Im not sure of much with the NFNL tribunal system, but im sure he isn’t walking away with 1 week for that.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
NFNL Div 3 discussion 2022
- Thread starter red_ranga
- Start date
- Tagged users None
My 2 cents as an impartial observer
Thompson, trying to stop ball carrier with ball, lunges to tackle seen plenty of tackles like this during the year, if Sth Morang player misses the ball, will be paid holding. His head does hit the ground but I think it’s a football act, not sure what Thompson could have done
Hall, vision seems to show 1-2 punches, from what I can see, if he has been offered 2 weeks with red card, I would just take that.
The head butt, again hard to see clear vision but Laurimar player does go down and has to be assisted from the ground. Definite head butt and i would say 2-4 weeks
Both clubs pretty dumb to risk players one week before finals.
Will make for an interesting 2nd semi final in a few weeks time
Thompson, trying to stop ball carrier with ball, lunges to tackle seen plenty of tackles like this during the year, if Sth Morang player misses the ball, will be paid holding. His head does hit the ground but I think it’s a football act, not sure what Thompson could have done
Hall, vision seems to show 1-2 punches, from what I can see, if he has been offered 2 weeks with red card, I would just take that.
The head butt, again hard to see clear vision but Laurimar player does go down and has to be assisted from the ground. Definite head butt and i would say 2-4 weeks
Both clubs pretty dumb to risk players one week before finals.
Will make for an interesting 2nd semi final in a few weeks time
I’d be surprised if the league didn’t request Hall to attend the tribunal. I think there’s been much less given 2 weeks this season.
nfnlegend
Team Captain
- Aug 5, 2019
- 316
- 243
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
- Banned
- #1,330
Hall basically teleports to Thompson straight after the tackle. Doesn’t bother to check on the state of his team mate. Like he didn’t even know he was “knocked out” at that stage and that was his reaction?
Seems like a excuse to lay into Laurimars best player to me.
The ruckman is beyond stupid. Kicks someone then head butts. May as well head off to football trip.
Seems like a excuse to lay into Laurimars best player to me.
The ruckman is beyond stupid. Kicks someone then head butts. May as well head off to football trip.
As some that just follows local footy. This sums up Div 3 footy, to many blokes that don't have footy IQ and skill. Can beat them with football skill so bash them... wow, massive step back in class.
L 17, poor tackling skill, causes SM player to hit his head on ground. Was a footy ball action, done really poorly. Should get a couple of weeks
SM 11, not a football action. To jump onto a player on the ground and strike a player is just stupid and wrong. Looks like several strikes before the melee, and guessing several more in the bottom of the pack. Should get minimum 4-6.
SM 27, stupid action. Headbutting, real tuff man, and then walks away and lets his team mates sort it out. Should get 4-6 weeks minimum.
The actions should be judged, not the force.
Might be time blokes to focus on the footy etc instead of the lack of discipline. Even martial arts fighters understand discipline. This happens way to many times at Div 3 level (multiple times with Mernda, stuff at SM several years ago). This stuff is killing the reputation of the NFNL.
L 17, poor tackling skill, causes SM player to hit his head on ground. Was a footy ball action, done really poorly. Should get a couple of weeks
SM 11, not a football action. To jump onto a player on the ground and strike a player is just stupid and wrong. Looks like several strikes before the melee, and guessing several more in the bottom of the pack. Should get minimum 4-6.
SM 27, stupid action. Headbutting, real tuff man, and then walks away and lets his team mates sort it out. Should get 4-6 weeks minimum.
The actions should be judged, not the force.
Might be time blokes to focus on the footy etc instead of the lack of discipline. Even martial arts fighters understand discipline. This happens way to many times at Div 3 level (multiple times with Mernda, stuff at SM several years ago). This stuff is killing the reputation of the NFNL.
