Autopsy NAB Cup Rd 3 vs Hawthorn

[sickzau]

hodge, franklin, Rioli. Sewell, Gunston, Guerra, Lake, Hale, Breust. Whitecross, Osborne,

 

[tigs2010]

His kicking is still a worry IMO

Does not hit the targets he should

Fair call as I said he's inconsistent. I'm not a fan of his kicking action. 2-handed ball drop. Probably why he can be hit and miss.

 

[tigs2010]

hodge, franklin, Rioli. Sewell, Gunston, Guerra, Lake, Hale, Breust. Whitecross, Osborne,

We had ours out last week and still won. What's your point?

 

[theflea]

A.Edwards... Thoughts?

hasnt shown anything.

 

[sickzau]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

 

[Darth_Tiger]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

Did you actually read anything? We have all been saying pretty much the same.

 

[TigerGlory]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

Pretty sure just about everybody in this thread is disappointed with the effort. But im not surprised you cant read given your grammar is quiet bad.

 

[jesterx]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

I honestly expected you to thrash the bulldogs but hey shit happens right? Now gtfo.

 

[theflea]

Some of them were kicking to contests long down the line because he didn't have a loose option. Like every player should. Hardly a fluffed kick. If our players don't win the contest then it's hardly his fault.

I counted about 6 floaters. Kicking to contests is fine, floaters not. I'm a little more critical bc he can do alot better than that. We just cant afford poor kicking out of B50.

 

[Gringo Star]

A win is a win in my book. Took me 20 minutes to settle myself down.

 

[Groupie_]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

Pre season game. Means nothing

 

[Heisenberg_]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

Exactly what we have all been saying.

Go away and don't bother posting here if its to deliberately antagonise people.

 

[theflea]

A Edwards needs to work a bit more on his forward pressure. Jack was like that his first couple of seasons but has really learnt this skill now. I saw Edwards ball watching a couple of times in that last quarter.

S Edwards though, looking good. White has also been excellent so far. Is there room for both White and Foley?

I'd be happy if he just took a mark or 2!!!

 

[Joker91]

Is anyone else worried about Dustin Martin? I think he's going to be just a serviceable player and not the superstar everyone thought he would be

He has been our best player this pre season not including today's game?

 

[Darth_Tiger]

I'm really happy it was an after the siren win. Made me actually feel good and pumped at the end. As they say though, good teams win ugly and we did that today.

 

[sickzau]

haha, its a nab cup match no need to get nasty... I personally couldn't give a stuff win / loss.

Its just great to watch the kids in action tho..

Ps... Riewolt to kick 70+ this year if he can just become more goal hungry

 

[jesterx]

Apology accepted!

 

[Stylo]

Its just great to watch the kids in action tho..

Yep, you guys have some good 'uns rising through the ranks too. Jed Anderson is a gem.

 

[tigs2010]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

Lol probably would have paid to have read the thread before looking like a complete goose. Lucky for Hawthorn we didn't play well. Remembering we beat your proper side by 10 goals last year in the wet which we don't play well in.

 

[Yelle]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

I'd rather play your full side, we would've won by ten goals again

 

[theflea]

Was real offended when King got that free for in the back.

Considering its been happening all game by players of both clubs, frankly for 2 years its a little mind boggling. fact is shaw hates us and waits with bated breath to can us at any given moment.

 

[djspank]

How was that attack on lids' kicking?????????


I can't even fathom how you could have thought his kicking was suspect. Shaw just being a Moo for Moo sake esp about the tigers.

not to mention the audible sighs every time we took a mark!
Also the flog can never help himself and continually knocks all our players. Him and BT are two Collingwood flogs in a pod who have been offended at some point by RFC!

 

[Tigersman]

Scratchy effort. Matty white good. Chaplin a tick first up. Cotchin some great last quarter efforts. Vickery needs to be better but did a couple of things, enough to keep my faith for now.

 

[smasha]

A win's a win and that win was very important for us.

Imagine the media.Richmond lose ANOTHER close one.
I think that's Hawthorn's 3rd close loss but do you see the media lambasting them?

 

[theflea]

lmao.... you actually rate that win at all? If you guys played like that in the real season you would get done by just about every team.

I honestly expected richmond to belt the hawks today quiet badly.

You just couldn't help yourself give you champ?