![](https://images.bigfootymedia.com/icons/mobile-bullets/geelong.png)
- Apr 6, 2010
- 3,330
- 3,902
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Man Utd, AC Milan, Wolfsburg,
Reckon he's a lock to play vs Roos in TasmaniaAny chance Hardie gets a run?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Reckon he's a lock to play vs Roos in TasmaniaAny chance Hardie gets a run?
I'm naming Bews as a roughy this week for AFL selection pulled from Sundays VFL side and not on injury list.Watch this space.
18-15 our way since 2004. Which I imagine is by far our worst record against any opponent over that time.
The move to Tom Stewart on ball should have been made a lot sooner, we could of won a few more games.
But you're then dropping a defender and adding a forward if it's Henry for TuohyGiven the 6 day break and how tuohy has struggled after a few games in a row so i would imagine he is sub or 'managed'.
But you're then dropping a defender and adding a forward if it's Henry for Tuohy
You would drop Neale after he had a game in which he scored 2.2 and could easily have had 3-5 goals? talk about harshWe are but unless they drop clark and dont recall knevitt its the most likely outcome (im assuming neale will stay for structure though i wouldnt personally)
I wonder what the Win/Loss record is Geel v Coll say for the last 20 years , i reckon it would be very tight 50/50 games split with some real hammerings handed out both ways
Thats why form , or if one side has got quite a few injuries , you dont get over confident , or you can end up dissappointed
No bulldust about 5 years ago at a guess , Buckley was still coaching them , we were warm favourites , and my power went out all day Sat , its like a 3rd world country without electricity , your just waiting for it to come back on , finally came back on that evening , and the woman giving the sports wrap said in an upset Coll have beaten Geel at the MCG ( got jumped in the 1st half ) and i thought can this day get any worse
Yes recently we have thank goodness , over the journey re finals re Coll , again i reckon it would be tight , they may just shade us
Flags are the name of the game and thus no Cats supporter is dissappointed re the last 16-17 years etc
However you mention finals , i think the only 2 clubs ( barring the new ones ) that Geel has got a positive Win/Loss record in finals against , are those 2 utter Powerhouse clubs called Footscray ( certain of ) and StKilda , and im not 100% certain on the Saints one , thats a definitely positively maybe one
I don't understand anyone wanting to drop Neale for Henry at all. Neale drops a few marks though he's getting better at that quickly, but he presents as a key. If you play Henry as a key he will be too easily outmarked and so you allow their 2nd kpd to play a bit of roaming interceptor.We are but unless they drop clark and dont recall knevitt its the most likely outcome (im assuming neale will stay for structure though i wouldnt personally)
You would drop Neale after he had a game in which he scored 2.2 and could easily have had 3-5 goals? talk about harsh
Will not be shocked if scott does a scott thing and dumps mannagh or puts rohan back to the sub role.
Post hoc justification will then flood this thread afterwards.
Meat tray
In Knevitt out Clark (if Knevitt is over his sickness)
Hmm i know Scott has flagged Henry back in but which forward to we drop , make sub for him?
I wouldn't be dropping Close, Miers, Stengle, Mannagh for him as they are different types.
Rohan has been playing to well which is the most like for like so no unless Rohan needs a rest or we are rotating them through the sub.
Neale is someone we need to get to 50 games asap to see if he can be a good long term key forward and he has been playing well not to mention he plays a role Henry isn't suited for.
Only other options for Henry to come in are for mids hell no or defenders hell no
I like our win loss ratio against the pies in finals since 2007.You are spot on. If we take it from 'Year 1' as I often reference my Geelong supporting experience (1984-when Gary Sr joined the club), there's been 63 clashes, of which Geelong have won 32, the Pies 31.
If we take it from our glory era from 2007 onwards, the Pies are the side we've had the least success against in this period, with a record of only 17-13 Geelong's way since then, when our record against all other sides has been much better than that. That's what I was saying in my previous post, the two sides just don't really win too many in a row against each other, no matter how good or bad they might be. We've lost the last two, it's our turn this weekend!
Personally i would be yes it would be a hard call.
Rest him against the dogs or north. We must win tomorrow to set up a top four spot and have a reasonable shot at a flag. Rohan has a good record against the pies and is becoming the most important player on our foward line.Mannagh won't be getting omitted
Rohan to sub as a management option is a possiblity though
He's not doing his chances any harm by playing the way he did on the weekend. His time will come.
O. Henry is just a lead and mark forward who offers absolutely nothing on transition footy between the arcs.
He seems more obsessed with running back to goal to get a shot.
Neales stats stand up pretty good against Henry’s this year.I don't understand anyone wanting to drop Neale for Henry at all. Neale drops a few marks though he's getting better at that quickly, but he presents as a key. If you play Henry as a key he will be too easily outmarked and so you allow their 2nd kpd to play a bit of roaming interceptor.
Just doesn't make any sense to me
We seem to be able to evolve within season by addressing our weaknesses and improving our game - one of the reasons Scott is lauded so much.Maybe, but there's also a silver lining that there's only one likely finalist that we'll face in the run from here.
Most finalists won't have seen their structure up against this new system and with their own battles to fight from here they'd be unlikely to have sunk enough time into their analysis to do anything but back their structure.
Absolutely.Any chance Hardie gets a run?
LOL. Is it?? Is that all his job is??Cos that’s his job!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk