-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Review Good, Bad and Ugly vs Collingwood
- Thread starter Carmo
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Are there still people on here that think Keays is more the issue than Fog ??
Without keays we lose last week by 6-7 goals and about 15 today
Heck he nearly allowed us to win a game which looks even more remarkable now
Without keays we lose last week by 6-7 goals and about 15 today
Heck he nearly allowed us to win a game which looks even more remarkable now
crowholder
All Australian
- Jul 26, 2018
- 904
- 917
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- West Torrens... I mean WWT
Good
Cook, Keays, Smith, Dawson and Hinge were probably our best today
Whatever tactic we used to get the 666 rule against the Pies. It was one of the only ways we could win a free kick.
Bad
Our tall forwards (Fog and Himms)
Ugly
Umpiring
Poor ball use on too many occasions
Cook, Keays, Smith, Dawson and Hinge were probably our best today
Whatever tactic we used to get the 666 rule against the Pies. It was one of the only ways we could win a free kick.
Bad
Our tall forwards (Fog and Himms)
Ugly
Umpiring
Poor ball use on too many occasions
Surprised that a few have escaped the wrath but people have a love of certain players.
The real bad
Umpires - killed us
Schoenberg - dreadful 12 disposals, should be dropped for that but we really can't.
Sloane - none entity and just bad, needs a spell to get himself right
Himmelberg - nothing to say
FOG - kept presenting but bloody awful
McHenry - didn't do anything positive
ROB - did nothing, Straughan would at least give our mids good service
The Bad
Rowe - if you can't kick goals back to the SANFL
Murray - needs a spell to learn to settle with ball or moved up forward
Scholl - his dinky kicks are starting to annoy me
Jones - not an ideal game
Average
Pedlar - like him just needs to be rotated middle and forward not pure forward
Gollant - competed but ineffective
The Good
Crouch - actually thought he was class in the guts
Keays
Rachele
Dawson
Dude
Smith
Cook
Brown
Hinge
Butts
The real bad
Umpires - killed us
Schoenberg - dreadful 12 disposals, should be dropped for that but we really can't.
Sloane - none entity and just bad, needs a spell to get himself right
Himmelberg - nothing to say
FOG - kept presenting but bloody awful
McHenry - didn't do anything positive
ROB - did nothing, Straughan would at least give our mids good service
The Bad
Rowe - if you can't kick goals back to the SANFL
Murray - needs a spell to learn to settle with ball or moved up forward
Scholl - his dinky kicks are starting to annoy me
Jones - not an ideal game
Average
Pedlar - like him just needs to be rotated middle and forward not pure forward
Gollant - competed but ineffective
The Good
Crouch - actually thought he was class in the guts
Keays
Rachele
Dawson
Dude
Smith
Cook
Brown
Hinge
Butts
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 61,624
- 164,817
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #81
List of issues to fix
- Kicking
- Handballing
- Marking
- Kicking goals from set shots
- Kicking goals from snaps
- Kicking goals from stoppages
- Crumbing off tall forwards
- Kicking inside 50
- Marking inside 50
- Leading inside 50
- Transition between midfield and forward
- Dynamic forward movement
- Defensive running
- Midfield positioning
- Ruck craft
- Ruck work around the ground
- Decision making
- Hitting targets under no pressure
- Hitting targets under pressure
- Speed of ball movement
- Speed of players
- Strength in the contest
- Defensive structure
- Defensive transition
- Use of outlet players
- Selections
- Use of talented players
- Playing players in the correct position
- Drafting
- Contracts
- List management
- Long term drafting strategy
- Player development
UcantCme
Premiership Player
- Mar 3, 2021
- 3,912
- 5,794
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Our composure and skill level not AFL standard
It's hard to see or judge a game plan when skills and decision making is so bad
Time to pull the pin on Himmelberg, yes he had a patch if 5-6 quality games in 2020 but either side of that he has been poo, I hate KPF or don't provide a contest
Brown, time to be a leader at sanfl level, for his experience he gives nothing
Our midfield needs a complete transformation, it needs more power, speed and good ball users, we are going nowhere with pure grunt players , the mix with Crouch, Keays and Sloane is just so wrong and unfortunately everyone sees this except for our coaches
On SM-G973F using BigFooty.com mobile app
It's hard to see or judge a game plan when skills and decision making is so bad
Time to pull the pin on Himmelberg, yes he had a patch if 5-6 quality games in 2020 but either side of that he has been poo, I hate KPF or don't provide a contest
Brown, time to be a leader at sanfl level, for his experience he gives nothing
Our midfield needs a complete transformation, it needs more power, speed and good ball users, we are going nowhere with pure grunt players , the mix with Crouch, Keays and Sloane is just so wrong and unfortunately everyone sees this except for our coaches
On SM-G973F using BigFooty.com mobile app
I thought Dawson was pretty good. One of the few players we gave on the list who has good foot skills. I know he left sydney for family reasons but but that's not looking like a good decision from an individual point of view. He is class.
