Changes Round 23 vs Hawthorn (thread now closed)

[CasuallyDressed]

KENNEDYYY!!!! IN.

You forgot to add as the sub.

 

[Magpie Mason]

In: Karnezis, Kennedy, Martin
Out: Swan, Young, Caff

Theoretically our season is alive but realistically its over. Get the kids in and leave guys like Ramsay and Broomhead to finish out the year.

Kennedy the sub? Karnezis deserves a game.

In. Karnezis, Kmart, Kennedy, Elliott, QStick
Out. Swan, Caf, Young, Fasolo, White

 

[Magpie Mason]

Alex Fasolo
Sam Dwyer
Brodie Grundy
Tyson Goldsack
Ben Kennedy
Martin Clarke
Scott Pendlebury
Jarryd Blair
Luke Ball
Jarrod Witts
Jesse White
Quinten Lynch
Steele Sidebottom
Lachlan Keeffe
Josh Thomas
Marley Williams
Tony Armstrong
Ben Sinclair
Tim Broomhead
Jackson Ramsay
Patrick Karnezis
Paul Seedsman
Tom Langdon
Jack Frost
Kyle Martin
Corey Gault



Am I missing anyone from the available list?

Geez you'd be unlucky to miss next week!

I reckon if you miss out next week, you might be looking elsewhere next year. it means you're about 38 on the list!

 

[MAGPIE2013]

Now that I think about it, had young marked that ball against gc and scored we would have kocked finals with the win last night. Just some food for thought. You could say young dropped our finals chances right there

 

[domus]

It can seem like everyone but it's not.

Some folks (generally VFL watchers) reckon Patty K has nowhere near the fitness required for AFL footy and there's no way he should be played unless we truly have run out of players and need to make up numbers.



Again, it can seem like everyone, but it's not ... It's often just a vocal minority in those situations.

If that is true it's an indictment on the CFC fitness staff not Karnesiz. Players have missed weeks through injury and still made a return to the seniors. Why isn't his fitness up to scratch?

 

[Kirby]

John Ralph just said on Foxtel that both Elliott and Lumumba are unlikely to be right for this week.

 

[MAGPIE2013]

John Ralph just said on Foxtel that both Elliott and Lumumba are unlikely to be right for this week.

Better of without them. Just wrap them up for 2015

 

[Kirby]

Better of without them. Just wrap them up for 2015

I'd like to see Elliott back. Certainly not so fussed with H in his recent form.

 

[76woodenspooners]

If that is true it's an indictment on the CFC fitness staff not Karnesiz. Players have missed weeks through injury and still made a return to the seniors. Why isn't his fitness up to scratch?

Patty missed the preseason because of OP, and then large portions of the season through hamstring.

Some injuries would impact a player's abiiity to train (hamstrings, OP) more than some other injuries (eg: Adams' finger)

 

[PorkyPie]

In: Seedsman, Kennedy and Karnezis
Loving the pace of Broomhead and Sinclair, and i hope Seedsman & Kennedy add to that.
I think Armstrong should do all the kicking in!
The Mighty Pies to win by 18

 

[mattys123]

By the sounds of this Lumumba is almost certain to play, and Billy is a huge chance also, would improve us a fair bit;

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...to-face-hawthorn/story-fni5f6hd-1227035004122

Revised ins/outs;

In: Lumumba, Elliott, Kennedy
Out: Swan, Young, Caff

 

[Bay Pie]

Sure ...

... but it's quite common that a few posters say something like "Buckley should be sacked" and that's extrapolated to everyone / Bigfooty / Collingwood supporters think Buckley should be sacked.

Even Eddie is doing it. Only a week or so ago we ran a poll on here testing the temperature of supporters and only a tiny minority wanted to metaphorically burn the place down, and a few more than that were feeling pessimistic. The vast majority were either feeling neutral or optimistic. And yet Eddie paid reference to "internet style carpers"

The negative Buckley thing is getting raised in almost every thread, irrespective of topic. It's changed the make up of this whole board. It's become a shit place to come, especially after a loss. Tough for you guys to moderate, but a snide remark here or there is becoming more and more prevalent. It's been let go for to long now to pull it in.

IN: balanced discussion
OUT: repetitive carping

 

[SnakePlisskin]

I'd rather watch Karnezis play a game than Luturnover.

 

[Brad Goodman]

Hawthorn won't rest players, they need to win to ensure not travelling in week one.

If we show the vim and vigour of this week against Hawthorn we might only lose by 10 goals.

 

[MyManLynch]

KENNEDYYY!!!! IN.

Did he pluck that out of the tree?

 

[TradeDraft]

By the sounds of this Lumumba is almost certain to play, and Billy is a huge chance also, would improve us a fair bit;

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...to-face-hawthorn/story-fni5f6hd-1227035004122

Revised ins/outs;

In: Lumumba, Elliott, Kennedy
Out: Swan, Young, Caff

Would Help the Team but we want lot more the Elliot and Lumumba to even have a Hope

 

[TradeDraft]

KENNEDYYY!!!! IN.

Great Mark.

Would not mind him playing in the VFL as that is a Bigger Game next week.

We can win that Game and get into a Semi in the VFL Finals Series

 

[jefffff34]

Would not mind him playing in the VFL as that is a Bigger Game next week.

No it isn't.

 

[Swooper18]

Hoggy's right Dave. Follow this mantra, believe until each game can no longer be won.

 

[robertg22]

No it isn't.

lol, incredible logic isn't it? We win the AFL game we most likely play finals!

 

[PieBeast]

Our best chance of winning is if Clarko decides to rest 6-8 players next week.

You just never know what might happen.

Imagine if we win.

I'll leave imagining things to the likes of you and will be guided by reality thank you very much.

 

[DaVe86]

Tough one.

Part of me says get the kids in like Kennedy, Martin, Seedsman, Gault, Karnezis.

The other part of me thinks that we need to win the VFL this weekend because the week after we'll be able to bolster the side with guys like Broomhead, Ramsay and Grundy.

Therefore, if Lumumba and Elliott are fit, I'd bring them in. I also really would like to see Karnezis in the side.

Kennedy and Martin are deserving, but the VFL team deserves its best possible chance.

 

[DaVe86]

I'll leave imagining things to the likes of you and will be guided by reality thank you very much.

Even if the Hawks rest 6-8....they still have a more senior side than us!

It only merely evens the game up a bit. To completely level it, the following guys need to be dropped.

Roughead (Cloke)
Mitchell (Beams)
Gunston (Reid)
Burgoyne (Swan)
Breust (Elliott)
Isaac Smith (Young)
Shiels (Macaffer)
Lake (Nathan Brown)
Sewell (Adams)
Stratton (Toovey)

That's 9 players

Hawthorn's only main injury at the moment is Cyril Rioli.

Therefore to make it fair, they are also not allowed to bring in guys like Hartung as our depth is also shot with guys like Freeman unavailable.

So I really struggle to see us winning this game because Hawks will not rest that many, and have depth to cover anyway. Guys like Schoenmakers, O'Brien, Cheney and McEvoy are running around in the reserves and ready to come straight in to replace the guys listed above.

 

[domin8tors]

IN: Karnezis Kennedy Toovey

OUT: MaCaffer Young Swan

I'm fairly sure that Toovey is done for the season. so I'm thinking Karnezis / Kennedy and Harry if fit otherwise Martin

 

[domin8tors]

I'm fairly sure that Toovey is done for the season. so I'm thinking Karnezis / Kennedy and Harry if fit otherwise Martin

I think that you have

Even if the Hawks rest 6-8....they still have a more senior side than us!

It only merely evens the game up a bit. To completely level it, the following guys need to be dropped.

Roughead (Cloke)
Mitchell (Beams)
Gunston (Reid)
Burgoyne (Swan)
Breust (Elliott)
Isaac Smith (Young)
Shiels (Macaffer)
Lake (Nathan Brown)
Sewell (Adams)
Stratton (Toovey)

That's 9 players

Hawthorn's only main injury at the moment is Cyril Rioli.

Therefore to make it fair, they are also not allowed to bring in guys like Hartung as our depth is also shot with guys like Freeman unavailable.

So I really struggle to see us winning this game because Hawks will not rest that many, and have depth to cover anyway. Guys like Schoenmakers, O'Brien, Cheney and McEvoy are running around in the reserves and ready to come straight in to replace the guys listed above.

I think that you have forgotten. Maxwell. and seedsman