Rounds 11, 12 & 13 - Trades

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Round 12 Trades

You could go worse, but i'd probably look at someone like Gilbee, Gilbert, Fisher or Duffield instead. Do you really need to trade out Maguire anyway?


Here's my backline:
Goddard, Hodge, Enright, Goodwin, H.Shaw, Kennelly, Maguire (Silvagni, Davis)

Only got 5 trades, so pretty reluctant to trade but, if i downgrade Howlett > Gysberts,
I can then upgrade Davis to a premium backman, such as Gilbee and my backline is pretty well sorted, with Maguire and Silvagni as cover. This kind of cover would mean no more messin with the backline at all, but a bit iffy about having someone like Maguire on the bench though...

What d'ya reckon?
Trade like this, or just sit still and wait for rnd 19?
*I am planning on upgrading Maguire anyway just before finals, if not hit too bad by injuries

We've got pretty similar backlines/situation.

U Goddard, Hodge, Enright, Goodwin, Shaw, Kennelly, Maguire Emg = Davis, silvangi

Me Goddard, Gilbee, Enright, Goodwin, Malceski, Kennelly, Maguire, Emg = Davis, Webberly

U have 5 trades. I have 6.

U could potentially plan on upgrading Davis. I could potentially upgrade Maguire.

:D

I'm going to do everything I can to keep from going below 5 trades for MANY weeks. It just seems too dangerous being where we are at at the moment. :D

I'm nervous about having both Kennelly and Maguire in the defence as injuries could continue to pop up over the run home. Thats why I'm thinking a Scotland. Consistent, and doesn't appear to be injury prone. Touch wood.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Davis > Rookie
Martin > Judd/ Montagna

Is it worth it, I still have 10 trades left and if Davis is out for an extended period. (Still have cover for Maguire down back as well.)

Second choice is, Judd or Montagna?

Anyone?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: Round 12 Trades

Glad I didn't just waste 2 hours of my life writing that thesis you wrote before and researched all those averages. Your days must be really forfilling. :eek:

Forfilling? Your education level is fairly minimal one would assume from this comment.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades


Id go Montagna, Saints have a fairly cruisy run home and he can score big tons. Judd can too but I'm not sure who Carlton play during SC finals I have a feeling they might have some tough games, whereas Saints play a lot of games at Etihad late in the season.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Forfilling? Your education level is fairly minimal one would assume from this comment.

but i bet hes got a higher ranking man ROFL!!!!:D:):eek::D You cant handle the might of judd_magic LMAAAOOOOOO :eek::thumbsu::thumbsu::thumbsu: HE LOVES TO TRADE:p:p;) i dont think the education system forfilled its duties ROFL:eek::D:):p

and yes before people ask i am joking.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

In my first season I did that a once or twice, traded after someone had a bad game or two.

You learn pretty quickly that trades are like gold!

Now that you have bought Fev in, I wouldn't go and trade him straight back out. And if you could get Ablett without trading out other premiums I'd say go for it.
Ok, so i just thought of this trade.
Phil davis >>> Rookie
Martin >>> Ablett
Thoughts?
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

is it worth jumping off higgins? i have have watts who could be cover but havent been happy with higgins' scores lately
would go to most likely Goodes or Waite
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Ok, so i just thought of this trade.
Phil davis >>> Rookie
Martin >>> Ablett
Thoughts?

Now that Scooter is a good trade.

Big question is....which rookie. Sorry but I dont have an answer for you. You may find out today when teams are listed.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

lol yeah thats going to be an issue, maybe Ash Smith from WCE, chance to debut this week? Also i have maguire, trade him out for a rookie and put davis/sheppard onto the field?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: Round 12 Trades

My Team
11 Trades Left - $192k in bank.

Am thinking Howlett --> Gysberts definately this week.

Any suggestions on my second trade?

