-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Eagles : "No chance in hell Judd is going to collingwood"
- Thread starter The Magenius
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Sounds good. Good luck.
Of course unless carlton offer up 1 & 3, 5 and rivers would probably seal it.
Well I doubt he will want to end up at the black hole that is Richmond so he will agree to go somewhere good
That rules out Carlton, then.
Yeah, I think either Collingwood or Adelaide might have to sweeten the deal a fraction for the Bulldogs to go for it. But the basic give-and-take seems fairly feasible.
Judd will end up at Melbourne.
Done deal, is speaking with Gary Lyon frequently. Will get the number 3.
The trade will be something along the lines of;
Melbourne Trade: pick 4, pick 21 and Russell Robertson
Melbourne Receive: Chris Judd
Bulldogs Trade: Pick 5
Bulldogs Receive: Pick 21, Pick 30 and Russell Robertson
West Coast Trade: Chris Judd and Pick 30
West Coast Receive: Pick 4 and Pick 5
Something along those lines. Bulldogs extremely keen to get Robbo. Melbourne desperate for Judd. West Coast want early picks, they will have pick 4, pick 5 and pick 13.
Done deal, is speaking with Gary Lyon frequently. Will get the number 3.
The trade will be something along the lines of;
Melbourne Trade: pick 4, pick 21 and Russell Robertson
Melbourne Receive: Chris Judd
Bulldogs Trade: Pick 5
Bulldogs Receive: Pick 21, Pick 30 and Russell Robertson
West Coast Trade: Chris Judd and Pick 30
West Coast Receive: Pick 4 and Pick 5
Something along those lines. Bulldogs extremely keen to get Robbo. Melbourne desperate for Judd. West Coast want early picks, they will have pick 4, pick 5 and pick 13.
Not enough in this for thwe Dogs to give away pick 5 IMHO. Robbo plus 2 picks in a crappy draft doesn't cut it.
Probably right.
I have a feeling, no source that he will end up at Melbourne.
I know Gary Lyon has been in contact with him since it was announced he was leaving. Whether its got to do with advice or a big push for him to get to Melbourne I dont know.
Will be a good outcome if he ends up at the Demons.
- Apr 2, 2000
- 75,704
- 25,437
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Seriously ppl... were not taking pick 4 and 5 for Judd.
It's 1 and 3 we want and it's what we'll get.
You ppl are all crazy.
It's 1 and 3 we want and it's what we'll get.
You ppl are all crazy.
- Sep 25, 2006
- 18,364
- 14,631
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- FC Barcelona, Liverpool, FC Bayern
I've heard Worsfold say he would not stand in Judd's way. Once Judd narrows his preferences from 4 down to 1 and IF he chose Collingwood you would think WCE would get a deal done for one of their greatest players and return the favour to Judd for his service to the club.
And i don't think Collingwood would under-value their offer for Judd if he was keen on joining the pies because you would do everything in your power to land his signature however, it may not be the 'best possible offer' wce could receive out of any Judd deal. It would contain contents of a first rnd pick possibly 2 and most likely a very good player i would imagine (i.e didak, maybe davis/dick as WA boy's or even Rusling).
Surely WCE would try and get the best possible deal they can out of Judd's choice of club without losing him for nothing via the PSD draft. I just can't see WCE sending Judd to the PSD after how highly they thought of him as a person and as a servant of the footy club. They'll do the right thing by Judd, whilst doing the right thing by thier footy club me thinks.
Thoughts??
And i don't think Collingwood would under-value their offer for Judd if he was keen on joining the pies because you would do everything in your power to land his signature however, it may not be the 'best possible offer' wce could receive out of any Judd deal. It would contain contents of a first rnd pick possibly 2 and most likely a very good player i would imagine (i.e didak, maybe davis/dick as WA boy's or even Rusling).
Surely WCE would try and get the best possible deal they can out of Judd's choice of club without losing him for nothing via the PSD draft. I just can't see WCE sending Judd to the PSD after how highly they thought of him as a person and as a servant of the footy club. They'll do the right thing by Judd, whilst doing the right thing by thier footy club me thinks.
Thoughts??
juddy_Like
Norm Smith Medallist
What are the changes of Carlton and Richmond swapping picks??? Like Pick 2 for Pick 3 and Player X.
Will settle for:
Pick 1 & 3 (obviously)
Pick 2 & 3
Pick 3 & Fev
Pick 3 & Waite
Pick 3, 20 & Fisher
Im sure many Carlton supporters would tell me to get f'ddd but i would take those trades immediately.
Will settle for:
Pick 1 & 3 (obviously)
Pick 2 & 3
Pick 3 & Fev
Pick 3 & Waite
Pick 3, 20 & Fisher
Im sure many Carlton supporters would tell me to get f'ddd but i would take those trades immediately.
Chances wouldnt be good. Its not in Richmonds best interests to help a deal with Judd go through, so you would think a team would have to give a lot more than pick 2 is actually worth to get it.
juddy_Like
Norm Smith Medallist
I only ask because i can see us taking Cotchin instead of Morton, Palmer, Masten... the WA boys.
Kinda reminds me of when everyone thought we were going to nab Polak but settled for some hack with shit shoulders named Judd. Kinda turned out alright didn't it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melbourne_Demons
Check out the Current Squad, seems some Demons fans are pretty confident!
Check out the Current Squad, seems some Demons fans are pretty confident!
murphy_the_future
Draftee
As a Carlton supporter I want to keep Kruezer (pick #1) and Fev at all costs, and I think we can keep these two and stil work a fair deal for Judd. Reason being We need a good ruckman to service Judd in the future, and all contenders need a spear-head, and when fev is on his game they're arn't many better than him at kicking bags! Also i don't think WC would want fev to badly because Lynch and Fev would struggle to work together in the forward line as they play identicle styles, and fev is a bit of a livewire as we all know so is a big risk when your giving up a player as good as Judd.
The #3 is a given, but one option that hasn't been thrown up is Josh Kennedy. Held in pretty high regard as a future gun, can play key position, so i would think WC wouldn't mind him in the deal.
Deals I like;
- Pick #3, #20 & Kennedy
- #3 and waite (But it would hurt cos Waites a freak in training)
- #3 & Gibbs
murphy_the_future
Draftee
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melbourne_Demons
Check out the Current Squad, seems some Demons fans are pretty confident!
HAHAHAHAHAHA Also, when did they aquire Matthew Warnock? Just robbing WA of they're talent! haha
Great spot!
- Sep 13, 2006
- 2,519
- 20
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Victory,Storm,Rebels,Bushrangers
On 6pr tonight. from the eagles hierarchy.
Good luck Collingwood
Eagles hierarchy - "would prefer to walk over hot coals"
look I want him to go to the Demons but as long as he doesn't go to eddiewood I will be content
- Sep 13, 2006
- 2,519
- 20
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Victory,Storm,Rebels,Bushrangers
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melbourne_Demons
Check out the Current Squad, seems some Demons fans are pretty confident!
very good, I must congratulate the man who did it
Senior Analyst
Senior List
- Banned
- #99
That is bizarre!
