- Dec 6, 2020
- 2,984
- 6,360
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
Without Lewis playing for the hawks, I don’t think we should risk Pearce, Cox and Draper/Davies can take care of Chol and Gunston.
Prediction Changes v Hawthorn (Round 18)
- Thread starter FreoRicci
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Clive Kepler
Debutant
- Jul 7, 2022
- 135
- 173
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
JL knows what he's doing with team selection, been pretty good with it as coach imo.
It’s been almost a year since they last played a game together in defence hasn’t it?
I wished you hadn't deleted your post, but I think a lot of the opposite views were based on the lack of value others would see Jye getting from WAFL and the perspective that he actually hasn't been playing badly, just not finishing like he can.
There's nothing wrong with offering up a scenario or considering different options, plenty of others had floated Voss replacing Amiss.
In my mind it's a positive overall because Voss has been a lot better than I expected, he's been valuable depth and not in the way I expected.
All I saw of him before was essentially as a medium forward despite his height, yet he's either shown more or developed a lot because he's been making the contests and getting good looks from his leading.
This 100%.
Hamann188 Don't let us doubt yourself mate, I get roasted on here all the time for my whacky shit
Confucius
Senior List
- Jan 7, 2016
- 181
- 592
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
This may be controversial but if Walker is fit, I'd let him earn his spot via Peel.
I'm liking what I've seen from Wagner and I know some are down on Aish, but despite having to play multiple different roles he's been better this year than most give him credit for.
I know some will say that Walker provides more run from the backline than Aish but I'm not convinced that's true.
It's Apples Vs Oranges V Mandarins but please consider the following comparison of this years' stats...
Disposals
Aish 18.7 v Walker 13.3 v Wagner 14.8
DE%
Aish 79.1 v Walker 76.7 v Wagner 81.1
Clangers
Aish 1.7 v Walker 2.2 v Wagner 1.4
Turnovers
Aish 2.4 v Walker 2.9 v Wagner 3.0
Intercepts
Aish 4.3 v Walker 4.1 v Wagner 1.6
1%ers
Aish 0.9 v Walker 2.1 v Wagner 0.8
Rebound 50s
Aish 2.9 v Walker 2.1 v Wagner 2.4
Score Involvements
Aish 3.8 v Walker 2.3 v Wagner 2.6
Metres Gained
Aish 289 v Walker 177 v Wagner 360
Walker is a great 1 v 1 defender on fast smalls, hence the only stat category he leads in the above comparison is 1%ers. Though I'm not convinced he's better one on one than Wagner or Aish.
If people want walker in for his defensive prowess on super quick smalls then cool. (Maybe Bolton wouldnt have gotten off the hook if Walker had played on him?).
But please don't suggest that Walker provides significant bounce from defence. If we want more attack from D50, Walker is the 3rd best of the 3 options.
I'm liking what I've seen from Wagner and I know some are down on Aish, but despite having to play multiple different roles he's been better this year than most give him credit for.
I know some will say that Walker provides more run from the backline than Aish but I'm not convinced that's true.
It's Apples Vs Oranges V Mandarins but please consider the following comparison of this years' stats...
Disposals
Aish 18.7 v Walker 13.3 v Wagner 14.8
DE%
Aish 79.1 v Walker 76.7 v Wagner 81.1
Clangers
Aish 1.7 v Walker 2.2 v Wagner 1.4
Turnovers
Aish 2.4 v Walker 2.9 v Wagner 3.0
Intercepts
Aish 4.3 v Walker 4.1 v Wagner 1.6
1%ers
Aish 0.9 v Walker 2.1 v Wagner 0.8
Rebound 50s
Aish 2.9 v Walker 2.1 v Wagner 2.4
Score Involvements
Aish 3.8 v Walker 2.3 v Wagner 2.6
Metres Gained
Aish 289 v Walker 177 v Wagner 360
Walker is a great 1 v 1 defender on fast smalls, hence the only stat category he leads in the above comparison is 1%ers. Though I'm not convinced he's better one on one than Wagner or Aish.
If people want walker in for his defensive prowess on super quick smalls then cool. (Maybe Bolton wouldnt have gotten off the hook if Walker had played on him?).
But please don't suggest that Walker provides significant bounce from defence. If we want more attack from D50, Walker is the 3rd best of the 3 options.
James Aish and Brandon Walker AFL Stats Comparison
James Aish and Brandon Walker AFL Stats Comparison.
www.footywire.com
Brandon Walker and Corey Wagner AFL Stats Comparison
Brandon Walker and Corey Wagner AFL Stats Comparison.
www.footywire.com
DRAGONS FFC - Moderator
- #208
Interesting to see it context like that.
Think we should be looking at Walks for a front half role. But really the only position up there is Banners so.....
Could be a good sub, but then I don't think Sonny gets dropped.
