Do we all agree "Chad Cornes" is in fact "Kane Cornes"?
Does that make the selection a little more accurate?
Does that make the selection a little more accurate?
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Mike's Top 50
- Thread starter Paul Kersey
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 22, 2000
- 62,351
- 41,703
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Ford
FFS,how many times do some moaners need to be told that it's Kane Cornes,not Chad 
Timbo's Top 50
1. Gary Ablett
2. Lance Franklin
3. Luke Hodge
4. Simon Black
5. Chris Judd
6. Brent Harvey
7. Adam Cooney
8. Brendan Fevola
9. James Bartel
10. Joel Corey
11. Dean Cox
12. Matthew Richardson
13. Matthew Pavlich
14. Nick Riewoldt
15. Sam Fisher
16. Sam Mitchell
17. Matthew Scarlett
18. Jonathan Brown
19. Joel Selwood
20. Brett Deledio
21. Daniel Cross
22. Cameron Ling
23. Max Hudghton
24. Nathan Bock
25. Andrew Mackie
26. Chance Bateman
27. Daniel Bradshaw
28. Brett Kirk
29. Daniel Motlop
30. Kane Cornes
31. Paul Medhurst
32. Steve Johnson
33. Jarrod Roughead
34. Dale Morris
35. Ryan O'Keefe
36. Lindsay Gilbee
37. Corey Enright
38. Dane Swan
39. Brad Sewell
40. Robert Murphy
41. Lenny Hayes
42. Tom Harley
43. Jarrad McVeigh
44. Mark McVeigh
45. Drew Petrie
46. Luke Power
47. David Hille
48. Ryan Griffen
49. Scott Thompson
50. Leon Davis
Much better?
1. Gary Ablett
2. Lance Franklin
3. Luke Hodge
4. Simon Black
5. Chris Judd
6. Brent Harvey
7. Adam Cooney
8. Brendan Fevola
9. James Bartel
10. Joel Corey
11. Dean Cox
12. Matthew Richardson
13. Matthew Pavlich
14. Nick Riewoldt
15. Sam Fisher
16. Sam Mitchell
17. Matthew Scarlett
18. Jonathan Brown
19. Joel Selwood
20. Brett Deledio
21. Daniel Cross
22. Cameron Ling
23. Max Hudghton
24. Nathan Bock
25. Andrew Mackie
26. Chance Bateman
27. Daniel Bradshaw
28. Brett Kirk
29. Daniel Motlop
30. Kane Cornes
31. Paul Medhurst
32. Steve Johnson
33. Jarrod Roughead
34. Dale Morris
35. Ryan O'Keefe
36. Lindsay Gilbee
37. Corey Enright
38. Dane Swan
39. Brad Sewell
40. Robert Murphy
41. Lenny Hayes
42. Tom Harley
43. Jarrad McVeigh
44. Mark McVeigh
45. Drew Petrie
46. Luke Power
47. David Hille
48. Ryan Griffen
49. Scott Thompson
50. Leon Davis
Much better?
As always its just one guys opinion and he's entitled to it...wouldnt matter what order it was there'd be complaints.
Some interesting high rankings tho...none moreso than Sam Fisher's rocket to stardom.
Tend to agree with it...the guy has actually become one of the games elite yet is still largely unrecognised as such. Was an inch off AA (in the squad) last year as well and i see him and Bock as the prototype attacking defenders all clubs want right now.
Bock and Fisher should be ranked alongside...boith about 20ish IMO. These guys had seasons to make other coaches green with envy...KP defenders that set up your attack are absolute gold in modern footy. Scarlett another one who had a good season setting up a lot of attack.
Some interesting high rankings tho...none moreso than Sam Fisher's rocket to stardom.
Tend to agree with it...the guy has actually become one of the games elite yet is still largely unrecognised as such. Was an inch off AA (in the squad) last year as well and i see him and Bock as the prototype attacking defenders all clubs want right now.
Bock and Fisher should be ranked alongside...boith about 20ish IMO. These guys had seasons to make other coaches green with envy...KP defenders that set up your attack are absolute gold in modern footy. Scarlett another one who had a good season setting up a lot of attack.
