Review Round 11, 2024 vs North Melbourne

[Doctor Feel]

Great content this

 

[edgie]

Taylor Walker and Charlie Curnow do not like this.

Taylor Walker and Charlie Curnow can do it against other teams too

 

[Duckimus Prime]

Trouble is when they put Dixon back in the team it hinders his progression.

I felt like we were playing two different game plans yesterday.

When we get the ball moving and lift our eyes how simple does it look to hit Todd lace out on a strong lead, for the most part though we still bomb it in rather than being a little more patient. This all revolves around the Dixon mentality. Even when we are 70m out we still bomb it in most of the time. They seem happy that a million entries will eventuate into goals as opposed to efficiency.

Its already been shown multiple times that Marshall performs better when Charlie is in the side.

And thats even with Marshall kicking bags against non-existant defences when Charlie is out.

Do we have to post the 2022 season results again where Marshall was considerably more consistent in the second half of the year after Charlie's return?

 

[PowerBaz]

Its already been shown multiple times that Marshall performs better when Charlie is in the side.

And thats even with Marshall kicking bags against non-existant defences when Charlie is out.

Do we have to post the 2022 season results again where Marshall was considerably more consistent in the second half of the year after Charlie's return?

The whole bomb it in game-plan doesn’t work for Marshall, it exists for Dixon. I’d rather see more of what I saw yesterday.

 

[philreich]

As sprinkles is clearly not doing gameday coaching anymore my worry is how different is Carr going to be.

I'm anxious to find out ASAP!!!

 

[jackag24]

lol Didn't Butters murder some North spud years ago when the North spud lined him up when Butters was still like, 48 kilos?

Yeah i remember that game, think he took out about 3 north players, including a tackle on goldstein when he was running at full pace

 

[Doctor Feel]

lol Didn't Butters murder some North spud years ago when the North spud lined him up when Butters was still like, 48 kilos?

Ziebell tried to kill him and he laughed at him

 

[Enviable Tradition]

I thought he was excellent against the Kangaroos with outstanding pressure and a couple of goals that could've been more.

The Perminator is quietly having a very good second year as a medium forward. Very good.

Imagine the melts if he sneaks in for an AA spot haha.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[GoPorts]

Ziebell tried to kill him and he laughed at him

Butters grins after being crunched by rampaging Roo

Port Adelaide jet Zak Butters wasn't fazed about being smashed by North captain Jack Ziebell

www.afl.com.au

 

[Schulzenfest]

lol Didn't Butters murder some North spud years ago when the North spud lined him up when Butters was still like, 48 kilos?

Ziebell. So not just 'some North spud', their captain. Still a spud of course, but chief spud.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Butters grins after being crunched by rampaging Roo

Port Adelaide jet Zak Butters wasn't fazed about being smashed by North captain Jack Ziebell

www.afl.com.au

Ziebel hurt his shoulder as well

 

[Powerage]

You’re using stats when Dixon didn’t play for port. His best for port against the Roos is 2 goals. He does not average 1.8 goals against the kangaroos for port.

Why shouldn't I use Dixon's career stats? Stupid not to because this provides a complete picture of Dixon's success against North. I'm also using Marshall's career stats. What are you - the post police?

 

[Powerage]

The whole bomb it in game-plan doesn’t work for Marshall, it exists for Dixon. I’d rather see more of what I saw yesterday.

Then we would have to keep playing North. Because against most other teams Todd wouldn't be allowed to lead without an opponent in shot.

I'm all for a gameplan where balls inside 50 are delivered to the advantage of the best option. Its the logical way of kicking the highest score which, you know, wins you the game. But what we saw yesterday with North's barely existent defence can't be taken as what we often encounter when playing other sides.

 

[edgie]

Ziebell. So not just 'some North spud', their captain. Still a spud of course, but chief spud.

I also have recollection of Alipate Carlile putting someone from norf in to a different state of consciousness?

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

 

[Marmozet]

I also have recollection of Alipate Carlile putting someone from norf in to a different state of consciousness?

Sent from my Nokia 7.2 using Tapatalk

0:57

 

[Phar Ted]

For some reason we don't hear about shinboner spirit anymore!

 

[GremioPower]

It's a tough competition and somebody has to fall asleep in front of the telly

It’s usually me.

 

[philreich]

For some reason we don't hear about shinboner spirit anymore!

The only spirits Norf fans have these days is the ones they drink, to drown their sorrows after another loss .

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

There was an article in Code Sport during the week.

Burgoyne was told his body language makes him look disinterested. It was never an attitude or effort thing, just how it looked externally.

Wonder what they told Burton

 

[philthy05]

Why shouldn't I use Dixon's career stats? Stupid not to because this provides a complete picture of Dixon's success against North. I'm also using Marshall's career stats. What are you - the post police?

because they were at another club, over a decade ago.

The only reason too include them is to try to distort his career versus north at port, which as the stats I posted were surprisingly bad.

The fact Dixon has kicked (what was it 7 total goals from memory?) against north in a port jumper is quite bizarre.

 

[Mutha F]

So Todd kicks 5 straight (and does not even look like missing) when we are playing the bottom team with no chance of losing. Anyone think he makes those shots in a close game, or any game against a top 4 team for that matter? Until we can get rid of the fragile mindset that Ken has cultivated we will always be FTB's. It is going to take years even after the clunt is gone

 

[Sunshine81]

because they were at another club, over a decade ago.

The only reason too include them is to try to distort his career versus north at port, which as the stats I posted were surprisingly bad.

The fact Dixon has kicked (what was it 7 total goals from memory?) against north in a port jumper is quite bizarre.

You're just cherry picking stats to boost your argument.

Marshall was averaging a goal a game against North until he kicked a bag of 5 against the bottom team which is still to restrict it's opposition to under 100 points.

Since 2020, when North have finished in the bottom 2 each year, Dixon has played a whopping 2 games against them.

 

[Powerage]

because they were at another club, over a decade ago.

The only reason too include them is to try to distort his career versus north at port, which as the stats I posted were surprisingly bad.

The fact Dixon has kicked (what was it 7 total goals from memory?) against north in a port jumper is quite bizarre.

But...but...but...because. So you do think you are the post police. Who is really trying to distort Dixon's career?

It was less than a decade ago that Dixon kicked 7.

You cherry picked your stats to make Dixon look bad and it backfired on you badly. Deal with it Constable philthy05.

 

[x_les_x]

If you guys want to keep shit fighting over useless marshall/dixon stats against north just remember this round J McEntee amassed a career high 17 disposals in this match, 4 more than his prior high. Those are some useless stats for you. Any stats against north are null

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

I don't think the forward line is better without Dixon but it was nice not to see him out there conceding frustration free kicks