Rachele - thought he looked pretty good when he went into the midfield. Another one who has good foot skills.
Butts - good game defensively
Cook - showed glimpses of why he can be a very good player at this level.
Our skill level is woeful
Our ball movement is garbage. Game plan?
Our tackling is ordinary.
The delivery to the forwards is shocking. In saying this I've seen enough of himmelberg, time to move on from him.
I know pedlar is underdone but we need to see him with some time in the midfield.
Schoenberg kicking is a big concern.
Midfield one paced and lacks skill. Crouch has no penetration or hurt factor what so ever. Need some pace in the midfield.
Rachele - thought he looked pretty good when he went into the midfield. Another one who has good foot skills.
Butts - good game defensively
Cook - showed glimpses of why he can be a very good player at this level.
Our skill level is woeful
Our ball movement is garbage. Game plan?
Our tackling is ordinary.
The delivery to the forwards is shocking. In saying this I've seen enough of himmelberg, time to move on from him.
I know pedlar is underdone but we need to see him with some time in the midfield.
Schoenberg kicking is a big concern.
Midfield one paced and lacks skill. Crouch has no penetration or hurt factor what so ever. Need some pace in the midfield.
Last edited:
UcantCme
Premiership Player
- Mar 3, 2021
- 3,912
- 5,794
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Cook must keep playing
I like Jordy with ball in hand
Fog is a better player when he gets a 2nd, or 3rd defender
Ned, I love his tenacity and pressure acts however needs to get back to what we started to see Kate last year where he started to show a little more composure
Pedlar must play AFL however needs to get some midfield minutes
On SM-G973F using BigFooty.com mobile app
I like Jordy with ball in hand
Fog is a better player when he gets a 2nd, or 3rd defender
Ned, I love his tenacity and pressure acts however needs to get back to what we started to see Kate last year where he started to show a little more composure
Pedlar must play AFL however needs to get some midfield minutes
On SM-G973F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Scorpus
Moderator
- Apr 16, 2014
- 61,624
- 164,817
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Moderator
- #90
I struggle to see us starting favorites in any match this season. We play all of Gold Coast, Hawthorn and North away (North in Tasmania)
Our first game going in as favorites might be the round 22 match against North Melbourne at home depending on how the season plays out
Our first game going in as favorites might be the round 22 match against North Melbourne at home depending on how the season plays out
Canuck_Crow
Senior List
So to summarize Football in general
True , Himmelberg was actually able to have enough looks however he’s just no good and wasn’t able to capitalise
He took 2x I50 marks and dropped 2 other very gettables , almost east marks . There is 4
He also got hit up outside 50
Surely TT can do that but actually capitalise , hopefully he comes back hungry after watching that and thinking he should be out there
I can't see how people are critical of Fog
Sure he gave 4 free kicks , some dubious , but **** me, they either kick in front of him when he's running backwards, over his head if he's leading forward.
He is in a no win situation with this teams horrendous midfield.
Sure he gave 4 free kicks , some dubious , but **** me, they either kick in front of him when he's running backwards, over his head if he's leading forward.
He is in a no win situation with this teams horrendous midfield.
Yeah we're not to far away.
But they try hard. That's what matters.
Oh and the good family. Don't forget that.
- Jul 22, 2016
- 3,475
- 5,363
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Used to drive me nuts how much people from here used to ridicule them. Rebuilding sides can fall into this trouble, I'm sure we'll find our way out of it faster than them but looks like we may have a very tough year ahead. Draw really only looks favourable to us in the back half but damage may be done by then.
- Oct 6, 2012
- 13,740
- 27,818
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
Geez. Were Himmelberg and Shoenberg have a contest on who could kick the ball higher today?
We have a team of players that have either poor disposal, bad decision making and in quite a few cases both. What a team of hacks.
We have a team of players that have either poor disposal, bad decision making and in quite a few cases both. What a team of hacks.
