Preview Changes: R5 vs Richmond - Saturday April 16, 4.05pm ACST @ Adelaide Oval

[Scorpus]

IN:
McAdam, Cook, Berry

OUT:
Hinge, Rowe, Schoenberg

Hinge dropped and named as an emergency, not injured

 

[Mutineer]

I hope those screaming for changes watched the SANFL today.

 

[hey shorty]

I hope those screaming for changes watched the SANFL today.

If they only watched the first half and the last quarter......

 

[Mutineer]

If they only watched the first half and the last quarter......

Nah, none of our midfielders had a decent game, very ordinary all of them if they were looking for an AFL gig next week.

 

[hey shorty]

Nah, none of our midfielders had a decent game, very ordinary all of them if they were looking for an AFL gig next week.

They were 40 points up at HT, I'd replace Crouch with any of them in a heartbeat

 

[kirky]

Perhaps I’m a few screws loose but actually think we can jag a win tomorrow.

 

[hey shorty]

Perhaps I’m a few screws loose but actually think we can jag a win tomorrow.

Richmond were very good last week but hadn't been before that, who knows.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

mitch hinge.. been an easy top 5 player for us in the first 4 rounds..

if he’s not injured why the fu** is he not named in the 22?.. if he is injured then why dont they simply say so and have him as an out (inj)?

the selection committee needs to fu** off.. they are simpletons.

Injured for sure , weird they named him emergency

Love his footy so far

As for the Fogarty fan boiiiis / lovers / defenders …… is it still the midfields fault when he takes 1 mark in the sanfl ???
The guy isn’t even sanfl level . I’m not sure he’d go that well at Rostrevor Old acollegians . Maybe get a kick at Lucindale …. Maybe

If Sam Berry doesn’t play high mid minutes Tomoz I think it’s time for all of us to give up

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Perhaps I’m a few screws loose but actually think we can jag a win tomorrow.

Usually happens when we are more upset than normal re selection

 

[Jeffcrowe]

I have been at three of our four matches this year in the flesh and I have watched a replay of all matches.

Dawson has spent 70% of his ToG in the midfield, mostly on the wing.

Until last week Shoey played almost entirely in the midfield.

Sloane and Keays have been spending more time forward and less time in the midfield than last year.

Hinge has been playing on the wing until last week when he was mostly at half back (and imho looked good before he was injured).

The only players who have not had a poor match or more are Dawson. Keays and Rachele. There is a Melbourne Cup field of contenders who could be dropped.

Yep best 3 by a mile and Tex in his one game was massive

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Rowe very unlucky. If they’re not going to give Murphy midfield minutes then they should be sticking with Rowe. He’s twice the small forward that Murphy is. It’s not surprising though, it’s a continuation of 2020 selection philosophy.

Rowe has been playing very well , he did cost us last week with chances to help ice the game by folding in crucial contests in a meek manner

Was disappointed in him as was loving his good stuff this year

Be good if Matt crouch was held to the same account though

 

[BRL121]

Injured for sure , weird they named him emergency

Love his footy so far

As for the Fogarty fan boiiiis / lovers / defenders …… is it still the midfields fault when he takes 1 mark in the sanfl ???
The guy isn’t even sanfl level . I’m not sure he’d go that well at Rostrevor Old acollegians . Maybe get a kick at Lucindale …. Maybe

If Sam Berry doesn’t play high mid minutes Tomoz I think it’s time for all of us to give up

Wright is more likely to come in than Fogarty.

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Wright is more likely to come in than Fogarty.

Yes he would contribute more

 

[Mutineer]

Rowe has been playing very well , he did cost us last week with chances to help ice the game by folding in crucial contests in a meek manner

Was disappointed in him as was loving his good stuff this year

Be good if Matt crouch was held to the same account though

Did you watch our midfield aspirants Hately, Schoenberg and Pedlar in the Snaffle today?

Hately got a bit of ball like he always does and did sfa with it, Schoenberg stunk it up, kicking shithouse again and Pedlar obviously not fit enough only played limited midfield minutes.

The 3 best mids on the ground were Glenelg's Brett Turner, Luke Partington and Matthew Snook roving to beaten rucks, actually roved better to Strachan's tapwork than any of our guys.

