Preview Round 18, 2024 : Hawks v Dockers, 1:45pm Sat 13th July, UTAS

[FB19]

Hopefully dear for Lewis and either Sicily or Serong for seamus. Morrison starts deserves a full game after being beat at BHH for a while and doing well enough as sub. Chad is a fair way of it needs more fitness and performance to warrant it. One of Breust or Gunston has to be sub simply can’t carry both on field.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

If Ginni doesn't get up I would start Morrison on the ground and Breust as sub swapping them around.

Morrison great discipline and good forward 50 entry skills. Can play the ginni role (obvs not as well).
And then when the game has opened up a bit Breust's smarts can get us a goal or two.

 

[twentythree]

Out: Mitchell, Lewis inj, Gunston and Bruest managed.

In: Dear, Serong, Maginness, Ward

Yep play the youf

 

[Sixpence]

Dewyyyyy this is your post you did say Seamus. Then tl92 replied and it said scrimshaw with scrimshaw in the back pocket?
View attachment 2043749

He edited it. Said Scrimshaw initially, but had meant to say Seamus.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

Dewyyyyy this is your post you did say Seamus. Then tl92 replied and it said scrimshaw with scrimshaw in the back pocket?
View attachment 2043749

It was edited after I realised I made a brain fade (naming Scrimshaw but listing him as an out instead of Seamus).

 

[Ballsontheline]

Hardwick Frost Scrimshaw
Weddle Sicily Impey

Mackenzie Day D'Ambrosio
Meek Worpel Newcombe

Moore Dear Macdonald
Gunston Chol Watson

Int: Amon, Jiath, Morrison, Nash,
Sub: Breust

Ginni will miss another week I'm hearing

 

[Pinoy Hawk]

Ginni will miss another week I'm hearing

No Ginni at training this morning.
Sic trained with the main group.

 

[FB19]

It was edited after I realised I made a brain fade (naming Scrimshaw but listing him as an out instead of Seamus).

Thanks that was doing my head in!

 

[MatteeG]

Hopeful ins- Sic, Dear, Finn, Mongrel, clean hands
Outs- Lewis, Seamus, 1 of Breust/Gunner, Lacklustre intent early, fumbling hands

I too would like to see Finn in to take the Ginni up and back forward role.

 

[JRH]

Out: Gunner, Breust, Lewis, Seamus, Morrison
In: Ramsden, Finn, Dear, Serong, Ward.

A lot of change but we got it wrong playing 2 vets. If we took those two out we would have a change for injury, Lewis, and a no show, Seamus. I thought the vets would have stood up stronger against the old enemy. Get punky and gunner to spend some time with Scaife at BH. Rama, Finn and Dima swing around depending. Ward as sub for no reason other than he needs a run, love you Harry.

 

[MuzzHawk]

Changes
Out / In
Lewis / Dear if fit, otherwise Scaife
Breust / Ginnivan if fit, otherwise Wingard
Mitchell / Sicily if fit, otherwise Serong

Would contemplate Maginess in for Morrison if Ginni doesn’t get up, with Wingard as the sub.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[reubski23]

Last week showed us a couple of things about overall inexperience and lack of depth

At our best we are good enough to make the 8 and maybe win a final.

At our worst we’ll look uncompetitive for good periods of the game.

Said it a number of weeks ago cannot start Gunston and Bruest together anymore sadly

Sicily obviously a huge out - he has been the second biggest reason behind our good form of late after a tough start to the season

Ginni’s X factor was def missing.

I hope we can turn it around this week against Freo and fight for the 8th spot!

 

[Simon Crawshay]

Last week showed us a couple of things about overall inexperience and lack of depth

At our best we are good enough to make the 8 and maybe win a final.

At our worst we’ll look uncompetitive for good periods of the game.

Said it a number of weeks ago cannot start Gunston and Bruest together anymore sadly

Sicily obviously a huge out - he has been the second biggest reason behind our good form of late after a tough start to the season

Ginni’s X factor was def missing.

I hope we can turn it around this week against Freo and fight for the 8th spot!

Really it was a pretty poor decision playing both Gunston and Bruest last week. Maybe against certain teams at the MCG on a fast deck you could get away with it but we all knew it was going to be a tough hard slog against the Cats at Kardinia Park on a cold winters night and we were essentially playing two men down with them starting.

We really, really need Sic to be okay for this game against Freo as alongside Max Gawn and Marcus Bontempelli I doubt there is another player in the AFL as important to their sides fortunes as James Sicily is for the Hawks.

 

[Roger Rogerson]

Out: Gunner, Breust, Lewis, Seamus, Morrison
In: Ramsden, Finn, Dear, Serong, Ward.

A lot of change but we got it wrong playing 2 vets. If we took those two out we would have a change for injury, Lewis, and a no show, Seamus. I thought the vets would have stood up stronger against the old enemy. Get punky and gunner to spend some time with Scaife at BH. Rama, Finn and Dima swing around depending. Ward as sub for no reason other than he needs a run, love you Harry.

I think we need to see how Gunners and Breust perform in a side where the midfield isn’t being destroyed before we lock in the theory they shouldn’t be in the same side.

 

[Sturty]

Hulking Scaife - Come on down

 

[Manila_Hawk]

Scaifey looks like Big Bad Barry,
plays like Big Bad Barry...
... let's just hope he doesn't take up boxing.

 

[Roddy]

So the forward line is looking like: Chol, Scaife, Dear, Moore, Breust and maybe Dimma?

 

[TheFourPillars]

No Scaife

 

[kenneje]

 

[RoughysMullet]

The Chol-Dear-Gunston forward line was working so think we’d just go with that

Think Bruest sub but geez wouldn’t be shocked if they drop him completely- was barely going last week…

 

[Baz_hawk]

Geez rollercoaster for Scaife today if he was in fact in line for selection.

 

[Jane Doe]

What happend to Scaife?

 

[Newmo89]

Copped a knock early into training. Went over the to the tent to get it looked at and then headed down the race. Appears to be chest area that he copped the knock.

 

[Jane Doe]

Copped a knock early into training. Went over the to the tent to get it looked at and then headed down the race. Appears to be chest area that he copped the knock.

Hopefully nothing serious

 

[lyger]

Great to hear Sic is expected to return.

Dear for Lewis and Sic for Seamus?