedy, Harper

Firitto - Delaney - Kennedy
Atley - Hansen - Wright
Mullet - Ziebell - Wells
Harvey - Petrie - Adams
Thomas - Tarrant - Black
Goldstein - Cunnington - Bastinac
Greenwood Garner McKenzie Harper

None of the players you list as ins would be able to replace what we lose by dropping Gibson.

He is one of few blokes on our list that can run hard enough long enough to make space. Dropping him for this game would be conceding the loss.

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Out: Sirra, Jacobs, MacMillan, Gibson
In: Garner, Adams, Kennedy, Harper

Firitto - Delaney - Kennedy
Atley - Hansen - Wright
Mullet - Ziebell - Wells
Harvey - Petrie - Adams
Thomas - Tarrant - Black
Goldstein - Cunnington - Bastinac
Greenwood Garner McKenzie Harper

Funny stuff.

 

[boneofshin]

Why would Macmillan get dropped?

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

Gibson getting 30 plus is working against us.

I'd take 10 from McKenzie instead.

 

[Roosurgence]

Why would Macmillan get dropped?

I'm no McMillan fan', but doesn't deserve to be dropped on yesterdays performance. In fact I was really impressed with his last quarter.

 

[ProfessorGaz]

North gunna chalk up a win this week?

After last night's historic victory I have been teasing my Carlton mates that they will be the first ILLEGITIMATE finalists in AFL history.

If North manage to take 9th however, it will be a very different story.

You clearly deserve, more than any other team currently outside the 8, to play finals.

Aside from a lacklustre win against a dispirited Richmond then exhausted from rigorous training, Carlton have been continually destroyed by the real contenders.

North on the other hand, are a team actually capable of doing some damage this September. You have almost invariably challenged the best, and at times been victorious against them (Geelong). Hence, I wish for you this upcoming weekend a sturdy win over the Pies, and for Carlton, another pathetic loss LOL

#TemporaryCraigieburnTrainLineAlliance

#NoFinalsForCarltank

 

[Winter]

Gibson getting 30 plus is working against us.

I'd take 10 from McKenzie instead.

You're mistaking him for Anthony.

While he does have his limitations by foot Gibson plays within them and is absolutely crucial to our game plan. You can't switch the play 10 times a quarter without his gut running.

 

[The Northerner]

You're mistaking him for Anthony.

While he does have his limitations by foot Gibson plays within them and is absolutely crucial to our game plan. You can't switch the play 10 times a quarter without his gut running.

Exactly. Plus Gibson can kick on both feet over good distances. So when breaking the lines on either side of the field he is not out-positioned. Not sure why the negativity on Gibbo.

 

[Maddox]

Gibson's gut running is too vital to our team. He gets the ball, gives it off, sprints 40 metres up the ground to be next in the chain again. Will. Not. Be. Dropped.

 

[winalotroos]

I can see only one change, Sirra, out for Adams.

I don't think Thompson will be back.

 

[Rockstar6]

In: Adams
Out: Sierakowski

If Tarrant doesn't get up then Currie has to play

 

[Liam Boy]

North gunna chalk up a win this week?

After last night's historic victory I have been teasing my Carlton mates that they will be the first ILLEGITIMATE finalists in AFL history.

If North manage to take 9th however, it will be a very different story.

You clearly deserve, more than any other team currently outside the 8, to play finals.

Aside from a lacklustre win against a dispirited Richmond then exhausted from rigorous training, Carlton have been continually destroyed by the real contenders.

North on the other hand, are a team actually capable of doing some damage this September. You have almost invariably challenged the best, and at times been victorious against them (Geelong). Hence, I wish for you this upcoming weekend a sturdy win over the Pies, and for Carlton, another pathetic loss LOL

#TemporaryCraigieburnTrainLineAlliance

#NoFinalsForCarltank

Without Swallow, Grima or Thompson, I doubt we'd do much in September. We would still beat Richmond though.

 

[Jack Reacher]

Out: Sirra, Jacobs, MacMillan, Gibson
In: Garner, Adams, Kennedy, Harper

Firitto - Delaney - Kennedy
Atley - Hansen - Wright
Mullet - Ziebell - Wells
Harvey - Petrie - Adams
Thomas - Tarrant - Black
Goldstein - Cunnington - Bastinac
Greenwood Garner McKenzie Harper

Really?

Out: Siera, Jacobs (both duds)
In: Jizzberts, Harper/Adams (if fit)

 

[muttley45]

dont care if taz is in or out, currie must get a game this week, and mc kenzie is not to be the sub, someone else can do the logistics for that scenario, but im sure it can be done,