Parnell our best easily IMO.

 

[hey shorty]

Did you watch our midfield aspirants Hately, Schoenberg and Pedlar in the Snaffle today?

Hately got a bit of ball like he always does and did sfa with it, Schoenberg stunk it up, kicking shithouse again and Pedlar obviously not fit enough only played limited midfield minutes.

The 3 best mids on the ground were Glenelg's Brett Turner, Luke Partington and Matthew Snook roving to beaten rucks, actually roved better to Strachan's tapwork than any of our guys.

Parnell our best easily IMO.

I'd rather any of them in the side than Sloane ATM

 

[Southerntakeover]

SANFL form is entirely unimportant to the club's future. Crouch, Laird and Sloane are not taking us to the promised land. Find out if any of these kids can play in the professional league.

 

[hey shorty]

SANFL form is entirely unimportant to the club's future. Crouch, Laird and Sloane are not taking us to the promised land. Find out if any of these kids can play in the professional league.

Laird might still be there, and help bring us back.

The others..... Nope.

 

[Southerntakeover]

Laird might still be there, and help bring us back.

The others..... Nope.

I meant the combination of the three, but agree otherwise.

 

[hey shorty]

I meant the combination of the three, but agree otherwise.

It's idiocy to keep doing it.

If the kids fail then we've still learnt something

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Did you watch our midfield aspirants Hately, Schoenberg and Pedlar in the Snaffle today?

Hately got a bit of ball like he always does and did sfa with it, Schoenberg stunk it up, kicking shithouse again and Pedlar obviously not fit enough only played limited midfield minutes.

The 3 best mids on the ground were Glenelg's Brett Turner, Luke Partington and Matthew Snook roving to beaten rucks, actually roved better to Strachan's tapwork than any of our guys.

Parnell our best easily IMO.

Yep saw a bit

Pedlar is at least a pre season away from being considered to play midfield at AFL - just not conditioned enough but a good talent . Anyone that whines that he’s not playing AFL mid minutes isn’t watching closely

Shoenberg should be playing AFL mid after his showdown game . That was only 14 days ago !!

Hately . I wouldn’t mind seeing him at AFL level as he has a bit more uncontested bias to his game as a mid which would maybe balance us out a bit , also height point of diff . Heck worth a go , what’s the worst that could happen ?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Did you watch our midfield aspirants Hately, Schoenberg and Pedlar in the Snaffle today?

Hately got a bit of ball like he always does and did sfa with it, Schoenberg stunk it up, kicking shithouse again and Pedlar obviously not fit enough only played limited midfield minutes.

The 3 best mids on the ground were Glenelg's Brett Turner, Luke Partington and Matthew Snook roving to beaten rucks, actually roved better to Strachan's tapwork than any of our guys.

Parnell our best easily IMO.

Parnell first half was great and I thought Newchurch is making some strides - 6 tackles 3 goals !

We’ve bombed some 1st round picks - Fog is a shocker , Mcasey ( I’m surprised he’s not better ) . Pedlar will be ok if he can get through more pre seasons but I’d take Tanner Bruhn or Tom Powell in hindsight

 

[Jeffcrowe]

SANFL form is entirely unimportant to the club's future. Crouch, Laird and Sloane are not taking us to the promised land. Find out if any of these kids can play in the professional league.

You don’t think Laird is much chop ?

Righto

 

[Southerntakeover]

You don’t think Laird is much chop ?

Righto

Where do you reckon he'd get picked in an all of AFL midfield draft?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

Where do you reckon he'd get picked in an all of AFL midfield draft?

Probably 20-25

He’s not a problem for us , either is Keays . It’s a lack of talent outside them . Our recruiters haven’t had good talent ID for mids

Our best mid is a rookie pick AA defender

 

[George Kramer]

Probably 20-25

He’s not a problem for us , either is Keays . It’s a lack of talent outside them . Our recruiters haven’t had good talent ID for mids

Our best mid is a rookie pick AA defender

How does Hamish keep his job?

 

[Jeffcrowe]

How does Hamish keep his job?

I think it’s time for a change personally

New eyes are needed