Getting bloody tough right now to fit everyone in.
Wizard
Brownlow Medallist
Based on the messaging from the club i'd be staggered if AP doesn't play.
Wizard
Brownlow Medallist
The way i look at it:
Shai Bolton had 16 disposals and 8 shots on goal (4.3) on the weekend. Does he have that impact with Walker in the side? I would imagine not.
Dylan Moore has kicked 26 goals thus far in 2024. I'd imagine he is less likely to add a significant amount to that number with Walker in the side then if Walker isn't in the side.
If Walks is fit he walks in IMO.
Confucius
Senior List
- Jan 7, 2016
- 181
- 592
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
The way I see it we have 9 'best 22 quality' defenders fighting for 7 spots.
Gives us the ability to manage players with minor niggles and choose the best fit for opponent needs.
I'll be bummed to see Walker, Wagner or Aish miss out (particularly in September) but it's a very good problem to have!
Gives us the ability to manage players with minor niggles and choose the best fit for opponent needs.
I'll be bummed to see Walker, Wagner or Aish miss out (particularly in September) but it's a very good problem to have!
- Aug 20, 2010
- 5,807
- 11,518
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Manchester City
It was pretty evident how badly we missed Walker on the weekend with Bolton running riot for a while. If Aish was in the form he was in last year than he's clearly ahead of the other two. Reality is that Aish's form has dropped away recently to the point that Walker and Wagner are ahead of him.
Walker also adds a point of difference - his speed is a valuable asset, and he's the best we have at closing down small forwards. Having Walker in the team allows Wagner and Clark to play more attacking roles.
I think the coaching staff actually pick Walker first out of those three. Aish will make a good sub should our preferred back 7 all be available.
- Aug 20, 2010
- 5,807
- 11,518
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Manchester City
IMO we've gone from having lots of uncertainty about who's in our B23 to having only a couple of positions under debate, all of them being bench roles.
Backline six: Pearce, Cox, Ryan, Chapman, Walker, Clark
Midfield six: Darcy, Serong, Brayshaw, Young, Sharp, JOM
Forward six: Jackson, Treacy, Amiss, Switkowski, Frederick, Sturt
Bench: Fyfe (mid), Johnson (mid), Wagner (back), Banfield (utility)
So that leaves a sub role remaining and Aish and Walters both out of the team (not even mentioning Erasmus or Voss). Who from those onfield or bench roles has their position under doubt? I'd argue none of them. The only two you could debate would be Wagner and Banfield, but their form is solid enough that it would be difficult to convince most people that Aish or Walters would be better.
It's a pretty exciting time, it's rare to have such a solidified best 22 at the pointy end of a season like this, and touchwood, we may actually see this B22 run out against Melbourne next week.
Backline six: Pearce, Cox, Ryan, Chapman, Walker, Clark
Midfield six: Darcy, Serong, Brayshaw, Young, Sharp, JOM
Forward six: Jackson, Treacy, Amiss, Switkowski, Frederick, Sturt
Bench: Fyfe (mid), Johnson (mid), Wagner (back), Banfield (utility)
So that leaves a sub role remaining and Aish and Walters both out of the team (not even mentioning Erasmus or Voss). Who from those onfield or bench roles has their position under doubt? I'd argue none of them. The only two you could debate would be Wagner and Banfield, but their form is solid enough that it would be difficult to convince most people that Aish or Walters would be better.
It's a pretty exciting time, it's rare to have such a solidified best 22 at the pointy end of a season like this, and touchwood, we may actually see this B22 run out against Melbourne next week.
Last edited:
- Moderator
- #217
- Moderator
- #218
- Moderator
- #219
Unique venues of no concern to Fremantle
Justin Longmuir believes visualising unique venues is a key to feeling more comfortable come game day
- Mar 29, 2019
- 12,227
- 17,055
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Glory, Bulls
I honestly think we have one of the best problems a list can have, having guys who are best 23 quality playing in the WAFL, it shows that we have so much depth, good depth at that, that we can't fit everyone on the starting team, gives people the incentive to work their asses off to earn their spot.
Wagner is an absolute lock best 22 ahead of Aish IMO. Would be happy to see Walker in for Aish and Aish moved to the sub role instead of Sonny.
Wizard
Brownlow Medallist
Strongly disagree.
I like Wagner but Aish has far more strings to his bow then Wagner does. Wagner is only best 22 if one of Aish, Walker, Chapman, Clark is unavailable.
That's the beauty of the forum! I have the exact same feelings about Wagner over Aish.
Why do you feel that about Wagner though?
He's been pretty decent in this stretch but for me Wagner is a bit one dimensional, and isn't particularly strong defensively.
His one wood is his willingness to attack and get on the bike, which is helpful for our ball movement, but he can get exposed with positioning and on rebound against.