- Jan 1, 2007
- 6,665
- 10,138
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Come on - that hand injury? AFL players harbour niggles week in week out and survive and thrive.
In that Prelim final, Max comprehensively played Buddy out of the game in the first quarter. It was a stunning performance - rivalled then topped only by the fact that Hawthorn realised this and then easily found and targeted many other avenues to goal.
aussieicon91
All Australian
1. Gary Ablett (1-2)
2. Lance Franklin (1-2)
3. Joel Corey (10-20)
4. Luke Hodge (1-5)
5. Matthew Scarlett (10-20)
6. Brent Harvey (1-10)
7. James Bartel (1-10)
8. Brendan Fevola (10-20)
9. Adam Cooney (1-10)
10. Chris Judd (1-10)
11. Sam Fisher (30-40)
12. Matthew Richardson (30-40)
13. Matthew Pavlich (1-10)
14. Nick Riewoldt (15-25)
15. Dean Cox (1-10)
16. Joel Selwood (20-25)
17. Simon Black (5-15)
18. Jonathan Brown (5-15)
19. Sam Mitchell (15-20)
20. Tom Harley (50+)
21. Daniel Cross (20-30)
22. Cameron Ling (15-25)
23. Max Hudghton (20-30)
24. Nathan Bock (20-30)
25. Andrew Mackie (50+)
26. Chance Bateman (20-25)
27. Daniel Bradshaw (20-25)
28. Drew Petrie (40-50)
29. Corey Enright (30-40)
30. Kane Cornes (20-30)
31. Paul Medhurst (30-40)
32. Steve Johnson (20-30)
33. Jarrod Roughead (30-40)
34. Dale Morris (30-40)
35. Ryan O'Keefe (40-50)
36. Leon Davis (45-50)
37. Daniel Motlop (35-45)
38. Aaron Sandilands (30-40)
39. Brad Sewell (20-30)
40. Robert Murphy (20-30)
41. Brett Kirk (30-40)
42. Brett Deledio (35-45)
43. Jarrad McVeigh (40-50)
44. Dane Swan (35-45)
45. Lenny Hayes (40-50)
46. Luke Power (35-45)
47. Scott Thompson (45-50)
48. Michael Osbourne (50+)
49. David Hille (45-50)
50. Matthew Boyd (50+)
2. Lance Franklin (1-2)
3. Joel Corey (10-20)
4. Luke Hodge (1-5)
5. Matthew Scarlett (10-20)
6. Brent Harvey (1-10)
7. James Bartel (1-10)
8. Brendan Fevola (10-20)
9. Adam Cooney (1-10)
10. Chris Judd (1-10)
11. Sam Fisher (30-40)
12. Matthew Richardson (30-40)
13. Matthew Pavlich (1-10)
14. Nick Riewoldt (15-25)
15. Dean Cox (1-10)
16. Joel Selwood (20-25)
17. Simon Black (5-15)
18. Jonathan Brown (5-15)
19. Sam Mitchell (15-20)
20. Tom Harley (50+)
21. Daniel Cross (20-30)
22. Cameron Ling (15-25)
23. Max Hudghton (20-30)
24. Nathan Bock (20-30)
25. Andrew Mackie (50+)
26. Chance Bateman (20-25)
27. Daniel Bradshaw (20-25)
28. Drew Petrie (40-50)
29. Corey Enright (30-40)
30. Kane Cornes (20-30)
31. Paul Medhurst (30-40)
32. Steve Johnson (20-30)
33. Jarrod Roughead (30-40)
34. Dale Morris (30-40)
35. Ryan O'Keefe (40-50)
36. Leon Davis (45-50)
37. Daniel Motlop (35-45)
38. Aaron Sandilands (30-40)
39. Brad Sewell (20-30)
40. Robert Murphy (20-30)
41. Brett Kirk (30-40)
42. Brett Deledio (35-45)
43. Jarrad McVeigh (40-50)
44. Dane Swan (35-45)
45. Lenny Hayes (40-50)
46. Luke Power (35-45)
47. Scott Thompson (45-50)
48. Michael Osbourne (50+)
49. David Hille (45-50)
50. Matthew Boyd (50+)
- Aug 29, 2006
- 4,394
- 4,767
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
Come on - that hand injury? AFL players harbour niggles week in week out and survive and thrive.
