AFL Autopsy NAB Challenge Game the Third: Wet Toast v Essendon, Domain Stadium, 4.10PM Western Time, 13/3/16

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

I love it when they try and mention a player they clearly know nothing about.
Baguley: an improving defender.
He's a blue chip small defender, you nonse.
 
I can honestly say, this would be BJ's worst game in his career, I hope this isn't a sign of his season to come
 
I can honestly say, this would be BJ's worst game in his career, I hope this isn't a sign of his season to come

He tilts so easily. I'd love to play poker against him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I'd say so. But the more interesting question is, who out of the current players are not best 22?
Yeah it's a tough one. Kelly and Stokes have been good and stay in. Dea has been good today, as has Ambrose, neither of whom I would have had in the best 22. McKenna will need to be upgraded to play, as will Walla. You'd think both are likely to be upgraded.

First, I'll consider the best 22 to be the team most likely to win a game, not who I think should be played for development etc.

For me Kommer, Ambrose and Jamar will go out. If Grima is fit then Grimley goes out for Brown to stay forward while Hartley, Grima and Gwilt fill the KPD spots.

I like Walla but needs more improvement to be best 22, he goes out. I like Jackson Merrett but hard to see him being much more than 23rd/24th player unless he can get amongst it more.

As I type this Grimley is playing better so it will be between him and Gwilt depending on whether they want Brown forward or back.

McKenna should get some games and I think he has a big future but not best 22 yet.

Dea will go when Dempsey comes back. Then I'd decide whether Parish and/or Edwards will provide more than Cooney and Fantasia who I think has a good future.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AFL Autopsy NAB Challenge Game the Third: Wet Toast v Essendon, Domain Stadium, 4.10PM Western Time, 13/3/16

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top