Round 3 Trades

[Riviat]

What do people think of this trade?

Lambert/Doghouse and Brayshaw
To
Boner and Cogs

Bonner will net me more cash quicker than brayshaw and possibly similar scoring to lambert/dahl and the Brayshaw to cogs trade is an insta upgrade. I've been salivating over Cogs for awhile.

Also means I'm one off of completing my mids as I see cogs as a keeper. Will mean I miss out on getting one of danger or PiggyOliver.

 

[joop]

So what you're saying eastfreo75 is that no 2 people in the world should share the same surname!? I'm thinking joop means Lachlan, not Darcy.

you are correct my man.

 

[Marlowe]

Can CARL supporters tell me why this would be the case ? ...... Judd_Magic ?

He's trying to keep Kade's ownership down a bit.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Waterman would a really good option if JJK was out longer.l think his due back rd 5 Here2tellyouwhy when's JK back please?
Barry not a great scorer but JS should be ok in the winning port team.

JK back round 5 or 6.
Will start his Coleman run then

 

[dees 4 life]

Thoughts on trading Zorko to Cog and banking the $150odd k.
Zorko looks like he is coping the tag now and scoring will be up and down.

Allready have $70k in the bank with no other pressing issues to take care off

 

[ormond-allen]

Laird, Savage, Sicily, Murray, Finlayson, Doedee, Mihocek, Murphy

Dusty, Titch, Fyfe, Cripps, Coniglio, Beams, TKelly, Holman, Banfield, Barry, Constable

Gawn, NicNat, Olango

Greene, Billings, Mundy, Lambert, Devon, Fritsch, Ryan, ZGL

I'm split on holding another week, or turning Beams and Sicily into K.Simpson and H.Shaw. Theory being that Kelly, Holman, and Finlayson can keep 3 mid spots warm for the gifts that are the premos that are due for a dip in price so soon ie Zerrett, Crouch and Zorko (though Zorko might make way for getting Danger in asap). Thoughts?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

As a Hurn owner from many seasons past, long long before Here2tellyouwhy was a glimmer in his old mans eye, be wary of a forward tag on him.

He will reward you but he can frustrate you. Beauty is he won’t need many touches to knock up 80-90’s

But be prepared for the 60’s as well

 

[Raveneyes]

Menegola OUT
H.Clark OUT

Have $1,025,000 to spend on a forward and a mid.
Have the best rookies, missing only both Fogs and Barry.
Have Danger/Dusty, missing Titch.
Have Billings/Walters/D.Smith as my forwards.

Feel like a kid in a toy shop with this cash to spend.

Holding Hibberd.

 

[Heritier 09]

What are peoples thoughts on Luke Ryan?

 

[Spacedog]

Any ideas what to do? Before Sicily got suspended I wanted to go Hibberd to Bonner and Brayshaw to Coniglio. Now with sicily missing next week I dont really want to have 5 rookies on the field down back. Plus ZLG is out and I probably should trade him to garlett for cash generation.

Option 1:
Hibberd to Bonner
Brayshaw/Barry to Coniglio

Option 2:
Hibberd to Simpson/Heater/Ryan
Naughton to Bonner

Option 3:
ZLG to Garlett
Hibberd to Simpson/Heater/Ryan

Option 4:
No trades

I have 83,300 in the bank

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Menegola OUT
H.Clark OUT

Have $1,025,000 to spend on a forward and a mid.
Have the best rookies, missing only both Fogs and Barry.
Have Danger/Dusty, missing Titch.
Have Billings/Walters/D.Smith as my forwards.

Feel like a kid in a toy shop with this cash to spend.

Holding Hibberd.

I think you just miss out on Titch/ Taranto don't you?

 

[Spacedog]

What are peoples thoughts on Luke Ryan?

He's a good pick. He will score well most weeks. Lots of kicks and marks.

 

[Turkeltone]

Thoughts on westhoff? Port look like they will win a lot of games and he has added ruck responsibilities with Ryder out. I think he is the real deal but I’m afraid I might be chasing points.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Thoughts on westhoff? Port look like they will win a lot of games and he has added ruck responsibilities with Ryder out. I think he is the real deal but I’m afraid I might be chasing points.

***without checking*** Always seems to start well but then falls away as the season progresses... could be wrong though.

 

[Turkeltone]

***without checking*** Always seems to start well but then falls away as the season progresses... could be wrong though.

Yeah I remember one year where he was up over 600k and then died in the ass

 

[balmainforever]

Am I being stupid here with the thinking of Caddy to Taranto?

 

[Donkey Magoo]

Hey Homies,

My only move from the year this far is MCrouch to Dusty.
Should I neck any of the rookies?

 

[arsene wenger1]

Hibberd for coniglio done.........until I reverse it tomorrow

 

[Spacedog]

Hey Homies,

My only move from the year this far is MCrouch to Dusty.
Should I neck any of the rookies?

Mills to Luke Ryan

 

[Judd_Magic]

Am I being stupid here with the thinking of Caddy to Taranto?

Hang on, just consulting the Judd_Magic 8 ball.....

 

[Spacedog]

Am I being stupid here with the thinking of Caddy to Taranto?

Do you have McLean? If yes then do the trade, otherwise get Mclean

 

[DERIBERATE]

View attachment 478586

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/68–95–99.7_rule

Won't find me trading in a KPF who scored 180 in a hurry.

Or in the same year, for that matter.

 

[Beardown1023]

Holding Hibbo

going by this thread, he'll be a nice POD next week

Thanks campaigners

A BPOD maybe

 

[Beardown1023]

Don't use these guys they're going bust!t

Having thought long and hard about Aaron Naughton who has performed poorly thus far, perhaps it might be worth holding onto him for a couple of reasons.

i) No other likely replacements - No other rookies are really available in defence. Most people who played it smartly already have Doedee, Murray, Finlayson &/or Bonner.

ii) He is a rookie with a low break even - With a break even of 25, surely, surely SURELY the kid can reach that? Should only go up in price if he manages to hit that magical 25.

iii) Not a starting rookie - Most people are likely going with two or three of the aforementioned rookies on the field already. His scores are unlikely to count towards your weekly score. Sure, he wont be a dominant scoring rookie but a nice little cash cow until we have a viable option.

iv) With the mounting injury crisis at the Bulldogs Naughton is likely to play 10+ games and earn us a handy enough $40,000.



Now if we see a more viable rookie option becomes available (looks at Lachlan Murphy who's job security is still questionable imho, Ed Richards come on down) then sure, bye bye Aaron but at this early stage of the season might actually be worth saving the trade with no other direct replacement available.

That all depends. What are you planning to do with your 40k you've made over the next 8 weeks?

If he averages a generous 50ppg from here till round 12, he makes you 79k.
He may be worth holding onto this week but certainly not long term. The sooner the better

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hang on, just consulting the Judd_Magic 8 ball.....

So that's how you do your trades .
But when you ask magic 8 ball she yes yes to every trade .