Round 13 Trades

[PAFC1996]

Smith and Davis > Trengrove and Hanners
Give me 18 provided Tucker/Collins/Hopper/etc aren't dropped.
Also helps even out my bye rounds somewhat, and leaves me with 14 trades and $188k.

 

[cdcanman]

A lot will depend on team selection this week for me.
Hopper (form), Hewett and Goldstein in some doubt I would think. If all play, and there are no other surprise outs, I would have 17 available.
In this event, I will likely go with:
1) Smith -> Selwood (Rd 15 bye suits me).
or
2) Hopper/Hewett (based on selection, Hewett if both picked) -> Trengove
Smith -> Selwood
or
3) Hopper/Hewett (based on selection, Hewett if both picked) -> Trengove
Smith -> Selwood
Parker -> Ward

I am favouring option 3 at present. Would leave me with only 10 trades left, and approx. 100k in the bank. Only 1 defender, 1 midfielder (+Libba?) and 1 forward left to upgrade.

Questions I have:
Is it time for Parker to go, or not?
I am leaning towards moving Parker, he looks proppy, not covering the ground at all well and having little impact.

Selwood vs Ward vs Rockliff????
I currently have them in that order. Too many ? on Rocky for mine. I lean towards Selwood's ability to go large over Ward's consistently good output.


Happy for anyone to pick apart my logic here

 

[cdcanman]

Is it too risky to trade in Jelwood if I already have Danger? I'm worried they may take points from one another?

Hasn't seemed to bother them too much so far. Both averaging pretty well.
Can't see why that would change all of sudden just because you have both in your side

 

[cdcanman]

Stewart so tempting.

I wouldn't trust it. You may get one or two good price rises, but is that enough to warrant a trade? His JS is still shaky at best

 

[cdcanman]

Okay guys, Am thinking
Gresham to J.Trengrove
Davis to Jansen
Kerridge to Zorko

Ideally id like to wait a couple weeks with Davis BE at 30, Kerridges at 50 and Zorko at 150 although im playing the league leader this week, im 4 points away from top spot & these trades will give me 19 playing, otherwise i have 17.
Also it leaves me with 170k to trade DBJ to Rance next week leaving me with 12 trades after that one. Thoughts ?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Looking at the bigger picture of what you are doing, your trades seem to be well thought through and make sense.
Are you being mindful of bye availability beyond this week? If so, then good trades

Do you have bigger priorities than Kerridge? He is filling a hole quite nicely at present. I'm happy holding him until I absolutely must trade him.

 

[leng jai]

Some big(ish) premium break evens:

Dollhouse: 189
Zorko: 151
Buddy: 156
McVeigh: 119
Parker: 125
Neale: 169
Montagna: 123
Deledio: 120
Hall: 140
Motlop: 113
Hannebry: 153
Sidebottom: 147
Treloar: 168

So many tasty options, I'm eyeing off Zorko, Deledio and possibly Motlop later for F7.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Kade Stewart will hurt a lot of people I reckon. I just don't trust Clarkson.

Agreed.
Pity b/e of -90 ish if he got a good run of games.
Hello cash.

 

[Hairy Lager]

Is it too risky to trade in Jelwood if I already have Danger? I'm worried they may take points from one another?

Get these 2 into your side its a lot of fun watching these guys rack up the points each week. SC studs

 

[leng jai]

Get these 2 into your side its a lot of fun watching these guys rack up the points each week. SC studs

How are people still asking if it's bad having both Selwood and Dangerfield? Their averages this year are plain to see for everyone.

 

[The Lemon]

Is it too risky to trade in Jelwood if I already have Danger? I'm worried they may take points from one another?

I started with Danger, Selwood, Bartel.

I am going ok.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Out - smith and gov.
In - Trengove and sallywood.

If matho is picked I might change to him.

If peeps were holding trades there are a lot of bargains around.

 

[Gigantic]

Smith and Davis > Trengrove and Hanners
Give me 18 provided Tucker/Collins/Hopper/etc aren't dropped.
Also helps even out my bye rounds somewhat, and leaves me with 14 trades and $188k.

A lot will depend on team selection this week for me.
Hopper (form), Hewett and Goldstein in some doubt I would think. If all play, and there are no other surprise outs, I would have 17 available.

It will be highly unlikely Hopper gets dropped. The coach has already stated his intention to rest Stevie J this week and since we're coming up against Essendon we could be resting a few others as well.

 

[PAFC1996]

It will be highly unlikely Hopper gets dropped. The coach has already stated his intention to rest Stevie J this week and since we're coming up against Essendon we could be resting a few others as well.

That's good news, cheers mate.

 

[alfyyy3]

Looking at the bigger picture of what you are doing, your trades seem to be well thought through and make sense.
Are you being mindful of bye availability beyond this week? If so, then good trades

Do you have bigger priorities than Kerridge? He is filling a hole quite nicely at present. I'm happy holding him until I absolutely must trade him.

I am mindful of that, including the Rance trade next week .. it leaves me with 19 playing this week, 18 next week and 20 playing the week after.

Dont really want to trade out Kerridge as i still think he has another 30k to make at the very least and Zorko will prob drop another 20k after this week .. although only having 16 playing this week kind of forces my hand a little ..

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

[Hairy Lager]

At this early stage, due to Dahlhaus being
out probably go Davis to Trengove.

That will get 18 on the park this week.

 

[HawkAussie]

I have no idea on what I am going to do this week. Especially when Natianui and Tippett is now out of the lineup.

 

[DraftPunk]

Pies fans how did you rate Phillips? What's his Js like? toxic Kadog Cheers

 

[Faz 2000]

Is it too risky to trade in Jelwood if I already have Danger? I'm worried they may take points from one another?

So far for me they're averaging 599 points per week together.

Admittedly this is not from a large sample size, but I think it's working OK.

 

[Edmund hunt]

Should i trade in Dahlhaus?
If not who is the best midfielder under 480k?

 

[toxic]

Pies fans how did you rate Phillips? What's his Js like? toxic Kadog Cheers

we have no job security

from yesterday blokes who shouldnt get a game at VFL level (not even close to AFL)

Witts
Frost
Crocker
Sinclair
Cox
Blair

I'd expect some more games for Phillips - he got better as the game wore on after looking like a dear in the headlights early on.

From our VFL to come in:
Cloke
Aish
Brown
Goldsack

happy to play 2 short and make the bastards work ffs

 

[toxic]

Should i trade in Dahlhaus?
If not who is the best midfielder under 480k?

yes get dollhouse - he's only out injured for 4-6 weeks

now seems like perfect timing

 

[Edmund hunt]

yes get dollhouse - he's only out injured for 4-6 weeks

now seems like perfect timing

I though it was just concussion?

 

[Judd_Magic]

I though it was just concussion?

Jeffery 2.0

 

[rocker_oz33]

I though it was just concussion?

I wish.

 

[Mitchell54]

Can we use players with a bye as Captain loophole players?