Round 12 Trades

[PAFCsince1870]

If Chad goes under the knife I'm starting to think;

Chad->Mcleod
Power->Ablett jnr

Purely as a defensive move in upcoming eliminator matches, and also thinking ahead to Power playing Sydney in rd 22 (as well as him being fairly ordinary compared to elite DT mids).

 

[Deenamite]

Is it too risky to have Armfield starting if i downgrade Wona to him?

 

[KouDogg]

Thnaks for your help... I'll do an ibbo to p burg or birchall if bug boy breaks his leg before friday when i do the trade...

No worries, glad i can help.

 

[richmond fanatic]

My teams completed imo with 5 trades left and im ranked somewhere around 2,400. What I want to know is whether I'm any chance to go top 500, even top 100 or is it too late?

BACKS

Shaw
P.Burgoyne
Milburn
S.Fisher
Goddard
Mcleod
Bowden

Myers
Thompson

CENTRES

Chapman
Cooney
Priddis
Dal Santo
Stevens
Jones

Nicoski
Cotchin

RUCKS

Cox
Simmonds

West
Hampson

FORWARDS

Didak
Reiwoldt
J.Brown
Pavlich
O'Keefe
Porplyzia
Richardson

Neagle
Valenti


Thoughts???? I'm really happy with my depth as well and I got some unique selections in Bowden, Cooney, Richo and O'Keefe.

 

[lmaohelp]

ey i have 12 trades left an only a few players to go to complete side

players that are iffy but still performing besides fev are -


fev, gram, palmer, griffen, simmonds(sorta wana keep)

who would u upgrade 1st ? and how many trades would i want for finals ?

rookies are

tippet, bird, kruezer, pfiefer,

thanks
daniel

 

[MarkJohnson#1]

ey i have 12 trades left an only a few players to go to complete side

players that are iffy but still performing besides fev are -


fev, gram, palmer, griffen, simmonds(sorta wana keep)

who would u upgrade 1st ? and how many trades would i want for finals ?

rookies are

tippet, bird, kruezer, pfiefer,

thanks
daniel

Fev
Griffen
Gram
Palmer
Simmonds (assuming you already have Cox)

In that order IMO.

 

[nooB]

Need some help guys - with 6 trades and $150, 200 in the bank, I'm wondering which key forward to bring in for Rioli in say 3 weeks.

Robert Murphy? Steve Johnson? Chapman? Or is there another deficiency that i should be focusing on? Backline has a fair amount of under performing players so yeah.



What should i do?

 

[Captain Kirk Army]

Need some help guys - with 6 trades and $150, 200 in the bank, I'm wondering which key forward to bring in for Rioli in say 3 weeks.

Robert Murphy? Steve Johnson? Chapman? Or is there another deficiency that i should be focusing on? Backline has a fair amount of under performing players so yeah.



What should i do?

my advice, dig yourself a whole and start again

 

[Captain Kirk Army]

like many dreamteamers, im faced with the prospect of having to trade chad cornes. my options are: bock, macdonald, newman, mcmahon, johncock. burgoyne, and birchell. im tending to favour newman/bock.... thoughts???

 

[kangaroo19]

like many dreamteamers, im faced with the prospect of having to trade chad cornes. my options are: bock, macdonald, newman, mcmahon, johncock. burgoyne, and birchell. im tending to favour newman/bock.... thoughts???

I might (but hopefully won't be) be in a situation where I will be trading Chad out, as SDT is my only backline emergency at the moment that is playing. If it is 4+ weeks, I think I will bite the bullet as I'm going for overall win or eliminator rather than league.

I'll be looking at Newman or Fisher...

 

[kangaroo19]

If Chad is okay and doesn't need trading, I have the following options to try and finalise my team. with $130k in the bank and 6 trades left. I can afford to do these ones this week only in these combinations

Simmonds --> Sandilands
Ibbotson --> Bock

Doesn't seem worth it... or

Porplyzia --> Franklin/NBrown/Gia (already have BJ)
Palmer --> Corey

or...

Ibbotson --> Newman (maybe Fisher)
Palmer --> Corey

Ibbotson, Palmer, Simmonds and Porplyzia are the weakest players in each position and will look to upgrade at least 2 either this week or next to finish off my team. Thoughts?

 

[lmaohelp]

hey i have tippet, bird, kruezer, pfiefer,

which should i downgrade for $$

 

[FFC_]

this week i'm gonna be doing:

morton --> armfield
and
wonae --> milburn/wheatley/newman

 

[matt73]

hey i have tippet, bird, kruezer, pfiefer,

which should i downgrade for $$

Downgrade Bird to Armfield. Tippett and Kreuzer should play the majority of games this year and would be good backup for injuries. Bird may struggle to get back in.

 

[FFC_]

hey i have tippet, bird, kruezer, pfiefer,

which should i downgrade for $$

i downgraded bird last round. I'd say kreuzer still has some growing to do, same with tippett (they are both 170-190k yes?)

Bird is injured, so can't increase in value, therefore i reckon he is the one.

Pfeiffer i don't know though, sorry

 

[cardiff_city]

 

[Ferg720]

Assuming i don't need to trade cornes out, i can get any midfielder this week by downgrading Wonamearri and upgrading Ibbotson;

Current midfield is: Ablett, Black, Johnstone, Pendlebury Palmer and Ibbotson

Basically who should i get: Bartel, Corey or Kornes?

Edit: Or Dane Swan

 

[Cruiser23]

Downgrade Bird to Armfield. Tippett and Kreuzer should play the majority of games this year and would be good backup for injuries. Bird may struggle to get back in.

Yep, i second that. No good downgrade options in the forward or ruck area. Pfeiffer is much more likely to get a game than Bird, Bird to Armfield is the go IMO.

 

[Gabbatoir]

My advice: get on Bryce Gibbs, I just traded him out for Daniel Kerr, expect him to average in the mid 130's for the rest of the season

 

[lmaohelp]

ey jus lookin at upgrading fev

thinkn either the following ...


steve johnson, robert murphy, brad johnson,

or neone under 400

thanks

 

[Outburst]

proud>armfield
bradshaw>barry hall

 

[The Special 1]

Is it time to downgrade Armitage?

Armfield looks like a tasty replacement

The 120k gained can be used to upgrade Kosi to Cox in a few weeks...

 

[swansational05]

Need some help guys - with 6 trades and $150, 200 in the bank, I'm wondering which key forward to bring in for Rioli in say 3 weeks.

Robert Murphy? Steve Johnson? Chapman? Or is there another deficiency that i should be focusing on? Backline has a fair amount of under performing players so yeah.



What should i do?

This is MY opinion, so if i was you, id work on the defence, considering you have 150K in bank mabey you could think about trading out Osborne or McLeod.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

This is MY opinion, so if i was you, id work on the defence, considering you have 150K in bank mabey you could think about trading out Osborne or McLeod.

No way

If you trade them to a higher scoring back you might be 10 - 15ppg better off

If you trade rioli to Chapman you will be 30ppg better off

Simple

This year Osborne and McLeoud are pretty much premium backs

EDIT: Just looked at your rucks. Bring in COX!!!

 

[FFC_]

This year Osborne and McLeoud are pretty much premium backs

huh? is that the same mcleod who is averaging 68 and has gone down in value by 133k???