List Mgmt. Contracts, trades, draft - 2022 superstar edition

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Link to contract status of all players -

 
The problem with Witherden is he's so damn slow. Daniel make be short but he's quicker in mind and body.
Witho is really just a one trick pony. It's a good trick but not elite.

He just doesn't provide enough drive and personally, I don't think he has the footy nous to play higher.
 
Last edited:
I would move on from Nicnat now and keep playing games into Jamo and Williams ..

Malthouse had a great idea, that he should be the second ruck and plonked in the forward pocket. When was the last time he played forward? It’s as though since he did his knee he either rucks or bench.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Unless you are Dean Cox, rucks are highly overrated. I don't think Jackson is going to be a generational player, bit undersized as a number 1 ruck and he is not a gun midfielder. We need quality midfielders.
 
Unless you are Dean Cox, rucks are highly overrated. I don't think Jackson is going to be a generational player, bit undersized as a number 1 ruck and he is not a gun midfielder. We need quality midfielders.
We would be mad to trade away our draft capital and salary cap space for Jackson. The ‘Kelly blunder’ all over again, surely we are not that thick.
 
Dockers trumped us for Luke Jackson ....rumoured 7 year deal offered .

If that's the sort of value attached to him, what would the trade look like? I struggle to see how Freo get a deal done. Their first round pick is looking like being 16-18, which won't be enough.

Being out of contract, he could nominate for the PSD... but takes the risk he ends up at North.
 
Yeah, definitely keep for me. With Hurn retiring and I'd like to see Rotham play on a wing.
Witherden is prone to an error or two but for the most part is pretty good. Definitely keep in the mix.

Next year defensive unit;
Cole Barrass Hough/Bazzo
Duggan McGov Jones

Depth: Foley, Witherden and Edwards

I'd prefer Hough TB Bazzo; Cole goes to 'depth' or plays on another line
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

If that's the sort of value attached to him, what would the trade look like? I struggle to see how Freo get a deal done. Their first round pick is looking like being 16-18, which won't be enough.

Being out of contract, he could nominate for the PSD... but takes the risk he ends up at North.

Lobb will be part of the trade + Freo first pick and future first and second Rd pick thrown in somewhere .
* probably unders but don't know Freos draft picks and they have NGA players everywhere available.
 
A lot of money and more than 1 high draft pick that they won't have, would probably cost future picks as well, you'd imagine Freo will have to up a few players deals that are already there after this season, going to be hard tying in a bloke for 7 years on huge dollars but you never know!
 
Used to love the anticipation build in the crowd when we realised the big fella was lurking in the forward line, the ball in true West Coast style comes in high and long and NAITANUI!!!!!

And everyone goes nuts.
Hes marked it 4 times in the forward line for his whole career,thats a lot of anticipation
Real shame he's never really capitalised on his leap

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
 
@$1.5m/yr too.

That’s according to Sumich so who really knows. ABC Sportstalk yesterday suggested Jackson has three offers Mel and 2 x WA teams all with similar $ and yrs.

Link - Rumour swirling AFL star ‘offered $10.5m’ — news.com.au

ABC team suggested Jackson’s final decision will be determined by the role & prospects at each club.

For mine, long and big contracts constrain list management too much. Would prefer 2 players at 750k than one at $1.5m.

Would take something huge like this to move Jackson , which thankfully rules WCE out ..
 
If that's the sort of value attached to him, what would the trade look like? I struggle to see how Freo get a deal done. Their first round pick is looking like being 16-18, which won't be enough.

Being out of contract, he could nominate for the PSD... but takes the risk he ends up at North.
They, Freo, would be much better served in throwing the kitchen sink at one of the King Brothers.

$1.5M a year. Let me know when he does something apart from the one game what's he going to command if he wins multiple AA and possessions up 25 a game. $2.5M?

Ludicrous
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top