Miguel Sanchez
(Unique injury) TBC
Simmo just on Seven. Shuey will be available provided he gets through training in the week. Hurn, Gaff, Yeo and Kennedy less likely.
Prediction Rd 10 changes
- Thread starter BeornJ
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Bender_
X
How many weeks did the Melbourne tackler get?
Bender_
X
I hope he got a reduction for having his remorse rated as high and for his good blokiness being rated as ripper.
Such an inspiration.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,601
- 14,321
- AFL Club
- West Coast
So I guess...
In: Shuey, Hough, Naish
Out: Ryan, Foley, Edwards
In: Shuey, Hough, Naish
Out: Ryan, Foley, Edwards
- Oct 22, 2017
- 4,018
- 5,019
- AFL Club
- West Coast
I just spoke to Simmo. Out is JJ and Waterman for next week and Naish only put in for one quarter, so hes dropped too.
Out: Foley and Ryan
In: Shuey and Hough
Who knows though. Pretty likely there will be injuries we have no idea about.
In: Shuey and Hough
Who knows though. Pretty likely there will be injuries we have no idea about.
Out for the rest of his career with a pulled heartstring.
I think they have an injury spreadsheet they fill in and send to the AFL.
It's limited to 11 lines because no-one ever thought they'd need more, and no-one knows how to unlock extra lines.
So they fill it to 11 injuries, send that to the AFL and all the rest just fall off the system. Like they don't exist.
He's taller than Shep/Hurn/Nelson and will slightly be bigger than him. I have no issue in his size. I liked what I saw in him last season but like you've mentioned, jis biggest issue is his lack of footspeed. I think he'll probably be what we want Rotham to be and be that third tall defender
Duggans knee is cooked too.
- Sep 16, 2006
- 36,401
- 36,528
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Call me crazy but I reckon we might win this game. Certainly a better chance than our last few games. GWS look completely cooked. (but we do too.... 
)
)
Get_The_Gaff
Norm Smith Medallist
- Apr 4, 2021
- 6,043
- 14,205
- AFL Club
- West Coast
We look like needing wafl top ups again this week . We may be a chanceCall me crazy but I reckon we might win this game. Certainly a better chance than our last few games. GWS look completely cooked. (but we do too....
- Nov 18, 2017
- 2,161
- 5,718
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Call me crazy but I reckon we might win this game. Certainly a better chance than our last few games. GWS look completely cooked. (but we do too....
I thought that and then watched them put Adelaide to the absolute sword.
We've historically hated the rain although with Clark and West in the team maybe we're a bit stronger in those conditions.
I think GWS still cover -38.5 as I think they'll be better in the wet, could see Toby having a big day, but not super confident.
Out: Duggan, Ryan, Foley
In: offseason party time, Hurn, Shuey
In: offseason party time, Hurn, Shuey
so I have forked out $100 to watch us blow our percentage. West and Clark will be worth it i guess.Call me crazy but I reckon we might win this game. Certainly a better chance than our last few games. GWS look completely cooked. (but we do too....
Call me crazy but I reckon we might win this game. Certainly a better chance than our last few games. GWS look completely cooked. (but we do too....
Of all of the games prior to the MSD (our games and Norf's games) this one is the only 'danger' game that either team could win.
It's pretty unlikely though, and teams generally have a decent record in their new coach's 1st game? (plus we are rubbish).
I do think we could get within about 5 goals though, which will hopefully start a trend in the right direction.
JKs knees have been cooked for years. Mate of mine is family friends with him and says even getting out of the car is painful for him.
Warrior.
Warrior.
There seems to be a chance that we will need top ups this weekend despite no covid cases?
That is unreal.
That is unreal.
For a normal player that is just a throwaway line, but for Shuey it's a legitimate concern.
- Oct 9, 2009
- 12,601
- 14,321
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Pretty sure top ups could only be called upon if there are players in H&S protocols, not purely through injuries.
I think the AFL has thrown us a bone there. We've called on them in other games when we still had fit players out of the team (due to team balance). The alternative is to not field 22 players and the AFLPA would probably shut the game down due to health and safety risks. It would also put the issue of reduced playing lists in the spotlight, which the AFL doesn't want.
We could also argue that a bunch of soft tissue injuries are as a result of player disruption from COVID.
OUT: Foley (dead), Ryan (moron), Duggan (dead)
IN: Shuey (Ugh), Gaff (Yuck), Hurn <---- The leaders are back errrbody, get ready for some 'intent'.
I'd say there should be no reason whatsoever for 35yr old Shannon Hurn to be playing in a 1-7 side during a full blown rebuild phase, but with Duggan also dead, i'm not sure throwing a Hough type in the mix would be so beneficial, with only really McGovern and Barrass around to support.
Naish comes into the starting 22, Nelson (if he simply HAS to keep getting games) can be the sub.
If not Nelson because of the photo's, Winder can be sub.
IN: Shuey (Ugh), Gaff (Yuck), Hurn <---- The leaders are back errrbody, get ready for some 'intent'.
I'd say there should be no reason whatsoever for 35yr old Shannon Hurn to be playing in a 1-7 side during a full blown rebuild phase, but with Duggan also dead, i'm not sure throwing a Hough type in the mix would be so beneficial, with only really McGovern and Barrass around to support.
Naish comes into the starting 22, Nelson (if he simply HAS to keep getting games) can be the sub.
If not Nelson because of the photo's, Winder can be sub.
- Status
