List Mgmt. Contract, Trade and Draft Discussions - 2024 Post Season

Whose future picks would you have preferred?


  • Total voters
    216

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #2


Quick links



Trade period
In:
12, F1, F2, F3, 73, Baker, Owies, Graham*
Out: 3, 63, F4, Barrass, Darling

*Free agent

Done deals

  • Jai Culley, Alex Witherden and Coby Burgiel delisted






  • Zane Trew, Jamaine Jones and Jordyn Baker delisted

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm a bit light on for details but Will Schofield coaches Aquanis (I think) and his team played Curtin's recently. From what I recall of the chat, Will sent his key back to Curtin who was playing forward, and he shut him down pretty comprehensively. Wish I could remember the name of the defender, as Schoey is big on him.
Well that may be so, but Curtin also kicked back to back bags of 6 goals after moving forward right at the tail end of the Colts season. Everyone can have a bad game, but its worth keeping an eye on how he goes next year of course to see if there are signs of him being too one dimensional or something.
 
Anyone else hearing Isiah Winder has been asked to do testing by a few AFL clubs.

Watch the Cats turn him into a Tim Kelly clone.........

Pretty sure he's been invited to official combine testing.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I know this will get me a thumbs down but baby Curts is one of the main reasons I want to trade 3 into next years draft and have an extra first. Unless we can get Warner this trade period we are so much better off having 2 top 10 picks next year than taking a pick at 3 this year.
I like the idea but surely we are better off splitting 3 for a 1st this year and a f1 for next year than just moving the pick into the future.
I dont think we can afford to push things back like that

Maybe a split of 3 into a 1st this year and a f1, like 3 for Freos 10+f1+something, or maybe the Saints are keen on 3+23 for 7+f1
Add that f1 to our normal f1 and the hawks f1 im sure we could work things
 
Anyone else hearing Isiah Winder has been asked to do testing by a few AFL clubs.

Watch the Cats turn him into a Tim Kelly clone.........
Reckon the Bombers are onto him. Saw Matt Rosa heading to a South Freo game earlier in the year, looking through the names playing Winder was the only one that looked of interest.
 
I know this will get me a thumbs down but baby Curts is one of the main reasons I want to trade 3 into next years draft and have an extra first. Unless we can get Warner this trade period we are so much better off having 2 top 10 picks next year than taking a pick at 3 this year.
Don't rate anyone this year?

On SM-S921B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Anyone else hearing Isiah Winder has been asked to do testing by a few AFL clubs.

Watch the Cats turn him into a Tim Kelly clone.........

Showed plenty enough while on our list. Think we went a bit early moving him on but sometimes that's the wake up call a player needs to round out the way they view their career.
 
Anyone else hearing Isiah Winder has been asked to do testing by a few AFL clubs.

Watch the Cats turn him into a Tim Kelly clone.........

Easy does it. Winder can hit a target by foot.
 
Well that may be so, but Curtin also kicked back to back bags of 6 goals after moving forward right at the tail end of the Colts season. Everyone can have a bad game, but its worth keeping an eye on how he goes next year of course to see if there are signs of him being too one dimensional or something.

It's less of a knock on Curtin and more of a need to track down who that defender is.
 
He has his moments but he lacks consistency and he doesn't have any real effective defensive pressure..he's worth listing as a rookie , but imo he will flop at afl level.
Are you joking

Draft year against men. Dewer only started kicked multiple goals after 2 seasons

Kid has potential
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If he went to Freo I wouldn’t accept anything less than pick 16. Probably start the negotiations at pick 10 with something going back and settle on that pick 16. Otherwise he’s worth more to us than that. If he gets over his niggles from this year and returns to 2023 form he’s still a good player.

End of the day we have a new coach so things can change quickly in the AFL and that’s more likely to happen the better your list is. You don’t just give away good players unless your salary cap is a mess.

Don’t overthink it like I said in my previous post it’s simply his manager trying to get the ball rolling over the summer break.
If we were ever to be trading with Freo I would be going after pick 9 and balancing the trade rather than just getting the best value with what they have. 9 for Kelly + F3 values Kelly at pick 14.
 
Going to be a lot of angry Eagles fans if Kelly moves to Freo

But.. if we effectively end up with Warner for Kelly, then that's a massive win for WC

Not drafting Kelly in 2017 is going to impact West Coasts trade and draft decisions for all time.
 
Now that the Tigers pres has had a thinly veiled swipe at the departing players ..loyalty... forget about bakers need to please his former club... he wants WC, he is uncontracted....WC just need to hold their nerve ... they will get him without losing any first round picks.
I suspect that was aimed more at Bolton but Baker is certainly in mind when making such statements. I'd be happy with this outcome.
 
Are you joking

Draft year against men. Dewer only started kicked multiple goals after 2 seasons

Kid has potential

Champion might be small but he's a pure footballer who makes things happen. Maybe he can't make the step up, but he's got a lot of skill.
 
If we could draft Cody Curtin with the Hawks F1 (along with Rodrigues with our F1) then fill our boots with Banfield and Walley with points, it would be an impressive haul. I write this with a lot of water to go under the bridge but dreaming of a better future is all we have at the moment
How do we get warner then?

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Everyone knows Zac Bailey was the real miss in 2017.
 
I just can't see him even doing well at WAFL level... way too small , no real defensive + to his game. Let him through and rookie list him instead of bidding on him.
He just kicks goals though. I can see him very easily growing into our own Bobby Hill. He has football smarts, good kicking.

Size of his muscles is only 1 aspect of football altogether out of the 10 involved
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top