If NFNL are serious about supporting to end the coward punch then the bloke from SM who was first in doesn't play footy again this year. Plenty of ways to show support rather than resorting to throwing punches while a bloke is defenceless on the ground.
Interesting viewing . 11 is coaches son isn’t he ? I think league will find a few more in that footage .Laurimar
nfnl.sportscastcloud.com
Part 1 end of the quarter…
tigerkelly
Team Captain
- Jun 12, 2010
- 334
- 48
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Certainly interesting viewing, as a separate matter, although they did not appear to be involved in any action, are the runners from both teams allowed to be on the ground during the melee.
Did Hall get sent to the tribunal or been able to take the 2? Was Mitch Thomson investigated?
Lazaric called to the tribunal?
Big week in D3!
Lazaric called to the tribunal?
Big week in D3!
Scrolling through facebook and i stumble across the Whittlesea highlights from the weekend.
Whittlesea showgrounds looking very ordinary.
Big cold snap hitting this week too. Would they consider a late change of venue?
Whittlesea showgrounds looking very ordinary.
Big cold snap hitting this week too. Would they consider a late change of venue?
EBERT THE KING just had a look at division 1 fixture and Whittlesea’s last 2 games are both away so ground should be fine
- Oct 3, 2017
- 1,466
- 684
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Intriguing week of footy to finish for the top 4. All dead rubbers.
Morang v Mernda
Turtles v West
Kilmore v Ressa
Laurimar v Lalor
Kilmore and Laurimar likely to face bruise free footy and can rest a few v Morang and Turtles to face much more physical contests in the tough conditions. All teams will be hoping to avoid further injury and suspension.
Interesting to see if the Turtles are disadvantaged by playing against more mature bodies on there home ground a week out from finals compared to Kilmore facing off against a youthful reservoir.
Not sure he would get investigated for the tackle momentum just took
Him forward and unlucky landing. You’d hope not anyway and if he did the morang players would be looking at a fair amount of times on sidelines
The grounds in terrible condition. Was average in 2019
Any junior finals on it this week?
3 out of 4 missing on Kilmore
Winner of the round: Going with Old Eltham who will go into their finals series with a win over Kilmore. The 3 games have had margins of 2 x 10 point wins to Kilmore and a 1 point win to the turtles. Can’t wait for 4th edition in the elimination final in 2 weeks time
Loser of the round: Sadly for Lalor their last chance at a win wasn’t to be losing by 24 points to Lalor. They did have something to celebrate though with their reserves getting their first win in 2023.
Let’s hope for the good of the competition both Reservoir and Lalor can have good off seasons, recruit well and be more competitive in 2023.
With Kinglake looking to come back into the division 3 in 2023, if all 9 teams are competitive then that is all we can ask
Winner of the round: Going with Old Eltham who will go into their finals series with a win over Kilmore. The 3 games have had margins of 2 x 10 point wins to Kilmore and a 1 point win to the turtles. Can’t wait for 4th edition in the elimination final in 2 weeks time
Loser of the round: Sadly for Lalor their last chance at a win wasn’t to be losing by 24 points to Lalor. They did have something to celebrate though with their reserves getting their first win in 2023.
Let’s hope for the good of the competition both Reservoir and Lalor can have good off seasons, recruit well and be more competitive in 2023.
With Kinglake looking to come back into the division 3 in 2023, if all 9 teams are competitive then that is all we can ask
Any tribunal news? Were Hall, Thompson and Lazaric summoned?
- Jan 12, 2013
- 1,454
- 1,054
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I not sure but I think both went to the tribunal last night no results published as yet
tasmanlvr
Club Legend
My understanding at the moment is Lazaric received five weeks and Hall got two weeks but obviously when tribunal results come out it will tell the full story
- Oct 3, 2017
- 1,466
- 684
- AFL Club
- Geelong
I heard it was the other way around
tasmanlvr
Club Legend
If it was, that would make plenty more sense. I thought it would be in the ballpark when I saw the vision myself.
