Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Haha! Yeah I know..It's spelt Fadge, but I love the attempt in your avatar to praise the thread starter for pointing out Nick's splendor.
Jesus mate you've gotta drop this
Daicos 2022 = first season in the system
Sheezel 2023 = first year in the system
Daicos 2023 = second year in the system
Sheezel 2024 - second year in the system
They are equivalents.
You are disregarding an entire year of Daicos wizardry because Sheezel was born 9 months later in his draft year.
You come across like some of those sad Dusty followers, who just handpick pieces of nothingness, just to try and strengthen their unwinnable argument.Not sure why you are getting so worked up, what part don't you get about " at the same age"
Sheezel as a first year player, eclipsed goaties first year and he played the whole year as an 18 year old, not 19
Sheezel this year, same age as goaties 2022 (same age) is well in front on most metrics
This isn't opinion, it's fact
4% difference. Crazy stuffNot sure why you are getting so worked up, what part don't you get about " at the same age"
Sheezel as a first year player, eclipsed goaties first year and he played the whole year as an 18 year old, not 19
Sheezel this year, same age as goaties 2022 (same age) is well in front on most metrics
This isn't opinion, it's fact
You come across like some of those sad Dusty followers, who just handpick pieces of nothingness, just to try and strengthen their unwinnable argument.
You will never admit it (and I get that) but deep down inside you know .
When you go to bed (or wherever you lay your head) you know.
And you just say to yourself "damn Nick is that bloody good, that I am struggling to find some BS thing to bring him down with"
And it gets harder each week but you just keep being you because eventually you will just give up and not just look at the jumper he is wearing.
4% difference. Crazy stuff
Yes and you have a remarkable way of using certain "facts" to suit your agenda.You must be cherry picking again, I have stated numerous times that goatie is a great young player, but it seems that unless all neutrals anoint him as the best young player they have seen, Pie supporters just aren't satisfied
I'm not a Tigers supporter pumping up one of my own, unlike you, I'm a neutral and everything I have stated is fact
I am comparing players at the same age, I have never shifted the discussion, so it is apple's for applesYes and you have a remarkable way of using certain "facts" to suit your agenda.
Instead of comparing apples with apples (year 1, year 2, year 3, ect)
You choose to compare apples and oranges because one was a few months older when he started.
So Tim Kelly was the best player in the 2017 draft and competition in 2018, despite being older than those 18 year olds?First year in the system is the first year in the system.
Whether a player was born in a different month mean very little.
The statistics state otherwise, impact? That's a different discussionSheez is a very good young player but there is a fair gap between the two, yo uar ejust to blinded to see it.
Pie supporters start trolling, I'll play, but I think Goatie is a great young talent and there would be other pie players id be happy to have in our sideWhen it comes to Nick, or anything Collingwood, you are far from a neutral.
I couldn't give a stuff how I'm viewed, more than happy to have a reasonable footy debate with anyone, about any player or clubIf you keep clutching at straws this much, you will soon be taken as seriously as other great posters like Kreuze Missile.
He has zero contested marks (career) but does it really matter as a 184cm midfielder built like him?There are more videos online of him shirking it than marking it.
Agree.There are more videos online of him shirking it than marking it.
Do you think Whispers will take that contested mark tonight?The funny thing about those knocking aspects of the game is that you're actually pointing out things that he'll probably get a fair bit better out, when many already consider him the best player in the game. A bit scary for those looking to knock him that he's still well and truly on the way up.
It doesn't matter if you're just judging his general output, but it certainly matters if you're trying to make claims he's the best player to ever lace a boot.He has zero contested marks (career) but does it really matter as a 184cm midfielder built like him?
Still kicks goals, still gets plenty of it
Personally my opinion is until it costs him in a big moment does it really matter? FWIW I don’t think he puts himself in many contested marking situations and nor should he, it’s not his role.
Are we even allowed to call him that??Do you think Whispers will take that contested mark tonight?
Imagine the celebration if he did!
Can’t wait
I personally don’t think he’ll be the GOAT but he is easily a T3 player in the competition two years running now, he’s seriously impressiveIt doesn't matter if you're just judging his general output, but it certainly matters if you're trying to make claims he's the best player to ever lace a boot.
Plenty of players his height have been wonderful marks and have taken telling grabs up forward at crucial times.
The three main tenets of our game are kicks, marks, handballs.
To be exceptionally poor at one of the three doesn't help your claim to be any sort of GOAT, which is the title of the thread.
He calls himself whispers apparently.Are we even allowed to call him that??
I cant keep up with it all regarding what we are allowed to call him. I know the I is banned on his name.
Pies supporters are mighty precious of their body contact avoiding little Nick.
BOG ordinary. Turnovers and stat padding. Oh, and BT reckons that kick back inside couldn’t have been pulled off by anyone other than NickBOG for the Bombers to half time.
That's all well and good, but nothing to do with this ridiculous thread....he is easily a T3 player in the competition two years running now, he’s seriously impressive
Predicting 30 and 2 (+3 votes) tonight for the future GOAT, hardly ever let's you down