Looking to get sandi and ablett as priorities... also tempted with balla to leon davis this week or next week..

team-1.jpg
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

My team is def- Goddard, hodge, malceski, Gilbert, Enright, fisher, mcguire (sheppard, shoenmakers) mid- ablett, j selwood, m Murphy, barlow, Sylvia, Burgoyne (Rohan, morabito) ruck- sandilands, natanui (warnock, grimley) for- chapman, brown, hall, didak, podsiadly, Franklin, fyfe (Peterson, watts) my team is almost complete although I don't have much back up in the ruck division, I have 6 trades left and the only I want to bring in is pavlich, the question is should I wait for sylvia to go up in price and pavlich drop and use 1 trade or trade morabito for gysbert and then bring in pavlich for Sylvia when I can afford him but then I will use 2 trades what does everyone think?
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

I enjoy Judd Magics comments. Does know how to play the game, however, I do like PK Le Grand's team and think that he will beat him easily (Sorry mate). Hurn will beat Waters. Selwood and Dal = no difference. Goodes will beat Fyfe. How many trades does PK have JM? If he has more than you, it will be tough!

On a side note, I have 4 different players to PK, and have slipped out of the top 1000 for the first time this week.

Just hits home how much Higgins, Tippett, Clark, Gilbee hurt compared to his : Maguire, Chapman, Cox, Franklin.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

My Team
11 Trades Left - $192k in bank.

Am thinking Howlett --> Gysberts definately this week.

Any suggestions on my second trade?

Looking to get sandi and ablett as priorities... also tempted with balla to leon davis this week or next week..

team-1.jpg
Maybe Hille to sandi this week and then go martin to ablett in the next week or so, because its the cheapest he may be in a while.. Ballantyne to someone looks good in the next few as well. I wish I had your amount of trades left :)

For me, Maguire and Jonathon Brown with Webberly or sheppard covering maguire while he is out OR Rockliffe and Shaw??
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Anyone else think Judd Magic and paulkelly/PK Le Grand should take their little bitch fight elsewhere?

Just throwing it out there
It's not quite as bad as the JM vs 6#MW shit fight of early 2009 but something tells this one could get worse if one of the starts sliding down the ladder.
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Forfilling? Your education level is fairly minimal one would assume from this comment.


I made a typo big deal. :rolleyes:

Won't be the first, won't be the last from anyone around here.

The way you talk its like you haven't made a typo before? Show us your degree in brain surgery then you rocket scientist. :eek:
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

It's not quite as bad as the JM vs 6#MW shit fight of early 2009 but something tells this one could get worse if one of the starts sliding down the ladder.


Ah the glory years. LOL! :D:thumbsu:

Well the only way is up for me. I intend to be top 100 this week. Pk whats his name has been lucky so far, I'm just waiting for his wheels to fall off.

If I had of taken it more seriously and not mucked around with non Ablett captain choices the first few rounds I would most likely be higher in the rankings than him. FACT!

Lucky for him....
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

I enjoy Judd Magics comments. Does know how to play the game, however, I do like PK Le Grand's team and think that he will beat him easily (Sorry mate). Hurn will beat Waters. Selwood and Dal = no difference. Goodes will beat Fyfe. How many trades does PK have JM? If he has more than you, it will be tough!

On a side note, I have 4 different players to PK, and have slipped out of the top 1000 for the first time this week.

Just hits home how much Higgins, Tippett, Clark, Gilbee hurt compared to his : Maguire, Chapman, Cox, Franklin.

Thanks for the kind words, I'll mention you in my speech if I win the $50,000. :D:thumbsu:

Well I have beaten PK twice already which is no fluke. Once in the finals last season and once this season.

People keep underestimating me but I keep proving them wrong. I like being the underdog and flying under the radar, suits me fine. :thumbsu:
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

but i bet hes got a higher ranking man ROFL!!!!:D:):eek::D You cant handle the might of judd_magic LMAAAOOOOOO :eek::thumbsu::thumbsu::thumbsu: HE LOVES TO TRADE:p:p;) i dont think the education system forfilled its duties ROFL:eek::D:):p

and yes before people ask i am joking.


Gave me a laugh. Liked the use of all the emotions too, good touch! :thumbsu:
 
Re: Round 12 Trades

Ah the glory years. LOL! :D:thumbsu:

Well the only way is up for me. I intend to be top 100 this week. Pk whats his name has been lucky so far, I'm just waiting for his wheels to fall off.

If I had of taken it more seriously and not mucked around with non Ablett captain choices the first few rounds I would most likely be higher in the rankings than him. FACT!

Lucky for him....

Top 100 this week i admire your optimism Judd_Magic, It will be interesting to see if you can maintain that position tho with so few trades and poor depth on your benches IMO.

That said if you can keep your best 22 on the field u wont have too worry too much i suppose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top