Unofficial Preview Changes V Sydney (Cloke, JDG in & White, Schazza, Maynard emergencies, see team in OP)

[Bucksboys]

Sinkers is top 22.. when will people realize?

 

[Bard]

Why? Sinclair was one of our better players last week. Do we reward form or fantasies about the future?

If he can stay on the park for an extended period of time Sinclair has a future with us anyway so it's a moot point!

 

[Apex36]

Maybe, but instead Cloke or Reid might do so as Moore hunts the contest and diverts Swans defenders. Just him in there as an extra competitor at ground level might be a big threat for the Swans. We also have an inform Fasolo in our forward line, and Elliott who will always require coverage by the Swans' defence. The selection of De Goey as another player who runs through the midfield will give extra reinforcements to our midfield group, and potentially give them the numbers to also run/rest in our forward 50 (ex Swan). I think the selection of De Goey and the presence of Moore has given us great attacking potential, plus added pressure for the contested ball (De Goey, and Moore, who applies more pressure than White). The more I reflect upon it, the more I like this decision to keep Moore in the team. It is not just a question of Moore, but it is a question of how Moore, Reid and Cloke combine together, and also how they combine with our small forwards.

You could say literally, exactly the same thing about White, given third tall alongside Cloke and Reid is the role he was originally recruited for, as well as him being a legitimate second ruck option.

 

[jmac70]

Pretty much! I'm not going to lie. Just have a bad feeling he will go and I just won't bump up his value. Since we won't play finals. I no its not the way the coaches would think but as a fan I would hate for us to waste pick 6

If he ends up going home the club will get something for him. Won't be a complete waste.

 

[TradeDraft]

Form is poor for both, lets be fair.

I'm backing Darce in. Like i said, different story this week not playing on the number 1 defender. I reckon the coaching staff have lost faith in Jesse as so far as defensiveness, actually competing for the footy in the air and then his ineptness to kick goals under any sort of pressure.

also Moore Offers way more then White at Ground Level

 

[Apex36]

Form is poor for both, lets be fair.

I'm backing Darce in. Like i said, different story this week not playing on the number 1 defender. I reckon the coaching staff have lost faith in Jesse as so far as defensiveness, actually competing for the footy in the air and then his ineptness to kick goals under any sort of pressure.

Is it? White was dropped off the back of a 2.2 game, had 1 lousy game at VFL level and then kicked 4 last week. He's also having a career best year in a position he was not recruited for, yet now that they can play him in said position, they're playing a first year who doesn't have the capacity yet to be a genuine second ruck.

I get that they're trying to get games in to Darcy, but I don't like the idea of sacrificing games to do so until it's mathematically impossible to make finals.

 

[jmac70]

also Moore Offers way more then White at Ground Level

I disagree there. White's second efforts are his strength.

 

[Pendles!]

also Moore Offers way more then White at Ground Level

I'd say its the opposite to be honest, Moore offers heaps more in the air where as White is better on the ground. In terms of tackling pressure and chasing from behind then Moore would offer more.

 

[Old Spice]

Pretty much! I'm not going to lie. Just have a bad feeling he will go and I just won't bump up his value. Since we won't play finals. I no its not the way the coaches would think but as a fan I would hate for us to waste pick 6

Everyone knows his value and 4 extra games won't change that. In fact if he was beaten up in Sydney, it might diminish his value. You only need 2 clubs for an auction, but in any case we can't be making decisions that way.

 

[Apex36]

also Moore Offers way more then White at Ground Level

Rofl no he doesn't. Whites major issue is that he is lousy in the air, his ground level work is very good.

 

[TradeDraft]

Cloke is a certainty. White may come in late for Moore is my guess

I highly doubt there be a late Change.

Only reason someone comes down with Sickness or Pulls up Sore tomorrow

 

[12kilos]

Has anyone have any idea if they expect Adams to play? He got injured.
Did not look good last week.

 

[TradeDraft]

He has done a couple of nice things but his influence on the game has been minimal.

Outside for a Few Goals. Which Moore has not quite done yet outside of 1 Game. He does not much else or even less then Moore

 

[jmac70]

Has anyone have any idea if they expect Adams to play?
Did not look good last week.

He has been picked.

 

[jmac70]

Outside for a Few Goals. Which Moore has not quite done yet outside of 1 Game. He does not much else or even less then Moore

Moore has had six possessions in each of his last two games. He has been average at best and in my opinion we would be stronger with White. Having said that I hope Moore has a blinder tomorrow night.

 

[boxy99]

Everyone knows his value and 4 extra games won't change that. In fact if he was beaten up in Sydney, it might diminish his value. You only need 2 clubs for an auction, but in any case we can't be making decisions that way.

I disagree he doesn't have much value at all really after the injuries. The only value he has is the fact he went pick 6. Which means nothing after 2 years. Putting together a solid 4 games would increase his value a fair bit.

 

[TradeDraft]

I disagree there. White's second efforts are his strength.

Well I can’t Remember him Competing at Ground Level after a Contest like Moore Does

 

[TradeDraft]

Moore has had six possessions in each of his last two games. He has been average at best and in my opinion we would be stronger with White. Having said that I hope Moore has a blinder tomorrow night.

Well I think you look a lot at Numbers and Stats. Look at Numbers and Stats yes Moore does look like he been Average.

But Watch him compete and fight for Balls you see there is more to then Stats to his Game at this Early Stage of his Career

 

[Pendles!]

Is it? White was dropped off the back of a 2.2 game, had 1 lousy game at VFL level and then kicked 4 last week. He's also having a career best year in a position he was not recruited for, yet now that they can play him in said position, they're playing a first year who doesn't have the capacity yet to be a genuine second ruck.

I get that they're trying to get games in to Darcy, but I don't like the idea of sacrificing games to do so until it's mathematically impossible to make finals.

He might be having a career best year in terms of Goals but thats it. His insipid attack on the ball and man and inability to mark a high ball is still prominent. For a team who relies on defensive pressure he just doesn't do enough.

Sacrificing games is a bit harsh, having White in wouldn't give us much more than Darcy imo.

Anyway agree to disagree, I'm just sick of White's insipidness and happy to have someone in who has a crack

 

[jmac70]

Well I think you look a lot at Numbers and Stats. Look at Numbers and Stats yes Moore does look like he been Average.

But Watch him compete and fight for Balls you see there is more to then Stats to his Game at this Early Stage of his Career

I go to every game and watch every replay. You don't have the exclusive rights to Moore.

 

[Old Spice]

I disagree he doesn't have much value at all really after the injuries. The only value he has is the fact he went pick 6. Which means nothing after 2 years. Putting together a solid 4 games would increase his value a fair bit.

Do you think him playing 4 extra games at Collingwood will determine him wanting to stay or leave?

 

[left at home]

at this stage of there careers white is in front of moore,and I would have white in this week
because the type of game Sydney play and for the position white was recruited for. mobile 3rd
tall and relief ruck

 

[bungwahl]

So you Finally Admitted you can’t beat us at ANZ

Hah I don't think that's up for debate!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Old Spice]

If he can stay on the park for an extended period of time Sinclair has a future with us anyway so it's a moot point!

Nothings moot regarding form. Sinclair is fringey and he knows it, but he certainly earned a recall after last weeks effort.

 

[boxy99]

Do you think him playing 4 extra games at Collingwood will determine him wanting to stay or leave?

Not at all he would have his mind made up by now.