In that Prelim final, Max comprehensively played Buddy out of the game in the first quarter. It was a stunning performance - rivalled then topped only by the fact that Hawthorn realised this and then easily found and targeted many other avenues to goal.
Agreed, in the prelim Maxy beat Buddy pretty easily, and that was probably the first time all year that he has been comprehensively beaten.
However i dont think he was "smashed" during the home and away as some supporters tend to think. Buddy beat him pretty easily in the first half kicking 3 goals, and got no supply in the second half.
Your missing Ozzie!
dunno bout motlop at 29, hes dangerous but doesnt have the consistensy. lenny hayes probably deserves to be further up in the rankings, definately ahead of motlop and corey enright. mackie should have got AA ahead of enright. mackie has a huge futur
i love mikes top 50. apart from the geelong players and richo (sorry everyone) most of those players make their possessions count. I would much rather have a team of 10-15 possession getters who miss the target once, then a team of 20+possession getters who cant do a thing with it.
This year he mostly picked a list who uses the ball well, and influences results. rather then picking a list based on hype (corey excluded)
This year he mostly picked a list who uses the ball well, and influences results. rather then picking a list based on hype (corey excluded)
Is that just based on this years performances???
When Harley was knocked out in the Grand final the defense lost it's way. Was it just a coincidence?
James Bond 008
Senior List
It's all BS all based on this year performances waste of time.
Tony Campbell (with glove) board
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
Go Chad, doesn't even have to do anything to get in the top 50. Maybe if he can play fifteen games next year he'll win the Brownlow.
Schulzenfest
TheBrownDog
The Motlop consistency thing is a bit of a misconception based on previous years. This year he was only goalless twice (very good for a small forward) and scored at least two goals in 16 out of 21 games. To put that in perspective, Franklin failed to kick at least 2 goals in 4 games this year out of 25, and Motlop five out of 21. It's a difference, but it's not exactly a huge one.
He isnt playing at Carlton and his name isnt Chris Judd.
- Sep 15, 2007
- 16,174
- 16,669
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Bit shocked to see his love child at number 10...
It's not a bad list, it will always be controversial. Still, Sheehan is a nob...
He has his agenda and believes his own hype. After talking the cats amazing team up all year, he cannot be seen to contradict himself.
For the first year in a row though I dont give a ****, we won what matters, the rest can think whatever they like.
It's not a bad list, it will always be controversial. Still, Sheehan is a nob...
Mike Sheehan said:
He has his agenda and believes his own hype. After talking the cats amazing team up all year, he cannot be seen to contradict himself.
For the first year in a row though I dont give a ****, we won what matters, the rest can think whatever they like.
- Sep 15, 2007
- 16,174
- 16,669
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Probably, he was being soundly beaten by Brown in the first half anyway.
Gozz
All Australian
My Analysis:
1. Gary Ablett
2. Lance Franklin
3. Joel Corey - Probably around 10 is right.
4. Luke Hodge - Probably biggest disgrace of all, should be late 40s.
5. Matthew Scarlett - Far too high, 20s.
6. Brent Harvey
7. James Bartel
8. Brendan Fevola
9. Adam Cooney - If he hadn't won the Brownlow nobody would have him here, 20s.
10. Chris Judd - Second biggest disgrace of all, 3.
11. Sam Fisher - Absolutely spot on, great to see this guy get recognised.
12. Matthew Richardson
13. Matthew Pavlich
14. Nick Riewoldt
15. Dean Cox - Should be top 10 at the least, if not top 6 or so.
16. Joel Selwood - Gun, but a tad too high.
17. Simon Black
18. Jonathan Brown
19. Sam Mitchell
20. Tom Harley
21. Daniel Cross - Good to see him up here well done sheehan.
22. Cameron Ling
23. Max Hudghton - hmm maybe a slight adjustment to >100.
24. Nathan Bock
25. Andrew Mackie - Probably 40ish is more accurate but good to see him recognised.
26. Chance Bateman - Mike is caught up in the premiership hype.
27. Daniel Bradshaw
28. Drew Petrie - correct.
29. Corey Enright
30. Chad Cornes - interesting.
31. Paul Medhurst
32. Steve Johnson
33. Jarrod Roughead
34. Dale Morris
35. Ryan O'Keefe - probably not top 50 this year
36. Leon Davis - not as outrageuos as some people think I reckon he is quite accurate.
37. Daniel Motlop
38. Aaron Sandilands - Get out!!!
39. Brad Sewell - Well deserved.
40. Robert Murphy
41. Brett Kirk
42. Brett Deledio
43. Jarrad McVeigh
44. Dane Swan
45. Lenny Hayes
46. Luke Power - No, not this year.
47. Scott Thompson
48. Michael Osbourne - Hahaha Sheehan has lost the plot here. Osborne is okay but not top 50.
49. David Hille
50. Matthew Boyd
Overall diagnosis: Sheehan is a looney.
1. Gary Ablett
2. Lance Franklin
3. Joel Corey - Probably around 10 is right.
4. Luke Hodge - Probably biggest disgrace of all, should be late 40s.
5. Matthew Scarlett - Far too high, 20s.
6. Brent Harvey
7. James Bartel
8. Brendan Fevola
9. Adam Cooney - If he hadn't won the Brownlow nobody would have him here, 20s.
10. Chris Judd - Second biggest disgrace of all, 3.
11. Sam Fisher - Absolutely spot on, great to see this guy get recognised.
12. Matthew Richardson
13. Matthew Pavlich
14. Nick Riewoldt
15. Dean Cox - Should be top 10 at the least, if not top 6 or so.
16. Joel Selwood - Gun, but a tad too high.
17. Simon Black
18. Jonathan Brown
19. Sam Mitchell
20. Tom Harley
21. Daniel Cross - Good to see him up here well done sheehan.
22. Cameron Ling
23. Max Hudghton - hmm maybe a slight adjustment to >100.
24. Nathan Bock
25. Andrew Mackie - Probably 40ish is more accurate but good to see him recognised.
26. Chance Bateman - Mike is caught up in the premiership hype.
27. Daniel Bradshaw
28. Drew Petrie - correct.
29. Corey Enright
30. Chad Cornes - interesting.
31. Paul Medhurst
32. Steve Johnson
33. Jarrod Roughead
34. Dale Morris
35. Ryan O'Keefe - probably not top 50 this year
36. Leon Davis - not as outrageuos as some people think I reckon he is quite accurate.
37. Daniel Motlop
38. Aaron Sandilands - Get out!!!
39. Brad Sewell - Well deserved.
40. Robert Murphy
41. Brett Kirk
42. Brett Deledio
43. Jarrad McVeigh
44. Dane Swan
45. Lenny Hayes
46. Luke Power - No, not this year.
47. Scott Thompson
48. Michael Osbourne - Hahaha Sheehan has lost the plot here. Osborne is okay but not top 50.
49. David Hille
50. Matthew Boyd
Overall diagnosis: Sheehan is a looney.
Putting Michael Osborne at number 48 is like selecting Kwame Brown in the NBA All Star Game.
tin can sam
Club Legend
well, the 1 and 2 were undisputed. He couldn't get that wrong.
Everything else is opinion. Corey and Hodge seem high, but not that high.
Sewell and Kirk seem too low, but that's bound to happen.
Overall rating - 1 man's opinion, get over it.
Everything else is opinion. Corey and Hodge seem high, but not that high.
Sewell and Kirk seem too low, but that's bound to happen.
Overall rating - 1 man's opinion, get over it.
ROFL 
Thanks for that, I needed a good laugh!! Osborne has been fantastic this year though and has achieved more than Kwame ever will in his career!
As for the Top 50, it's kinda funny how so many people get their knickers in a twist over it. It used to piss me off but honestly, it's just one guy's opinion and doesn't really matter all that much.
