- Thread starter
- #201
looking at the differences between my rankings and BF Phantom that happened recently
the balance between SA/WA/VIC/ALLIES in the Phantom Draft was a bit more reasonable than my rankings, as im a bit behind in my WA/SA information at this point of the year
Conrad Williams - he is one i have just outside my top 60, i've mentioned him a lot over the last 12 months
Jakob Ryan - apparently is in good form this year, wasnt overly impressed with him last year, so i'll wait until i see more
Harry Barnett - another i have liked and have him lower than he probably deserves
Ryan Eyers - 19 year old i believe from NSW border playing for Murray/Allies, has been better in his overage year, but im not sure?
Will Elliot - in the 2 games i saw him play this year he was very underwhelming, played as a ruckman resting forward and was beaten comprehensively, now he is having surgery on his knee
Toby McMullin - i dont know much about him, has not played this year
Tyson Walls - his height is an issue, can play and had a great game for the Allies as an underager SA player
Nick Sadler - i like his game and i probably should have him in my top 60
Hudson O'Keefe - he and McLarty are playing ruck for Oakleigh, both similar players with O'Keefe having a slight edge
Cameron Owen - Tassie ruck/forw, has not been overly impressive this year, a chance late/rookie
Will Verrall - SA ruck similar to Owen
Brodie Tuck - i have had him in my lists for a bit, maybe another i have dropped too far?
Jayden Davey - well if his brother goes mid-30's he will also probably get picked up
Eli Pearce - was one i have liked and was surprised when someone picked him in the BF Phantom Draft
Jovan Petric - another i have liked and surprised someone picked him in the BF Phantom Draft
Finn Emile-Brennan - a player who has good movement, but his ordinary disposal, lack of physical contests and slight build make me not as big of a fan as others are
Blake Hansen, Steely Green, Wade Derksen, Jasper Scaife and Luke Taylor are blind spots for me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ted Clohesy - he was really strong in the Geelong midfield earlier in the year, Geelong seem likely to get him 40+ at this rate
Josh Weddle - has been really strong defensively and as an attacking runner, is tall and has great athletic qualities for Oakleigh and more importantly knows how to play footy.
Jaxon Binns - i wasnt a huge fan of his u17s games last year at the champs, but this year he has been an attacking weapon for Dandenong on the wings/mid
Josh Bennetts/Zac Greeves - really liked their outputs for Eastern, would love to see them get opportunities at the champs level to see if they sink or swim
Coby Burgiel - another that has had a great year so far and i want to see how they do at a higher level
Jack O'Sullivan - was unlucky not to get drafted in the BF Phantom Draft, has had a couple of great games this season and was a highlight last year
Brady Wright - impact/x-factor player in the forwardline for GWV, GWV are a weak team this year so their top end talents arent able to shine as much, but he has a lot of talent as a forward imo
Ben McCarthy - Bris A player that reminds me of Maynard at Collingwood, good build, moves well, good disposal, strong in the contest, a diamond in the brisbane academy rough.
Harry Rowston - has been a really good player for GWS A and could be close to being picked up by GWS or a rival club potentially?
Angus Curry - GWS A playing for Oakleigh, in the same boat as Rowston where GWS might only take Lawrence and Madden and let the other 2 Academy players go into the open pool?
the balance between SA/WA/VIC/ALLIES in the Phantom Draft was a bit more reasonable than my rankings, as im a bit behind in my WA/SA information at this point of the year
Conrad Williams - he is one i have just outside my top 60, i've mentioned him a lot over the last 12 months
Jakob Ryan - apparently is in good form this year, wasnt overly impressed with him last year, so i'll wait until i see more
Harry Barnett - another i have liked and have him lower than he probably deserves
Ryan Eyers - 19 year old i believe from NSW border playing for Murray/Allies, has been better in his overage year, but im not sure?
Will Elliot - in the 2 games i saw him play this year he was very underwhelming, played as a ruckman resting forward and was beaten comprehensively, now he is having surgery on his knee
Toby McMullin - i dont know much about him, has not played this year
Tyson Walls - his height is an issue, can play and had a great game for the Allies as an underager SA player
Nick Sadler - i like his game and i probably should have him in my top 60
Hudson O'Keefe - he and McLarty are playing ruck for Oakleigh, both similar players with O'Keefe having a slight edge
Cameron Owen - Tassie ruck/forw, has not been overly impressive this year, a chance late/rookie
Will Verrall - SA ruck similar to Owen
Brodie Tuck - i have had him in my lists for a bit, maybe another i have dropped too far?
Jayden Davey - well if his brother goes mid-30's he will also probably get picked up
Eli Pearce - was one i have liked and was surprised when someone picked him in the BF Phantom Draft
Jovan Petric - another i have liked and surprised someone picked him in the BF Phantom Draft
Finn Emile-Brennan - a player who has good movement, but his ordinary disposal, lack of physical contests and slight build make me not as big of a fan as others are
Blake Hansen, Steely Green, Wade Derksen, Jasper Scaife and Luke Taylor are blind spots for me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ted Clohesy - he was really strong in the Geelong midfield earlier in the year, Geelong seem likely to get him 40+ at this rate
Josh Weddle - has been really strong defensively and as an attacking runner, is tall and has great athletic qualities for Oakleigh and more importantly knows how to play footy.
Jaxon Binns - i wasnt a huge fan of his u17s games last year at the champs, but this year he has been an attacking weapon for Dandenong on the wings/mid
Josh Bennetts/Zac Greeves - really liked their outputs for Eastern, would love to see them get opportunities at the champs level to see if they sink or swim
Coby Burgiel - another that has had a great year so far and i want to see how they do at a higher level
Jack O'Sullivan - was unlucky not to get drafted in the BF Phantom Draft, has had a couple of great games this season and was a highlight last year
Brady Wright - impact/x-factor player in the forwardline for GWV, GWV are a weak team this year so their top end talents arent able to shine as much, but he has a lot of talent as a forward imo
Ben McCarthy - Bris A player that reminds me of Maynard at Collingwood, good build, moves well, good disposal, strong in the contest, a diamond in the brisbane academy rough.
Harry Rowston - has been a really good player for GWS A and could be close to being picked up by GWS or a rival club potentially?
Angus Curry - GWS A playing for Oakleigh, in the same boat as Rowston where GWS might only take Lawrence and Madden and let the other 2 Academy players go into the open pool?
Last edited:
