List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 part 2 - see Mod Warning p 281

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
On that, why don't you go by Madagascar anymore?
Sometimes it's a matter of being banned & sometimes I think he just loses track of new accounts & when he created them.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Not only would he not leave the doggies, but do you think they would let it be known a day before their semi final match?
This one is just bull.
Agree and to avoid 50 other reactionary posts I'll delete it.
 
pie time said:
Daniel wells is poised to join Collingwood, there was a chance geelong would come to the party late but from what I'm gathering he has nominated Collingwood should be official in the next 2-3 days.
from pietimes thread...
 
pie time said:
Daniel wells is poised to join Collingwood, there was a chance geelong would come to the party late but from what I'm gathering he has nominated Collingwood should be official in the next 2-3 days.
from pietimes thread...
Is this from the super secretive PM list?
 
pie time said:
Daniel wells is poised to join Collingwood, there was a chance geelong would come to the party late but from what I'm gathering he has nominated Collingwood should be official in the next 2-3 days.
from pietimes thread...


Not exactly going out on a limb is he? :rolleyes:
 
pie time said:
Daniel wells is poised to join Collingwood, there was a chance geelong would come to the party late but from what I'm gathering he has nominated Collingwood should be official in the next 2-3 days.
from pietimes thread...
Can we just avoid anything pie time related? He has his own thread already.
He's hardly put his balls on the line with that info either, all been posted on bf recently.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

from another thread.
Not sure why all the negativity from recruiting older players, yes a young list is a key to long term success but how do people expect growth with no one in the team to direct and teach and use past experience if there is none.. Look at the top 8 teams all have a fair bit of experiene on there list bar the bulldogs but guess what, dogs had one of the stingiest backlines in the comp this year and 2 of there back 6 are over 30, 3 if you count bob murphy, coincidence?
The problem we have is we dont have the experience in the key area's right across the field, our most experienced backs are brown and reid, brown i dont see being there next year leaving reid as the experience. I think reid is great back, but i dont think he is even in our leadership group? Any way i think we need a general down there who can keep an eye on the game as well as direct, as our best backman next year i dont think he wont have the time to organise everyone else when he's having to chase the likes of franklin around.
Langdon was thought to be a ready replacement to maxwell i believe he will be but he isnt there yet he still needs guidance, we know its a dificiancy down there hence the reason for sending pendles back early on this year but that just robbed peter to pay paul our midfield was hurt by that. So in my opinion taking wells fills a need of pace, creativity and kicking however im not sure its the leadership experience we need thats where i see the idea of a dal santo off half back teaching and directing alah a nick maxwell roll would be a good thing not to mention having nds kicking out and across halfback can improve the whole team. Mayne is also filling a need of defensive minded fwd as well as an experienced head amongst a very young fwd line. just my 2 cents though:)


Have you heard of Heath Shaw ...um yer was on our list and a general down back but gone now irony that your now calling for a player exactly like him. Buckley got rid of him.
 
Damo on TFS, asked brayshaw whats the go with Wells , brayshaw said something along the lines of ''id be dissapointed if he leaves, its the industry though , theres a chance it could happen though''

In other Words they have no idea
 
Geelong is playing in a prelim next weekend and Wells is 31. The chance of a flag before he retires would be very tempting.

I actually think Geelong's list is pretty ordinary in spite of where they find themselves. Still, a reasonable point.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top