Prediction Round 13, 2024: Changes vs North Melbourne

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Kelly ruled out this week, which basically means Culley has to come in.

You underestimate the pull a centre square of Sheed, Gaff and Yeo would have to Simmo.

YoU CaNt gO toO fAr the OthEr waY. :drunk::drunk:
 
It's the expectation after beating Freo and Melbourne that St Kilda and Norf would be winnable.

Reckon this feeling is worse than feeling nothing at all across 2022-23.
Yeah we are like the 2000 Eagles now, can produce some good footy in patches but can also still get smashed quite easily.

expectations have risen

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

Log in to remove this ad.

I know they are going to persist with it but BBW for me is the odd man out. He's not good enough to play as a forward over Williams and JWill is more than a serviceable backup ruck like he's been playing.

If Flynn stays fit I can see BBW being forced out due to team balance.
BBW was great on the weekend? He is clearly ahead of JWilliams right now.
 
Yeah we are like the 2000 Eagles now, can produce some good footy in patches but can also still get smashed quite easily.

expectations have risen

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app

We're still years away from being able to finalise the list with specific positional needs too. Still need elite mids. In 2000 we had Cousins, Kerr, Fletcher, Embley and Braun (AAs, Brownlow, Norm Smith, Rosco Medals) and were a year away from Judd. We only have Harley who copped two fines and a two week suspension the first time he had to deal with a tag :(
 
We're still years away from being able to finalise the list with specific positional needs too. Still need elite mids. In 2000 we had Cousins, Kerr, Fletcher, Embley and Braun (AAs, Brownlow, Norm Smith, Rosco Medals) and were a year away from Judd. We only have Harley who copped two fines and a two week suspension the first time he had to deal with a tag :(
Yeah as of mid 2000 only Cuzz was a known player at that point.

We could be the same, In 5-6 years, flag

On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
It's the expectation after beating Freo and Melbourne that St Kilda and Norf would be winnable.

Reckon this feeling is worse than feeling nothing at all across 2022-23.
Definetly not a worse feeling, but losing to a pleb team in the saints feels like 2 steps forward 1 step back.

If we lose to Norf, even with our outs..i will have no words
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Definetly not a worse feeling, but losing to a pleb team in the saints feels like 2 steps forward 1 step back.

If we lose to Norf, even with our outs..i will have no words
Our wafl midfields (gaff, Sheed and Culley) had trouble beating lowly wafl sides so don't hold your hopes up high.

Our beagles got flogged by peel thunder. Good luck against Fremantle a team
 
Last edited:
Feels like he's next in line, was mentioned in emergencies last week, if TK's out again -maybe? See what emerges from the Bermuda Triangle of MC...

Culley is getting very close.

The plan for his comback maybe was to build in the WAFL until mid season and consider him post bye.

Well technically this is mid season and at Optus v North may be a good option.

We need to drop a tall if he comes in though. We are starting to lack leg speed and pressure.
 
Definetly not a worse feeling, but losing to a pleb team in the saints feels like 2 steps forward 1 step back.

If we lose to Norf, even with our outs..i will have no words
If we have no Kelly, Yeo, Reid, Allen and Warerman then there's a good chance we do lose. Our depth is young guys who are still developing or old guys over the hill. It is a reality of a rebuilding team, we just have to suck it up. The wheel has already started to turn, a few more pre seasons into the young guys and we'll be back.
 
It's the expectation after beating Freo and Melbourne that St Kilda and Norf would be winnable.

Reckon this feeling is worse than feeling nothing at all across 2022-23.

Anyone who says this is worse than 2022-23 has quickly forgotten how bad the last 2 years were.

More than a few around here were just about ready to pack it in 9 months ago.
 
I know they are going to persist with it but BBW for me is the odd man out. He's not good enough to play as a forward over Williams and JWill is more than a serviceable backup ruck like he's been playing.

If Flynn stays fit I can see BBW being forced out due to team balance.
I dunno why people are writing off BW so quickly as a forward, he has barely even played there yet. Give him at least a couple of months to see if he adapts to a more forward role.
Hes got a great leap, hes relatively agile for a big man and can compete/crash a pack. Accuracy at goal is not unfixable, and sticky hands will come with confidence.
Contested marking vs other rucks who are bigger than him was always an issue, but vs a 2nd or 3rd defender he should have a much better shot
 
Culley is getting very close.

The plan for his comback maybe was to build in the WAFL until mid season and consider him post bye.

Well technically this is mid season and at Optus v North may be a good option.

We need to drop a tall if he comes in though. We are starting to lack leg speed and pressure.
Could swap Hutch for JWil, still a marking target but provides some run/pressure. Hes an awkward matchup too, would be an issue for them, especially with Norths backline not being so strong
 
Metro has snuck under the radar a bit this
If we have no Kelly, Yeo, Reid, Allen and Warerman then there's a good chance we do lose. Our depth is young guys who are still developing or old guys over the hill. It is a reality of a rebuilding team, we just have to suck it up. The wheel has already started to turn, a few more pre seasons into the young guys and we'll be back.
Why the speculation around Yeo not being available?
 
Jai Ho India GIF by Anupam Kher
 
This will be a tough game I think - could very easily lose it if they show up desperate to snag a win (as they should!).

Pressure might ramp up on the club again should we drop it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top